9 ms·
Airlines Make More Money Selling Miles Than Seats
- jph 10y agoTLDR: Airlines make large profits from the credit card loyalty programs; the specifics are typically hidden from outsiders.
- spoonie 10y agoBeyond the cash, carriers reap something else from the cards: These deals remain lucrative in both good times and bad, as they are immune to economic cycles. That’s because of the addictive nature of miles, a dubious commodity that tens of millions of Americans, particularly those who fly for their jobs, will probably never quit. “In a recession, that [bank] business will go down, but it should provide a very high cushion to the airline,” DeNardi said in an interview. “That’s the real benefit here: It speaks to downside protection for the industry better than anything else.” So they earn money by selling miles to the CC companies who give the miles to customers who spend. So if spending goes down won't there be fewer miles to buy? Or is the point that general spending with CCs isn't correlated with people buying airfares?
- nommm-nommm 10y agoWhen people have money troubles they cut down their spending. Non business airline travel would be an expenses they would cut first. But the airlines are still making money from them even if they aren't travelling because with the cards they still make money from them when they buy food.
- prostoalex 10y agoThe baseline for comparison here is not an airline that is selling an enormous amount of miles to the credit card networks. The baseline is an airline that has no credit card program. If air travel purchases hit a headwind, it has no alternative sources of cash.
- ubernostrum 10y agoIndenting to get fake-blockquote style makes your comment completely unreadable on mobile, and in this case also on desktop without a lot of annoying horizontal scrolling. Please consider not doing it. If you need to indicate a quote, you can always do paragraphs in italics, or use quotation marks, or just say you're quoting and indicate where the quote ends.
- rdl 10y agoI've never found the airline credit cards to be the best deal for purchases. I can get 1.5-2% cash back on some cards (even higher on certain types of purchases), but the best value is either Chase Sapphire Reserve (essentially 3% back on travel/dining, and potentially more if you redeem for miles), or SPG Amex (2.2-3%, minimum, and sometimes higher). Airline cards are worth it for status, and for the bonus for on-airline purchases, but not for general purchases.
- pbreit 10y agoDoes it not make sense to evaluate the offering in total? Also, rewards cards usually try to optimize perceived value vs actual value. So miles, for example might have perceived value of 4% but only cost the bank 2%. Cash reward is 1:1.
- ajdlinux 10y agoHere in Australia, US-style cashback cards basically don't exist - there have been a handful of banks that have tried things like a 2% cashback on debit cards for using Visa PayWave, a few cards which have introductory (e.g. first three months) cashback deals, and of course you can use Amex points to pay off your Amex debt, but usually at worse rates than you can exchange to airline miles. But nothing like US-style permanent cashback deals. Of course, over here we have far lower interchange rates than the US, and courtesy of new Reserve Bank regulations, interchange rates will drop even further on Visa and MasterCard purchases later this year, which I suspect makes it rather harder to do a cashback offer profitably.
- notacoward 10y ago> I've never found the airline credit cards to be the best deal for purchases. So don't use them for regular purchases. However, if you like things like first bag for free or free in-flight wifi (because of the mileage bonus), then the airline-branded card can be nice to have. It's not like you're only allowed to have one kind of card.
- tiatia 10y agoIn the US I have a Citi Platium Cash back card since man years. Very satisfied, except it has foreign transaction fees. If lounge access is your goal, you can get this with some cards (US: Amex, Europe: Diners Club)
- fizixer 10y agoI don't understand. I read about half of the article and it doesn't explain how that works. I mean money has to come from somewhere, I assume the tens of millions of credit card holders. But credit card holders do their usual spending, and in fact save between 1% and 3% on their monthly bills instead of paying more. Unless. - They increase their air travel frequency. - They get addicted to collecting airline miles, because it gives them the feeling of free air travel. - And as a result they increase their average spending (so no longer the 'usual' spending), and buy useless stuff, just so they can collect more and more miles. Is that the real story or something more/different?
- pbreit 10y agoThe banks pay the airlines for miles cardholders earn.
- fizixer 10y agoYes. But how do banks make money? Surely they're not paying airlines for miles and distributing the miles free-of-charge to their card holders out of the goodness of their hearts. What are they getting in return? Either what I said above or something more/different (annual fees is another possibility?).
- ajdlinux 10y agoInterchange fees charged per-transaction by Visa/MC/Amex.
- pbreit 10y agoCorrect. Merchants pay about 2% on credit card charges. The other big earnings stream for banks are finance charges on cardholders who carry a balance (ie, borrow money from bank).
- dragonwriter 10y agoEvery cardholder who uses their card borrows money; carrying a balance is a matter of not paying it back within the grace period, but you are borrowing money either way.
- itchyjunk 10y agoHeh, I just bought a ticket from SLC -> CHI for around a $100. AA had a nice little add(?) showing it would cost me $0 (minus tax and other fees) if I got their card. I was just thinking how crazy that was. I've personally never found the use for a credit card from a specific airline to be useful for a casual traveler. I generally like to shop around for the cheapest price between all available carriers. There is no incentive for me to stick with a single carrier to get those miles simply because I can't afford to travel that much. I also don't have those credit cards from walmart, Khols or <insert business name here> though. When I first came to USA, someone told me having multiple cc can lower your credit score and credit score is life. So I am still scared of credit cards.
