5 ms·
Computer Programming Using GNU Smalltalk (2009)
- Safety1stClyde 10y agoI looked at a number of Smalltalk books yesterday after reading a discussion here, but all of the ones I read of the following list were terrible books: http://stephane.ducasse.free.fr/FreeBooks.html http://stephane.ducasse.free.fr/FreeBooks.html I didn't try all of the books. I also tried to read the Wikipedia article on Smalltalk. I consider trying to read a Wikipedia article about anything an act of desperation. Is this book any better than the ones I found yesterday?
- jameskilton 10y agoI haven't read many books on or using Smalltalk, but I can definitely recommend Kent Beck's "Smalltalk Best Practice Patterns" https://www.amazon.com/Smalltalk-Best-Practice-Patterns-Kent/dp/013476904X/ref=sr_1_1 https://www.amazon.com/Smalltalk-Best-Practice-Patterns-Kent...
- smalltalker4 10y agoYes, this book is very good, although its contents does overlap somewhat with Fowler's Refactoring.
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoIf memory serves, the GNU Smalltalk manual is not a bad introduction/tutorial to the language.
- Safety1stClyde 10y agoI found your suggestion valuable.
- brudgers 10y agoSince it is on the list, it cannot be better. Probably the best book on Smalltalk is Smalltalk 80: the language (for some definition of 'best'). It is very readable despite serving as a specification for Smalltalk 80 version 2. It is a revision of the similarly titled: Smalltalk 80: the language and its implementation linked on the list. The text is clear and professionally edited to a level consistent with the commercial sale of printed books by a reputable technical publisher (Addison Wesley). Used printed copies are widely available and often inexpensive. With the caveat that I vastly prefer dead tree books to PDF's, the physical book is a thing of beauty with the code for the running example printed on the backface of the front cover and the parser state machines printed on the last few pages. On the other hand, what I appreciate about GNU Smalltalk is: 1. It is text based and while I consider the Smalltalk IDE to be historically interesting, it is the least interesting part of the language for me, today. 2. GNU Smalltalk integrates with Emacs (in Debian it is a separate package gnu-smalltalk-el). 3. I prefer tiling windows to overlapping windows and the keyboard to the mouse and other Smalltalk implementations follow the WIMP paradigm. 4. Though in fairness, I am just goofing around with Smalltalk and if I had production grade concerns, I might have a different attitude.
- Safety1stClyde 10y ago> Since it is on the list, it cannot be better. It might be better, since I did not try all of the books, and I did not specify which of the books I had tried.
- brudgers 10y agoI assumed that the referent for 'the ones I found' was the list. My apologies for the confusion.
- kwhitefoot 10y ago> 4. Though in fairness, I am just goofing around with Smalltalk and if I had production grade concerns, I might have a different attitude. I'm curious, is Smalltalk especially good for any particular task? Or especially easy to use for something? I'm always on the look out for something better as all the languages I use and know well seem inadequate or tedious in one way or another and a lot of those that I don't use seem intimidatingly difficult to get started with (often because ecosystem in which they live is difficult to handle).
- throwaway7645 10y agoI found the pharo books to be lacking as well in addition to the YouTube videos. It's nice they're there, but I expected more. I wish Richard Eng (Smalltalk evangelist doing a lot of marketing blog posts) would add some videos of creating some simple/small projects using Pharo as well so I can get a better gist of what it's like developing in it. There is a lot there, but I have no way to get at it efficiently. I may have to look at the environment's built-in tutorial again.
- smalltalker4 10y agoPharo By Example was recently updated for Pharo 5: http://files.pharo.org/books/updated-pharo-by-example/ http://files.pharo.org/books/updated-pharo-by-example/ As for that list, Smalltalk-80: the Language and its Implementation (the "blue book") is phenomenal. One of the co-authors is Adele Goldberg herself, and the last few chapters (26-30) contain the blueprint for a basic, canonical VM using Smalltalk itself as the implementation language (referred to as the "blue book VM"). I think The Art and Science of Smalltalk is quite good also, but outdated and VisualWorks-specific. The section on MVC is particularly interesting, especially if your understanding of it was shaped by RoR and other web frameworks.
- agumonkey 10y agoNot a book, but there was a Pharo MOOC on the FUN platform (france université numerique); which was as interesting for the theoritical and the pragmatic side of ST like languages.
- dragonwriter 10y agoNot sure if this is the same course, but: http://files.pharo.org/mooc/ http://files.pharo.org/mooc/
- agumonkey 10y agoYes it is. Didn't know they published it this way. If I may, I didn't like the "we the real OO man, look at our dispatch" feel sometimes. Hubris if you ask me.
- jhbadger 10y agoSmalltalk with Style (one of the books in that page) is actually a really good book on coding style in Smalltalk. I remember reading it and taking its advice about twenty years ago when I was using Smalltalk heavily.
- riffraff 10y agoI seem to remember VisualWorks had a builtin tutorial which was kinda awesome, but I might be having rose tinted memories, it was many years ago.
- dragonwriter 10y agoWhich books did you find, and what did you find "terrible"? It's very hard to suggest books which you might find subjectively superior when you don't identify what you've tried or why you didn't like it or what, specifically, you are looking for.
- analognoise 10y agoI know it's Windows only, but Dolphin Smalltalk is really much more impressive than GNU Smalltalk or Pharo.
- hboon 10y agoFor a long time, Dolphin Smalltalk was a very good Windows development tool, and probably the best Smalltalk. Fast and native UI, wonderful refactoring support, builds to exe, great community.
- analognoise 10y agoIt is now fully open source and on GitHub, too!
- ttflee 10y agoThis site would not render until JavaScript was enabled. EDIT: It seems that NoScript plugin has stopped Firefox from rendering this page where no script is embedded/referred. Probably NoScript blocked XSLT in Firefox.
- userbinator 10y agoInterestingly, the page doesn't claim to be HTML or even XHTML --- it's served with "application/xml" content type, and is pure XML with an XSL that transforms it into HTML in the browser. I don't see that very often.
- Moter8 10y agoThat's amazing :D I browsed the source code and found a lulu tag (?) <lulu url="http://www.lulu.com/content/paperback-book/computer-programming-using-gnu-smalltalk/7746227" /> Apparently it's declared in www.canol.info/xsl/default.xsl <xsl:template match="lulu"> ... </xsl:template>
- ZuLuuuuuu 10y agoYeap, I was looking for a method to seperate content from design without using server side technologies and found this XML + XSL method. It worked quite well actually and still works till this day :) --canol
- noblethrasher 10y agoI also use pure XML/XSLT for one of my production sites. In theory, XSLT is th nicest templating language I've ever used (even the 1.0 version). But, in practice, there are too many inconsistencies among browsers (e.g. in-page JavaScript is difficult because IE’s CDATA handles escaping “<” and “>” differently than Chrome, Firefox, and Safari). Sadly, Google is planning to deprecate and remove the feature[1]. [1] https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/forum/m/#!topic/blink-dev/6MOMhQaX3N8 https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/forum/m/#!topic/bli...
- 10y ago
- bonzini 10y agoWow, seeing this on hackernews made me shed a year. I picked up maintenance of GNU Smalltalk when I was 19 and kept it going for about 11 years. In the meanwhile I wrote thousands and thousands of lines of C and Smalltalk code, a generational and incremental GC, a debugger, a documentation generator, a JIT compiler and whatever else. Maintaining GNU Smalltalk taught me so much about testing, release engineering, C programming, mentoring and almost everything else I learnt about programming during those 11 years.