5 ms·
Hey, the big reason to oppose segwit is mostly as a negotiation tactic. Many of the bitcoin developers , small blockers, and the blockstream people really, R
by stale2002 10y ago
Hey, the big reason to oppose segwit is mostly as a negotiation tactic.
Many of the bitcoin developers , small blockers, and the blockstream people really, REALLY want segwit to activate.
They are so desperate to have it, that although they may not explicitly agree to a "compromise" 2MB HF + segwit proposal, they might at the very least not go freaking nuclear or something in their attempts to oppose it.
Segwit is nice, sure. But us big blockers know that if it gets activated now, then we are never going to see big blocks, regardless of how much support we get.
Don't believe me? Just check out some of the stuff that lukejr (the lead bitcoin developer) says.
They explicitly say that it could be decades before any more block size increases come around.
- TD-Linux 10y agolukejr is nowhere near the "lead bitcoin developer". Wladimir van der Laan is the Bitcoin Core maintainer, not lukejr. lukejr even maintains his own fork (Bitcoin Knots) for stuff that didn't make it into Core.
- fpgaminer 10y agoI'm happy to have some big blocker perspective, as I know my comment perhaps paints "Big Blockers" in less than favorable light. Not intentionally. It's a bit hard to be completely fair in a short summary, given the events that have occurred, even though those events are likely not the fault of real big blockers. That said, good technology should _never_ be used as a bartering chip. I think it's hypocritical of any Bitcoin user to be against SegWit for political reasons. From day 1 Bitcoin has suffered of accusations of being used for illegal and evil activities. And from day 1 we, as a community, have had to fend off those claims saying "Yes, it _can_ be used for illegal activities. But that's not what it's about. It's about a revolutionary technology that, for the most part, will be used for good." To block SegWit is to go against that ethos, an ethos so embedded into Bitcoin. It's about technology; about changing the world. SegWit enables so many cool new uses for Bitcoin. Can it be used to create off-chain transactions; something some big blockers are against? Sure. But that's no reason to stop good technology. Just like it was no reason to stop Bitcoin itself, just because it _could_ be used for illegal activities. > 2MB HF + segwit proposal I don't understand that proposal at all. SegWit _is_ an increase in block size, by on average 2MB. So why have the additional hard fork if the block size is already increasing? > Segwit is nice, sure. But us big blockers know that if it gets activated now, then we are never going to see big blocks, regardless of how much support we get. The one good thing to come out of this years long battle in the community, is that ultimately users and miners are in charge. If big blockers wanted big blocks, all they have to do is offer them. Offer real specifications and real code with real tests and real study. To date, I've never seen that from the big blocker camp. I'm not in either camp, really. Small or big. Personally, I think Bitcoin will need to increase block size eventually anyway, whether directly or indirectly. 1MB forever is silly. But nobody has offered a reasonable, long term solution to increasing block size, besides SegWit. Hard forking is very risky. Emergent consensus is risky. All the big block supporting altcoins I've seen are cobbled together messes. And I'm not speaking as a user; I'm speaking as someone who writes code for a living, implemented the foundation of all modern mining ASICs, and have dealt with the Bitcoin Core code specifically as well.
- stale2002 10y ago2MB HF + segwit (2MB average) adds up to 4 MB total. 4MB forever is better than 2Mb forever. If this whole debate really is because of soft fork is hardfork, that is easy to solve. You can scale by soft forking using extension blocks, OR just by changing the segwit discount parameter that segwit does. If segwit can do it, then so can 4MB segwit.
- midmagico 10y ago> They are so desperate to have it This is completely false. In fact, they're quite honest about the fact they don't mind if it doesn't. Here's an example: https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/617b7h/peter_rizun_the_future_will_look_similar_to_the/dfcdfc5/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/617b7h/peter_rizun... gmax says: "none of us are particular eager to see segwit activate-- we did our part, Bitcoin is just fine without it. -- bitcoin core doesn't even signal it by default, though I suppose the next version probably will." > They explicitly say that it could be decades before any more block size increases come around. Since nobody can predict the future by more than a few months, and most people know this, you should probably cite this. I'm pretty sure nobody has said that it will be decades before a hardfork. In fact, most people have been quite forthright in that a good hardfork is something they are looking forward to. lol