5 ms·
It’s a similar story as with Firefox and Chrome, and you’re sadly right. The free software community is more than ever before at risk of being replaced by a mo
by kuschku 10y ago
It’s a similar story as with Firefox and Chrome, and you’re sadly right.
The free software community is more than ever before at risk of being replaced by a monopoly culture controlled by large corporations.
- adrianN 10y agoThat's what you get when you prefer programs that are merely open source to free software.
- ymse 10y agoLLVM is free software. The term you are looking for is "copyleft".
- arca_vorago 10y agoExactly. It's like when evaluating things people just completely forget about the implications of the license they use, in both specific and broad contexts. I use and support GPL products as much as possible, even when a BSDesque product may actually have a few advantages. I'm not 100% on that either, but I try hard to slowly adapt and use truly foss software and get used to the ecosystem mentality changes they require. I wish people, particularly devs, thought more about licenses and their long term impact on freedom of the user & dev. I get tired of hearing about how "but copyleft is less free because it restricts me", but to me that's like saying "individual liberty under the rule of law is less free because it prevents me from punching that dude in the face". It's some strange form of anarchism argumentation that fails to respect the rights of others. With all the security issues cropping up lately, I think it should be obvious to big picture thinkers that, while not the solution in itself, any real forward thinking solutions for cyber-security must focus on keeping black boxes out of the picture. BSD style licenses are dangerous to me because they allow hard working peoples code to be abused and used for abuse of others. To be fair to this particular argument though, LLVM does fall under the LSCA license which is gpl compatible, it simple isn't copyleft, so my above rant is more a general comment than on the topic of clang.
- cat199 10y agoCopyleft software presumes software exists in a vaccum where money and funding aren't an issue in other areas of society.. If everything in computer software is copylefted, the status quo in the rest of the non-software economy persists. Further, examples of AGPL 'free software' for the web backed by the dominant cloud service provider essentially give them an unlimited monopoly on that particular service, since, as copyright holder, they will be the only party able to create a proprietary fork which is better than the competition.. More philosophically: The spirit of the law is always greater than the law itself..
- cyphar 10y ago> If everything in computer software is copylefted, the status quo in the rest of the non-software economy persists. If every free software project was copylefted, it would be effectively impossible for any company that is smaller than Apple to maintain everything they need to make software proprietary. Want font rendering? Reimplement libharfbuzz. Want to write any C program? Reimplement glibc. And so on. > Further, examples of AGPL 'free software' for the web backed by the dominant cloud service provider essentially give them an unlimited monopoly on that particular service, since, as copyright holder, they will be the only party able to create a proprietary fork which is better than the competition.. Only if they have a CLA or don't accept any contributions. I can't think of any examples of such AGPL projects, but even with the GPL such projects are quite rare (and CLAs like the FSF actually don't allow them to create proprietary forks). You're just spreading FUD, please stop.
- arca_vorago 10y ago>it would be effectively impossible for any company that is smaller than Apple to maintain everything they need to make software proprietary. Why does it need to be proprietary in the first place though. I feel like the arguments I am hearing are making assumptions about the desired outcome to support their reasoning.
- cyphar 10y ago
- Sylos 10y agoOpen-source means the exact same thing as free software, there's just an ideological difference between the two. https://opensource.org/osd https://opensource.org/osd
- cyphar 10y agoIt definitely does not mean the same thing, the OSD is not congruent to the four freedoms. They have significant overlap, but they are not equal sets.[1] As a dumb example, the Open Watcom license is an "open source" license but is not a free software license because it is too restrictive. In the Open Watcom instance, the OSD does not protect the freedom for users to have private copies of software, the four freedoms do (or at least the modern interpretation does). There's also the whole TiVo thing, where the modern interpretation of freedom 0 is restricted by DRM while "open source" software does not have any problems with DRM restricting users. [1]: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point....
- Sanddancer 10y agoIt's more at risk because they have lost sight of what people want. Firefox muddled itself with a halfassed phone project, a programming language, etc, instead of making a good browser, while google poured efforts into making chrome fast and less prone to crashes taking out everything. It's only natural then that they'd lose market share. Free isn't Good Enough, it has to work well too.
- caf 10y agoThere's something about a near-duopoly in technical fields that seems to encourage camps of dedicated partisans. In addition to GCC/clang and Firefox/Chrome already mentioned, think Microsoft/Apple, Intel/AMD, nvidia/AMD, Boeing/Airbus, Playstation/XBOX...