3 ms·
From another IoT comment [0] that I just posted: • Develop a standard interface/protocol for integrating IoT devices with the major mobile operating systems:
by Razengan 10y ago
From another IoT comment [0] that I just posted:
• Develop a standard interface/protocol for integrating IoT devices with the major mobile operating systems:
• Upon unboxing an IoT device and first power-on, require physical contact (via NFC?) with user's primary smartphone/wearable, and register the device with the user's third-party cloud account (e.g. Apple's iCloud/HomeKit).
• Only allow control of the IoT device from the smartphones/wearables that are signed into the user's iCloud/Google/Microsoft/etc. account.
• Web interfaces for IoT control should require two-factor authentication on the user's smartphone/wearable, again like the web interfaces for iCloud/Google/Microsoft accounts.
• Expose a different set of controls based on the user's physical distance from the IoT device, and the level of authentication on the controlling phone/wearable. For example: To unlock your front door you'd have to be standing right there (similar to unlocking a MacBook with the Apple Watch) but you could turn the lights on/off from across the world if you've unlocked your phone and entered your iCloud/Google/Microsoft password – and only from that phone.
• Sharing control with spouses/family could be similar to how Family Sharing for the App Store currently works; set a level of access on each IoT device for each member, and fallback on asking the family "admins" for permission.
No doubt there must be some non-apparent holes in this, but just throwing an idea out there.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14077965 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14077965
- kbart 10y ago" Upon unboxing an IoT device and first power-on, require physical contact (via NFC?) with user's primary smartphone/wearable, and register the device with the user's third-party cloud account (i.e. Apple's iCloud/HomeKit)." Sorry, you lost me here. The last thing we need right now is another database of users' personal information. Why every gadget should be attached to my personal phone? "Only allow control of the IoT device from the smartphones/wearables that are signed into the user's iCloud/Google/Microsoft/etc. account." No again. It's enough Google owns my phone and email, I don't want it to own my home. What happens when Google's algorithm decides to ban you for no apparent reason (there are plenty of such horror stories around)? Tl;DR if that's the price to pay for IoT security, I'm resorting back to "dumb" devices or going to live in woods.
- Razengan 10y agoThat is sort of similar to how Apple's Continuity/Handoff/etc. currently works though, isn't it? Your iDevices, once registered on the same iCloud account, just talk to themselves, without needing to tell or ask Apple anything, other than just checking that you've signed into the same iCloud account.
- kbart 10y agoI don't use Apple products, so can't comment on how that works, but Apple is a rare company that owns it all: hardware, software, support, so the hardest part of any solution -- agreement of different parties -- disappears.
- Klathmon 10y agoI like some of these ideas, mainly because they aren't "absolutist". One of the major problems I've seen again and again (especially on this site) is people saying things like "these devices should be 100% local". That's not realistic. It seems like many attempts to improve the situation are met with hostility that they aren't "perfect" and the people trying to help lose interest because they are being fought on all sides.