- pbreit 10y agoThe opposite. Lenders like to see that you can obtain credit, use it a little and make payments on time.
- derefr 10y ago> When I first came to USA, someone told me having multiple cc can lower your credit score and credit score is life. That's strictly the opposite of true. Now, carrying a balance on multiple credit cards, or paying multiple cards late, is worse than the equivalent with a single card. And applying for lots of credit cards quickly can hurt you. But just having multiple credit cards, that get paid off every month—or don't carry a balance at all—helps your credit score: the "positive side" of your credit score is computed as (effectively) the amount of money that people are currently contractually obligated to give you if you ask (i.e. the limit of all your credit accounts + loans + equities added together.) If you can get more companies to extend you credit, that has the same positive benefit as getting your limit raised on a card you already have.
- ctchocula 10y agoI'm not sure that the "don't carry a balance at all" helps your credit score. I've heard some places say that a utilization of 1%-9% and the balance being paid at end of each billing cycle will help increase one's credit score more than 0%. > On the other hand, using a low percentage of your available credit can have a positive impact. In some cases, a low credit utilization ratio will have a more positive impact on your FICO Scores than not using any of your available credit at all. [1] [1] http://www.myfico.com/CreditEducation/Amounts-Owed.aspx http://www.myfico.com/CreditEducation/Amounts-Owed.aspx
- bkohlmann 10y ago"A soldier will fight long and hard for a bit of colored ribbon" - Napoleon. What strikes me about this is the behavioral decision making aspect. The airlines - and many other loyalty rewards programs - have tapped deeply into the human tendency to accumulate currency, however meaningless. And as someone who is well aware of this tendency, I still gleefully watch my credit card points balance increase every month, even though it really means I'm spending a ton of actual money. I don't begrudge the airlines at all for this technique. It intrigues me than in our advanced society, we are easily fooled by simple measures.
- analogmemory 10y agoI pay all my bills/groceries/expenses with a credit card, and get points. I use to use my debit card. Might as well get something out of a process I'm already doing.
- desdiv 10y agoThen get a cash-back card back where you get legal tender USD back, instead of some psudo-currency that arbitrarily expires, has a shitty exchange rate, and can only be spent at limited locations.
- daurnimator 10y agoI've never seen a "cash-back" card outside the USA. Here in Australia, a 2 points per $ is the best value I can seem to find. Edit: I just did some quick searching, and cash-back cards do exist here, they are just horrible value.
- santaclaus 10y agoHell, even in the states, I haven't seen a cash-back card with a reasonable rate (~5%) in years. Most cash-back cards I see are slightly less than 2% back, while with 'rewards' cards (e.g. Amazon) you can easily find 5%. If anyone can point me towards a nice cash-back card I'm def game, though!
- gozur88 10y agoThe credit card company is probably getting the miles at a steep discount, but I wonder how many people actually use their miles before they expire.
- ubernostrum 10y agoAirlines don't really use expiration as a way to control this anymore; while they haven't all moved to non-expiring setups, it's usually easy enough to keep current that it won't matter (i.e., in many cases miles expire based on a period of inactivity on the frequent-flyer account, but adding miles through card usage counts as activity). The way they prevent it being too large a loss is by periodically devaluing, so that the cost in miles/points to purchase a ticket goes up over time.
- reacharavindh 10y agoAt the end of the day, it is the merchant that pays upto 4% of their transaction as fees to these banks, and that money travels through several pockets before some hits the consumer back. I know I'm about to move out of the US. So I signed up for several high rewards credit cards and racked up their signing bonuses and travel rewards. The hit on credit score is not bothering me either :-) Essentially free money to me for using credit cards for stuff I would have done anyway. ~$3500 in free money so far and counting.. Oh and I pay those bills in full on time. So no fees to them. Feels good to score against the banks :-)
- MrFoof 10y ago> Oh and I pay those bills in full on time. So no fees to them. Feels good to score against the banks :-) It's weird, but the reality is the rewards from credit cards can be ridiculous, whether percent-cash back, miles (for heavy travelers) or signup bonuses. For those unaware, there are people who try to maximize the signup bonuses in particular through a process called "churning", mostly to travel for near or at no cost at all. There's very detailed guides on how to maximize the signup bonuses. I don't churn, but I do try to maximize what I can get back for things I buy anyways. * One card gives me 6% cash back at grocery stores. I do eat food after all (I cook 99% of my meals, and rarely eat out). I also use them as my pharmacy. 6% off food and medication -- two things I can't live without -- is pretty good. There is a fee for this card, but the cash back puts me at +$285 back a year after the annual fee. * Amazon gives me 5% back off what I get through them. Sure, I'll take another 5% off. * One gives me 5% off gasoline. I tend to need gasoline at the moment. Sure, I'll take that! * Two have rotating 5% categories, that tend not to overlap. So sometimes I can get 5% off something I needed anyways. Great! * One gives me 2% back that goes into my IRA. If I had kids, I could put it in their 529 instead. Automatic planning for the future on anything where I'd normally get just 1% instead. Sweet! * This year I moved and planned on getting a new dishwasher, washer and dryer. So I searched for cards with a cash-back on spend signup bonus. Found one that best matched, which was $300 back if I spent $3000 in the first 90 days... plus 1% cash back on the card. Got $334 back in total on money I was going to spend anyways, which was a 10% discount. Sure thing! I realize merchants pay higher fees to give me these rewards. If these huge rewards go away, that won't bother me. I'll still use the cards with lower rewards, because something is better than nothing, the issuers fight harder than my bank would if I used debit and things happened, and I haven't ever paid a cent in interest on a credit card.
