3 ms·
Your post is useful to me. It shows me what I am going against. I need to refine my ideas, that's why I am debating them. The difference between people and car
by visarga 10y ago
Your post is useful to me. It shows me what I am going against. I need to refine my ideas, that's why I am debating them.
The difference between people and cars is that people are self replicators, cars need people to create them. So people HAVE to fend for themselves, cars don't. Self replicators have needs - energy, nutrients, cooperation with other agents - and fulfilling these needs require complex actions in a dynamic environment - a role taken by the nervous system.
When I say that consciousness is the thing that protects the body, I say it thinking about evolution, competition and cooperation with other agents for survival and reproduction. Without the ability to adapt, we can't fend for ourselves, and nothing else will protect us, unlike cars.
When you go up from unicellular organisms to mammals, life becomes much more complex and the "ability to adapt" has to become much more powerful, but even cells sense their environment and adapt to situations, even exchange chemical signals between them (communicate), cooperate, fight and so on. So they have a sliver of consciousness.
- hacker_9 10y agoAt some point we will fully automate the creation process. Meaning robots will be able to build robots. I'm still not seeing the need for consciousness here, this is just more advanced mechanical motions and cleverer math. Just because cells adapt doesn't mean they are conscious. They are a bag of chemicals that react to thermal changes and kinetic energy. We have observed that protein nanomachines simply react to changes in their immediate environment [1]. There is no thought process or consciousness required, they are just static machines that take in inputs and perform the same process each time. I think you are conflating the human survival instinct with a need to be conscious. But this is just an inevitable result of evolution; surviving longer means you have more chance of reproducing. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zm-3kovWpNQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zm-3kovWpNQ