4 ms·
I don't believe the idea was to make money at that time. It was to avoid a run on the banks and a repeat of 1929. I am not convinced the economy would have been
by cm2187 10y ago
I don't believe the idea was to make money at that time. It was to avoid a run on the banks and a repeat of 1929. I am not convinced the economy would have been better off. In those days you had pretty much one major bank failing every week.
- blowski 10y agoSo why not make the change explicitly? I'm not against a change in the rate of LIBOR, nor am I against people making profits, as long as it's done fairly.
- cm2187 10y agoAgain, not profits, collapse of the financial system. The problem was: how do you combat fear? The LIBOR submissions were pretty transparent and investors were using it as a way to guess which banks would be the next to fail. I guess the BoE either thought they needed a short term solution / didn't have the time or appetite to change the way LIBOR was submitted. Or they thought that if they were hidding individual bank submissions (which they ultimately did), it would only aggravate fear.
- branchless 10y agoNo this is warped. They put profits before stability, then needed low rates forever, then had to lie again.
- al452 10y agoThe LIBOR rates were constructed by the BBA phoning around the banks, and reporting an average of the numbers they came up with. How would the BoE "explicitly" change that? By telling the BBA to lie? I don't imagine you'd find that "fair".
- cm2187 10y agoYeah but they could have requested the BBA not to publish individual contributions. I guess they thought it wouldn't have been enough.
- raesene6 10y agoThe BoE rigging might not have been to make money, but the rigging done by individual traders at the participating banks definitely was.
- cm2187 10y agoYeah but this was an unrelated event, which happened before the financial crisis, and (as far as we know) didn't involve the senior management of either the banks or the BoE.
- raesene6 10y agoGiven the level of compliance & audit work required in the UK FS industry (look for example at the sizes of regulatory and operational risk teams) and the nature of career paths in the industry (senior figures tend to come up from the ranks quite often), I'd have to say I'd be really surprised if no-one in the senior management of affected banks was aware that Libor manipulation occurred. That's not to say that there'll ever be enough evidence to prosecute that awareness, but the idea that they have no idea what goes on at lower levels, and that none of the 2nd/3rd line risk functions or Internal Audit did any work that would have uncovered that activity....
- cm2187 10y agoNo the development of the swap market is quite recent. At the time when senior managemers were traders or sales people, there was no particular incentive for anyone to push libor submissions one way or another (and libor submission was more of a boring routine, the markets only started focusing on them from 2007).
- raesene6 10y agoSo your suggestion is that no-one in any of the risk functions or internal audit functions (or the external auditors of the bank) ever thought to look at Libor in the years from it becoming important until the scandal emerged? And that senior management, who were surely aware that it was now important, never thought about the risk of a rating based on trust being manipulated by people who would profit from that manipulation by receiving increased bonuses? If all that's true, doesn't say a lot for all these very highly paid bank executives does it?