5 ms·
Since it is on the list, it cannot be better. Probably the best book on Smalltalk is Smalltalk 80: the language (for some definition of 'best'). It is very rea
by brudgers 10y ago
Since it is on the list, it cannot be better.
Probably the best book on Smalltalk is Smalltalk 80: the language (for some definition of 'best'). It is very readable despite serving as a specification for Smalltalk 80 version 2. It is a revision of the similarly titled: Smalltalk 80: the language and its implementation linked on the list.
The text is clear and professionally edited to a level consistent with the commercial sale of printed books by a reputable technical publisher (Addison Wesley). Used printed copies are widely available and often inexpensive. With the caveat that I vastly prefer dead tree books to PDF's, the physical book is a thing of beauty with the code for the running example printed on the backface of the front cover and the parser state machines printed on the last few pages.
On the other hand, what I appreciate about GNU Smalltalk is:
1. It is text based and while I consider the Smalltalk IDE to be historically interesting, it is the least interesting part of the language for me, today.
2. GNU Smalltalk integrates with Emacs (in Debian it is a separate package gnu-smalltalk-el).
3. I prefer tiling windows to overlapping windows and the keyboard to the mouse and other Smalltalk implementations follow the WIMP paradigm.
4. Though in fairness, I am just goofing around with Smalltalk and if I had production grade concerns, I might have a different attitude.
- Safety1stClyde 10y ago> Since it is on the list, it cannot be better. It might be better, since I did not try all of the books, and I did not specify which of the books I had tried.
- brudgers 10y agoI assumed that the referent for 'the ones I found' was the list. My apologies for the confusion.
- kwhitefoot 10y ago> 4. Though in fairness, I am just goofing around with Smalltalk and if I had production grade concerns, I might have a different attitude. I'm curious, is Smalltalk especially good for any particular task? Or especially easy to use for something? I'm always on the look out for something better as all the languages I use and know well seem inadequate or tedious in one way or another and a lot of those that I don't use seem intimidatingly difficult to get started with (often because ecosystem in which they live is difficult to handle).
- brudgers 10y agoSmalltalk 80: the langauage is formally divided into three parts. The third part is devoted to simulations such as a car rental agency (one of the examples). I was a bit surprised, but then I remembered that Smalltalk's object oriented predecessor was Simula (as in 'simulation'). The code for the simulation examples is compact because Smalltalk includes 'primitives' that are suited for building simulations. From a more mundane language design standpoint, Go's capital/lower syntax for 'public' versus 'private' identifiers in modules mirrors Smalltalk's public/private syntax for object methods/variables.
- gaius 10y agoI'm curious, is Smalltalk especially good for any particular task? Or especially easy to use for something? Have a read of http://www.cincomsmalltalk.com/main/successes/financial-services/jpmorgan/ http://www.cincomsmalltalk.com/main/successes/financial-serv... But then consider that they didn't choose Smalltalk for the next project...
- throwaway7645 10y agoWhat did JPMorgan use for their next project?
- gaius 10y agohttp://techcareers.jpmorgan.com/cm/BlobServer/athena_jpmc.pdf?blobkey=id&blobwhere=1320615212303&blobheader=application/pdf&blobcol=urldata&blobtable=MungoBlobs http://techcareers.jpmorgan.com/cm/BlobServer/athena_jpmc.pd... C++ and Python
- throwaway7645 10y agoYea, I often wonder about this kind of thing. Compared to Fortran, Common Lisp is a tower of power and sorcery, but compared to Python it isn't as impressive. Yes, it is a more powerful language, but the power isn't always worth the learning curve and mostly abandoned libraries. I think Python + C++ seems to be an easy spot marrying rapid prototyping & raw speed when you need it in addition to all the developers you'd get from 2 of the top 5 languages in amount of use. The Smalltalk and Common Lisp ecosystems are pretty similar to me. Both have a few commercial products and a few open source projects and a fairly small and fragmented community despite some commercial success.