3 ms·
It is nice to see someone dig deeply into what the numbers actually mean, but it is surprising to see them come away with the wrong conclusions. The DOW isn't
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
It is nice to see someone dig deeply into what the numbers actually mean, but it is surprising to see them come away with the wrong conclusions.
The DOW isn't useless, look at this graph : https://www.google.com/finance?chdnp=1&chfdeh=0&chdet=1491778123622&chddm=502044&cmpto=INDEXDJX:.DJI;INDEXSP:.INX;INDEXNASDAQ:.IXIC&cmptdms=0;0;0&q=INDEXDJX:.DJI,INDEXSP:.INX,INDEXNASDAQ:.IXIC&ntsp=0&ei=HbrqWMm9N8TxjAHv6bvIDg https://www.google.com/finance?chdnp=1&chfdeh=0&chdet=149177... which is a comparison of the DOW, S&P and NASDAQ indices. Note how closely the DOW and S&P 500 track each other? If the DOW was 'useless' as the author surmises, and the S&P 500 is 'better' then why are they so closely correlated?
The answer is of course that membership in the DOW (and S&P 500) changes over time. The selection of companies and their weighting is done by people who look at the impact a particular company has and how its stock price 'leads' or 'trails' the market. You pick 30 of those and they become your 'signal' for the health of the market.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoFor short distances, the pre-Newtonian "ball flies straight and then drops vertically when it runs out of oomph" math approximates Newton. It's close enough, except when it matters. Unlike Einstein, those conditions arise regularly. It's as easy to calculate Newton as its predecessors. The predecessor is useless. The Dow and S&P 500 are as easy to access. (They're similarly intensive, with a computer, to calculate.) When they diverge, the S&P tells one more. (The Dow only talks to industry, for which the relevant SPDR is better.) It's uselsss. (We loved it on the trading floor, though. Retail would buy based on the Dow. Free profits.)
- ChuckMcM 10y ago> It's uselsss. (We loved it on the trading floor, > though. Retail would buy based on the Dow. Free > profits.) This is almost like the Yogi-ism "Nobody goes there any more, its too crowded." Because in the same sentence you say "its useless" and "it gives you free profits" (which is useful), much like "nobody goes there" and "its too crowded" (hence lots of people do go there). I don't disagree with the assertion that as a trading signal it is useless, there is much better information around where the market is going right now, or perhaps in the short term future. But as an investing signal it serves the purpose well, with fewer stocks than the S&P 500. My parents for example received an inheritance and wanted to invest it, so I suggested an S&P 500 ETF fund. Doesn't cost anything for them to sit on it and when they hear the radio say "The S&P is up 10% for the year so far" they know that their investments are also up about 10% for the year. For a while I had a DOW basket, actually holding shares in the 30 companies in the index. When the DOW hit an all time high I knew my basket of stocks was worth more (as a group) than they had been in the past. Changes in the index did not cause my parents to make trades, instead they just reflected changes in value of that portion of our investment portfolio. And for that it continues to be useful.
- megablast 10y agoIt is useless in the fact that you can just use the S&P numbers, with no extra cost of downside. If you had a number that almost represented the temperature now, and one that represented it a lot closer, and it was free to use either one, then why use the slightly more error prone one?
- stygiansonic 10y agoYour graph tracks changes over a 3-day period. Look over a 5 or 10 year period and the separation between the DJIA and S&P 500 would be far greater.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoInteresting, the link doesn't go to where I had it set. I had selected 'all' on the top line. It might take a refresh to see it, and it takes the indices from 1970 to the present (approximately) the distance between the S&P and DOW indexes fall on top of each other in that view nearly everywhere.