3 ms·
The above comment is a ghostly gray right now. Why? cyanotic is merely stating a conjecture out loud. There's nothing rude in the comment, it's not attacking yo
by Razengan 10y ago
The above comment is a ghostly gray right now. Why? cyanotic is merely stating a conjecture out loud. There's nothing rude in the comment, it's not attacking your favorite company/paradigm/X and he even concedes to the "default"/"correct" opinion at the end.
Why downvote that? Are we Reddit now?
- te_chris 10y agoNo, hence the downvotes. His comments belong among the conspiracy theorists over at reddit, always ready with a few tea-leaves to read.
- Razengan 10y agoSo we're punishing thinking? > conspiracy theorists ... always ready with a few tea-leaves to read. That's how you see it. I didn't see that comment as a "conspiracy theory." It wasn't a rambling rant. I'd say you're always ready to see everyone as a conspiracy theorist if they don't parrot the default explanation. In any case, remember that people voicing concerns about widespread government snooping were shut down and derided as "conspiracy theorists" barely 10 years ago.
- alphapapa 10y agoHonestly, more than 50% of the downvoted comments I see on HN do not deserve to be downvoted. Less than half of them are rule-breaking, rude, useless, etc. Frankly, downvoting here has become just as bad as on Reddit: it happens because people don't like the comment for any reason, including, e.g. that what they had for lunch is giving them indigestion at the moment they lay eyes on it (but mostly it's because they simply disagree, which is shameful). This particular comment is full of speculation, but it's not unreasonable speculation, and the linked article gives no details to contradict it. I wish we could have an interesting discussion about what might be, rather than mindlessly censor it by downvoting so that we can only have approved conversations. This just reinforces my conclusion that the only kind of voting should be upvoting. If a comment breaks a rule, flag it, otherwise leave it alone, and concentrate on upvoting good comments. This shaming-by-graying is becoming very tiresome. It's ridiculous that it only takes a few random downvoters to turn a comment gray, because it's not an indication of what the community as a whole thinks, only those who happened to downvote it (after which the likelihood of it being upvoted by people who do like it diminishes, because it being downvoted decreases the likelihood of anyone seeing it). TLDR: Voting on HN is badly broken. It only takes a few selfish, childish people to kill comments and prevent the community from even having a chance to correct the downvotes.
- gus_massa 10y agoYou can see [dead] comments if you enable the show-dead flag in your profile. Also, you can vouch a [dead] comment to revive it. (You need to have a minimal amount of karma for this.) And if you see something egregious, you can send an email to the mods hn@ycombinator.com
- alphapapa 10y agoI've had show-dead on for a long time, and I use custom CSS [1] which even makes dead posts stand out more. The downvote abuse here is ubiquitous. The mods don't care, I supposed because 'pg decreed long ago that downvoting for disagreement is acceptable. The finger-wagging of the invisible hand is working as intended. That doesn't make it right. 1: https://github.com/alphapapa/solarized-everything-css/blob/master/css/solarized-hackernews-dark.css https://github.com/alphapapa/solarized-everything-css/blob/m...
- najajomo 10y ago@alphapapa: 'Honestly, more than 50% of the downvoted comments I see on HN do not deserve to be downvoted'.. They've even downvoted that comment :)
- alphapapa 10y agoAs expected.