6 ms·
NeXTSTEP seems to have been far ahead of Windows 95 too. I wonder how far Microsoft would have gotten if Steve Jobs hadn't left Apple for a while. [0] https://
by Razengan 10y ago
NeXTSTEP seems to have been far ahead of Windows 95 too. I wonder how far Microsoft would have gotten if Steve Jobs hadn't left Apple for a while.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NeXTSTEP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NeXTSTEP
Bonus irony: The pioneering PC games Wolfenstein 3D, Doom (with its WAD level editor), Doom II, and Quake (with its respective level editor) were developed by id Software on NeXT machines.
- QSIITurbo 10y agoApple would've gone nowhere with their pricing with NeXT. NeXT station was basically a Silicon Graphics workstation for developers and cost 8000, about four times as much as a high-end gaming PC that would run Win31 Word and Excel with no problems. So not a computer for the masses. I see the pricing problem happening to OS X at the moment. MS has excelled in getting price, (backwards) compatibility and system requirements correctly. That's why they moved slowly at the time and still do in some regards. OS/2 was merged into Windows NT which is what almost everyone is using on desktop these day. IBM even tried giving OS/2 for free (Warp or 2.1, can't remember, you could get it by sending a coupon to the publisher), but the lack of compatibility and system requirements killed it. I remember booting it on a 486/33 + 8MB, yuck. Contrast that to almost instant startup of DOS and the requirements of an ordinary user. Also, IBM sold PS/2 (or something like that) with OS/2 preinstalled... It booted like forever and there was zero software available for the home-user.
- pjmlp 10y ago> Also, IBM sold PS/2 (or something like that) with OS/2 preinstalled... It booted like forever and there was zero software available for the home-user. And was like 500 € (on today's money) more expensive than a PC compatible with similar specs.
- brudgers 10y agoThe big thing the PS/2 had going at introduction was 80386 chips. The big limitation over the long term for consumers was MicroChannel which limited flexibility in configuring systems due to fewer total options; higher prices; and no commodity market for expansion cards.
- JdeBP 10y agoAt https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14024665 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14024665, pjmlp has been propounding the myth that OS/2 required a PS/2. This is a myth, untrue of any version. I am surprised to see it still around, a quarter century or more after it was debunked.
- pjmlp 10y agoMyth or not, in 1992 on my hometown it was only possible to get legal OS/2 2.0 copies when buying a PS2. Only one IBM dealer was selling PS2 with them. OS/2 2.0 wasn't nowhere else to be found and I didn't knew anyone to get me a pirate copy of OS/2 2.0 just to try it out on a PC clone. So regardless of you calling me a liar, in 1992 on a small Portuguese town, getting OS/2 2.0 on a legal way, required buying a PS2 with it bundled at the local IBM dealer. And for what I could remeber it was pretty much like that across the country until OS/2 Warp got released.
- JdeBP 10y agoOne IBM dealer not being willing/permitted to sell you OS/2 pre-loaded on anything other than a PS/2 is a very different thing to OS/2 requiring a PS/2. That you continue to conflate the twain is an error, and a repetition of a long since debunked myth. This was written in 1995, and was far from the first debunking of this myth: * http://www.mit.edu/activities/os2/faq/os2faq0201.html http://www.mit.edu/activities/os2/faq/os2faq0201.html The unwillingness of that one IBM dealer was almost certainly far more to do with the structures of the Microsoft licensing deals for pre-loaded systems than any mythical requirement of a PS/2. This came to light some years later; around the time of the US DOJ anti-trust case. To learn how for a quarter of a century you've erroneously been ascribing things to the myth that OS/2 required a PS/2 when in fact your one IBM dealer was merely part of a larger and complex picture of licensing deals and royalty payments involving pre-loading Windows on IBM machines versus pre-loading anything else, start here: * http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/368660.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/368660.stm * http://www.theregister.co.uk/1999/06/04/ibm_witness_the_inside_poop/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/1999/06/04/ibm_witness_the_insi... There is a lot more to read than just those two, of course.
- 52-6F-62 10y ago"...for the home-user." I think that says it all right there. In 1994 I was still very young, learning DOS on my mother's old 80286 she'd purchased for work in the mid 80's. I'd had some exposure to Win3.1, but Windows 95 was when I thought the future had arrived. I was ignorant; but it was more highly polished (than Win3), just looked easier, and it had much greater market exposure because of the business world. It had a few stupid games, could still run most DOS applications (at my age, games), and a clean up of the skeuomorphism that had arrived in the other OS's at the time. Everybody knew what NOTEPAD.EXE did. Sure you could say the same for Mac, NeXT, OS/2, and pretty much whatever GUI was popping its head up at the time, or eventually.... but my parents didn't know what a Mac was. They weren't cool. Or wealthy. Queue: what's available for purchase for uncool people in rural Canada who still have technological wants.... and nothing. Getting that price point down was key in pervading such a wide variety of demographics in the marketplace, and getting the home, unwitting user, hooked; for better or for worse.
