3 ms·
What they call "unfair competition" is nothing more than not having to pay for a taxi service license that should not be sold that high in the first place becau
by squarefoot 10y ago
What they call "unfair competition" is nothing more than not having to pay for a taxi service license that should not be sold that high in the first place because they're assigned from local municipalities after the driver passes an exam to get the appropriate driving license and other stuff. Unfortunately taxi licenses are assigned very scarcely and the resulting huge disproportion between demand and offer creates a market in which old drivers when retiring sell their ones at absurd prices, that is, even over $200K. Of course license scarcity and the lack of competition means higher fares for customers and higher profits for drivers.
That is ultimately the only one reason why they acted against Uber like they did against other services such as the NCC (rent with driver) which is a workaround to trick the law and get a taxi service disguised as a car rent.
- Markoff 10y agoso Uber should be allow to break the laws to offer lower prices (which is not even true in rush hour), is this what you propose? why not open restaurant chain recycling leftovers from other customers, storing all ingredients without fridge on floor of kitchen with some rats running around BUT hey I am American corporation bringing you cheap food and don't dare to tell me I am unfair competition compared to those dumb local restaurants meeting local hygiene rules
- briandear 10y agoIf people buying the food like the food and know what they're getting, then why should government be involved? Let the people spend their money how they want. If the Italian taxi industry is anything like the Venician gondoliers association, then this ruling has zero to do with safety and everything to do with protectionism.
- Markoff 10y agoif you don't like the law then vote for someone who will change it, not just break it
- Sacho 10y agoThat's a good point that I would agree with, however, I don't think it's applicable here. It's not just Uber customers that pay for the company's services - the Uber "taxis" also use infrastructure that Italian taxpayers have paid for(roads, taxi lanes, etc...I'm not familiar with the Italian situation). In that case, the Italian taxpayers would also have a say in the services provided. But even ignoring that, there is a fundamental contention between state regulation and free markets. It's obvious that Europe in general prefers at least some level of state regulation, and is willing to suffer the market inefficiency for it. Whether that's "good" or "bad" is difficult to determine, but there's certainly a number of arguments that can be made in favor of state-wide rather than piecemeal regulation, e.g. the uneven information relationship between producer and consumer(I'm not really qualified to determine whether the product is safe), the unrealistic time investment for each consumer to verify with an independent agency whether a producer is up to their standards, and so on.
- onion2k 10y agoUnfortunately taxi licenses are assigned very scarcely and the resulting huge disproportion between demand and offer creates a market in which old drivers when retiring sell their ones at absurd prices, that is, even over $200K. That makes it sound like the license acts as a proxy for a pension. If so, $200K is really not absurd at all. That's a very small pension, and Uber's disruption of the market is going to mean a lot of Italian taxi drivers have a horrible time living in poverty in their old age. That's obviously not Uber's fault, but it's understandable that the taxi drivers and the government would be very much against a sudden change to the status quo.
- _joe 10y agoYes. Also, license costs in Italy sunk in the last 15 years anyways, as more of them were granted. Add to that that the license is individual, and you can surely sell it, but just to another person; corporations can't own them and ask for a daily ransom from taxi drivers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Marazan 10y agoWrong, Uber subsidises taxi rides to the tune of billions of dollars. Billions.