5 ms·

Review my webapp (#2): sharebookbox.com

2 points by lkozma 16y ago

I have this small side-project: a widget for book collections linking to Amazon, targeted primarily at non-technical users. It is quite trivial, originally I coded it in a weekend to learn some javascript, but it was picked up by a few users (mostly schools and libraries), and I would like to improve it. I would be curious what features would it need to have to make it more usable, how could the design be improved. If someone uses similar widgets, what features are those missing? Last time I asked for feedback, someone suggested that it should allow people to plug in their own amazon-id. That is allowed now, so users can actually make money with the widget. What else is missing? link: sharebookbox.com in use (my own page): www.lkozma.net

mikeleeorg 16y ago
Clickable link: http://sharebookbox.com/ http://sharebookbox.com/ Nice widget! For the UI, consider making the steps the user should take to create the widget more clear. You could have "Step 1", "Step 2", "Step N" spelled out, for instance. Also, I wasn't sure why I needed to enter in a password to get the widget code. To me, a password means a user account is involved somehow, though that's clearly not the case here. Perhaps the word "password" could be replaced. Or an explanation can be offered. I applaud the effort to learn JavaScript. It's a good language to know. Although many embeddable widgets also use document.write like you do, this has some performance implications. Here's an article with more info about that: http://www.schillmania.com/content/entries/2009/defer-script-loading/ http://www.schillmania.com/content/entries/2009/defer-script... Google Analytics recently implemented a performance improvement that's related to this issue: http://searchengineland.com/google-analytics-releases-new-faster-tracking-code-42367 http://searchengineland.com/google-analytics-releases-new-fa... For further JavaScript geekery, you can consider something similar. Lastly, you can try that pop-up layer from KISSinsights (http://www.kissinsights.com/ http://www.kissinsights.com/) that's been popping up (no pun intended) on various sites lately. It's basically a survey with which you can ask your audience whatever questions you'd like. Perhaps you can get some more feedback that way. And Andrew Warner from Mixergy reported that it gave more feedback than GetSatisfaction.com: http://mixergy.com/kissinsights-so-far/ http://mixergy.com/kissinsights-so-far/ I hope this helps. Good luck!
- lkozma 16y ago
  Thanks, very good suggestions. Also I'll look into the deferred javascript trick.

2 points by lkozma 16y ago

mikeleeorg 16y ago

Clickable link: http://sharebookbox.com/ http://sharebookbox.com/ Nice widget! For the UI, consider making the steps the user should take to create the widget more clear. You could have "Step 1", "Step 2", "Step N" spelled out, for instance. Also, I wasn't sure why I needed to enter in a password to get the widget code. To me, a password means a user account is involved somehow, though that's clearly not the case here. Perhaps the word "password" could be replaced. Or an explanation can be offered. I applaud the effort to learn JavaScript. It's a good language to know. Although many embeddable widgets also use document.write like you do, this has some performance implications. Here's an article with more info about that: http://www.schillmania.com/content/entries/2009/defer-script-loading/ http://www.schillmania.com/content/entries/2009/defer-script... Google Analytics recently implemented a performance improvement that's related to this issue: http://searchengineland.com/google-analytics-releases-new-faster-tracking-code-42367 http://searchengineland.com/google-analytics-releases-new-fa... For further JavaScript geekery, you can consider something similar. Lastly, you can try that pop-up layer from KISSinsights (http://www.kissinsights.com/ http://www.kissinsights.com/) that's been popping up (no pun intended) on various sites lately. It's basically a survey with which you can ask your audience whatever questions you'd like. Perhaps you can get some more feedback that way. And Andrew Warner from Mixergy reported that it gave more feedback than GetSatisfaction.com: http://mixergy.com/kissinsights-so-far/ http://mixergy.com/kissinsights-so-far/ I hope this helps. Good luck!

lkozma 16y ago
Thanks, very good suggestions. Also I'll look into the deferred javascript trick.