4 ms·
It's uncompetitive because the only purpose of doing so is to ensure other less VC-backed companies are driven out of business, creating a monopoly. Which needl
by notahacker 10y ago
It's uncompetitive because the only purpose of doing so is to ensure other less VC-backed companies are driven out of business, creating a monopoly. Which needless to say, isn't good as in the long term for its customer base as nice VC-subsidised rides are in the short term. It's not a charitable endeavour, and they're not subsidising rides out of an intention to extract less profit from the public in the long term.
Calling the banning of a company which has pointedly ignored every law that gets in its way "fascism" is just childish, and when it's referring to a country that actually suffered the results of having a Fascist government, it's offensive childishness.
- patrickaljord 10y agoBut creating laws that favour a few corporations against the benefit of the people is textbook definition of fascism, that's literally fascism. Sorry if quoting definitions is offensive. Also I'm from France and we've suffered from both Nazism and Fascism. About price dumping, this is a myth. When has this ever happened and tell me how could Uber remain a monopoly if its prices are too high? Competitors will show up because there will be good money to be made. The only monopolies that can last despite being overpriced are the ones protected by state violence and state laws that make competition illegal, a good example here would be, I don't know, Italian taxi companies?
- rorykoehler 10y agoWhich corporations are being protected in Italy? As outlined multiple times in this thread all the taxi licenses are owned by individuals. Uber will fail precisely for the reason you pointed out, they will never be able to keep a monopoly. In the mean time though it is not in the interests of society to favour short term gains for the individual in the form of cheap loss leading fares (price dumping... not a myth and widely documented.. how else could Uber be haemorrhaging $1B plus a quarter?) at the expense of mass unemployment and the associated reduced tax receipts that benefit society as a whole. Arguing otherwise is extremely short sighted.
- patrickaljord 10y agoItalians taxi drivers are independents and therefor are single person corporations. Same thing. They offer horrible service and use the law to keep higher quality and lower price competition away. I'm sorry but you don't understand what price dumping is, there is nothing wrong with offering lower prices at a loss, most companies do so to bootstrap or try to get into a market. What you are accusing them is to dump prices and then in the future higher their prices once there is no more competition and then keep a monopoly forever. This part is the myth that _never_ happens, if Uber kills competition and then hikes its prices, competition will come back because there will be a good business opportunity. Again, read this to see how "price dumping" accusations are always about protectionism against better competition and innovation, most economists agree with this, it's one of the oldest tricks of protectionism and mercantilism. Accuse new entrant offering something better at a lower price of just wanting to kill your business and then up their prices, by this logic we would never ever see any price lowering if anyone offering better service and innovation at lower prices was accused of "price dumping". This is what's wrong with Italy (and France), so sad to see so many people falling for these myths that only serve a few corrupt lobbies that are against innovation and competition https://ideas.repec.org/a/ags/ecjilt/23876.html https://ideas.repec.org/a/ags/ecjilt/23876.html
- rorykoehler 10y ago>Italians taxi drivers are independents and therefor are single person corporations. Scraping the barrel there
- patrickaljord 10y agoFavoring a tiny minority against the majority of the people is corporatism/fascism. It doesn't matter what the size of the corporation is, ever heard of corporatism? You're the one scraping the barrel here.
- notahacker 10y agoThe literal definition of fascism is a totalitarian nationalist state which disavows all the principles of liberal democracy and established freedoms, and seeks to compel the public to unwaveringly support its ideology by manipulating public sentiment against dissenters and minority groups portrayed as the enemy. A court ruling that long-established taxi regulations devised by elected officials should be enforceable is not fascism even under the the most tortuous application of the definition. Competitors won't show up if Uber's biggest VC raise in history throws more money at subsidising rides until the competitors go away which is their purpose for doing it (along with other such consumer-hostile strategies as mass hailing and cancellation of competitors' rides). Their entire business strategy is based around ride-hailing being a winner-takes all business; just because it may not succeed doesn't mean that this isn't their objective. Do you honestly believe their VCs are subsidising rides out of the kindness of their hearts?