- chiph 10y ago> OS/2 was merged into Windows NT Sortof yes, sortof no. Microsoft's relationship with IBM was damaged by this point, and they had hired Dave Cutler to start work on NT in 1988 (the breakup happened in 1990). There were stories about Microsoft starting newly hired engineers on the OS/2 program to get them up to speed on 32-bit event-driven programming, then moving them to NT after IBM effectively paid for their training. You needed an i486 DX2 with at least 8mb and 120mb drive to run OS/2 effectively. This was a high-spec machine back then - not cheap. I still have my OS/2 Warp t-shirt somewhere in the back of the closet...
- ldiracdelta 10y agoDuring my education at the University of Washington, one of the lecturers was on the Microsoft side of the OS/2 development. He said that the relationship drastically soured when some IBM supplied code got passed around with comments by Microsoft employees just mercilessly ripping the IBM code apart. And then it got back to IBM..
- nickpsecurity 10y agoWindows NT was a modified version of OpenVMS done by the OpenVMS team: http://windowsitpro.com/windows-client/windows-nt-and-vms-rest-story http://windowsitpro.com/windows-client/windows-nt-and-vms-re... I'm still looking for how much of OS/2 made it into NT. I know NT had an OS/2 subsystem which is an obvious candidate. What I did find is that Windows NT was developed on OS/2 computers. They also had to be forced to give up OS/2 & dogfood on Windows NT. They didn't want to lol.
- yuhong 10y agoEarly versions of NT supported HPFS, and NT of course still supports EA to this day.
- chungy 10y agoNTFS itself is directly derived from HPFS.
- JdeBP 10y agoNo, it is not. NTFS, if one looks at it, is a direct descendant of Files-11, the on-disc filesystem layout for VMS. ODS has several of the elements of NTFS: * a master file table (INDEXF.SYS => $MFT) * ACLs, with a system of ACL-bypass privileges * a whole bunch of special files, with known fixed entries in the MFT, including a block bitmap file and a bad block file (BITMAP.SYS => $Bitmap, BADBLK.SYS => $BadClus) In contrast, there are significant dissimilarities with HPFS.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThat corroborates my reference a bit where author says they made changes to filesystem during the clone of VMS. There would be similarities between the two filesystems if this were true.
- glhaynes 10y agoSome interesting info on the OS/2 subsystem is here: https://www.microsoft.com/resources/documentation/windowsnt/4/workstation/reskit/en-us/os2comp.mspx?mfr=true https://www.microsoft.com/resources/documentation/windowsnt/.... My favorite part is how NT didn't directly use CONFIG.SYS — but, if you edited C:\CONFIG.SYS from an OS/2 editor, NT would render a "stub" CONFIG.SYS file from the OS/2-specific settings from the Registry; then, when the editor saved the file, it would translate those settings back into appropriate Registry keys! Another interesting tidbit: Up through NT 4.0, Microsoft sold the "Windows NT Add-On Subsystem for Presentation Manager" that let 16-bit OS/2 GUI apps run on NT. So much work went into the OS/2 subsystem, but I can't imagine it was important at all to NT's eventual marketplace success.
- pjmlp 10y agoIf Steve Jobs hadn't left Apple, NeXTSTEP would never exist.
- Razengan 10y agoWouldn't the same ideas just have been incorporated into macOS then?
- pjmlp 10y agoNo, because System 7, Taligent and Copland were quite different than NeXTSTEP.
- Razengan 10y agoI mean, what would have prevented NeXTSTEP from being developed at Apple?
- nickpsecurity 10y agoBackward compatibility or them thinking too alike to have come up with something so different. Plus, they might have bought BeOS. That would've been awesome. We'd have gotten multicore benefits way earlier. Mac OS X server might have also succeeded more given concurrency benefits.
- pjmlp 10y agoThe minds behind NeXT weren't at Apple, Jobs was not alone in this startup. It was the team work of all these people together that brought NeXTSTEP to life. You cannot ignore the human aspect of it. Also Apple never was a UNIX shop, A/UX was just a distraction they never cared much about.
- mtkd 10y agothe siesmic impact of that decision has been kind of lost - iphone etc. all happened because of the moment in time Steve J and others took that decision
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- frik 10y ago> Bonus irony ... were developed ... on ... machines. Bill Gates and Paul Allen originally wrote Altair BASIC using an Intel 8080 emulator running on a PDP-10 at Harvard University. PDP-10 was a mainframe computer by Digital Equipment Corporation (DEC). To develop something ground braking, that is clearly ahead of its time (competition) it helps a lot if you have access to better computer resources than others.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"To develop something ground braking, that is clearly ahead of its time (competition) it helps a lot if you have access to better computer resources than others." Maybe. The reason C and UNIX existed was because they didn't have enough resources to use clearly better languages or OS design. Richards invented the "programmer is in control" philosophy because his crappy ESDAC couldn't run an ALGOL. Chopped off what couldn't fit until he got BCPL. Thompson and Ritchie modified that into C language to work with a PDP-7 and PDP-11. Likewise, after working on MULTICS, Thompson chopped off [good] features of MULTICS trying to fit UNICS, err UNIX, into those same machines. Originally implemented in assembly language since early versions of C were too primitive to get the job done. Final version of C was way less sophisticated than competition doing things like ALGOL or Pascal. Market demand, accessibility, and social effects that cause spreading seem to combine to increase odds of success more than what hardware is available.