3 ms·
Re: Entropy: Note that just adding random padding to packets doesn't actually protect you from this kind of analysis. You'd want a constant bit-rate ("CBR") en
by loeg 10y ago
Re: Entropy: Note that just adding random padding to packets doesn't actually protect you from this kind of analysis. You'd want a constant bit-rate ("CBR") encoding instead. Even with CBR, the exact length of the video might give away the contents too.
From a bandwidth perspective, such CBR encodings are either wasteful or low quality for high motion scenes—or both. So it makes sense that Netflix has chosen a VBR system, but does have this privacy caveat.
- notgood 10y ago> Even with CBR, the exact length of the video might give away the contents too. To avoid that issue you just artificially make multiple movies have the same length, meaning do some padding to round up to the next e.g. 10 minutes (so if the movie is 1:48:23 it becomes 1:50:00), to do so the movie keeps buffering in the background (some random audiovisual noise). Maybe netflix should have a "Fully safe" mode where it uses CBR instead of VBR so the user knows the trade off (slower/heavier buffering)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Franciscouzo 10y agoIt wouldn't work, that sounds like adding sleep calls to prevent timing attacks, which doesn't works... Different bit rates on the random audiovisual noise (white noise would be uncompress-able, thus weight more, pure black would be too compress-able, etc).
- aianus 10y agoWhy wouldn't adding sleep calls help prevent timing attacks? Assuming you're padding all response times to the same total response time.
- MayeulC 10y agoI just want to point out that Signal, the encrypted messaging/voice chat app is using CBR for that reason: it should be possible to reconstruct the words spoken using the metadata that is leaked from a VBR. Of course, that means losing some bandwidth, so it is not the most bandwidth-efficient app. https://whispersystems.org/blog/signal-video-calls-beta/ https://whispersystems.org/blog/signal-video-calls-beta/