- dvdhsu 10y agoI think this industry won't last for very long. Mile-earning cards are dependent on merchants paying high fees. In most of the developed world, interchange fees have been capped (e.g. 40bp in the EU). Once that happens, these rewards credit cards disappear overnight (which is what happened in the UK shortly after the IC regulation). Eventually, I think the US will have its own cap on interchange fees. Credit card rewards will then cease to exist. It's fundamentally inefficient. (But perhaps lobbyists are more powerful here than in the EU / Australia?)
- danielfoster 10y agoLobbyists are pretty powerful and Americans like the rewards, so I don't think it will change any time soon. In any case I would assume that merchant fees follow the same pattern as tax incidence. Just like taxes on goods, they are passed on to the consumer or merchant in relation to the supply and demand of the product: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence
- Havoc 10y ago>credit cards disappear overnight (which is what happened in the UK shortly after the IC regulation). huh? I've still got a UK issued British Airways Amex?
- Symbiote 10y agoAmex cards operate under slightly different rules. Presumably, the limited acceptance of Amex is related. According to [1], the exemption from the 0.3% cap only lasts three years -- that is, until December 2018. (I wonder what American Express will do? Doesn't their business depend on the high fees they charge merchants?) [1] https://www.adyen.com/blog/eu-interchange-fees-cap https://www.adyen.com/blog/eu-interchange-fees-cap
- Havoc 10y ago>Doesn't their business depend on the high fees they charge merchants? I've got local businesses that charge extra for all cards -- except Amex. So no idea how this stuff works except for the fact that it's all over the show.
- danielfoster 10y agoThe other great thing here for airlines is that they can devalue the miles at any time, which they do on a regular basis.
- formula_ninguna 10y agoIt's rather simple -- don't use credit cards, don't borrow money.
- hueving 10y agoSure, if you like leaving money on the table that's a simple thing to do.
- formula_ninguna 10y agoI'll tell you a secret -- you can keep your money in a bank and have a debit card.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 10y agoThe parent isn't talking about not using banks. They are saying that using debit cards (or cash) to do transactions when you could be doing the same transaction on a credit card and getting free points is akin to leaving money on the table. This year I made several hundred dollars worth of points for which I did not have to alter my spending behavior at all. I am buying plane tickets and staying in motels and filling gas and renting cars and eating out and blah blah, credit card or not, points or not. It's ridiculous to not want to get back 1-3% of that money as long as you have even a bit of control on your spend. If you actually have a decently paying job so that you don't have to rely on credit cards to borrow money that you can't return, it's perfectly rational to have credit cards and pay the points game.
- tiatia 10y agoCollecting miles is an art. (See Flyertalk). In my experience: - You can collect the miles but it is very difficult to use them. I think I had this problem with AA, if I remember right. They were rated last in a Frequent Flyer Miles Ranking I once saw. - It is easy to use the miles (Lufthansa, can use for every flight, even pay taxes with miles) but they don't give you the miles. Lufthansa was #1 in the ranking. I flew something like 100k miles and they credited 10k miles based on Booking Class and cross carrier miles crediting (Star Alliance).
- tiatia 10y agoAlso, sometimes the employer pays for the miles. If you get reimbursed for your flights, some airlines give you much more miles if you buy a ticket (Economy has many sub classes) that is slightly more expensive (e.g. 100 Dollar more, double miles). This is a "nice" way to collect miles and have somebody else pay for it.
- tuna-piano 10y ago1. There's a reason high margin businesses are so rare- generally, competition will bid the prices down to more reasonable levels of profit. I understand each airline has their own branded credit card, which they have pricing power over. But besides branded cards and direct mileage purchases, why would mileage margins stay so good? Surely the mile buyer would have negotiation power between the airlines. Why can't these mileage buyers (banks, rental car companies, etc) get lower prices for the miles, given the high margins? Is it possible there is mileage price collusion among the airlines? 2. How do airlines account for the cost of mileage seat redemptions when calculating their margins? Do they just use their marginal cost of carrying that passenger (very small)? In my mind, the cost of selling a seat with miles should be at least as much as the lowest price they charged other paying customers. If a plane flies 100% at capacity with mileage redeemers onboard, certainly the airline could have sold the mileage seats for at least about the same as the lowest ticket price paid onboard. I'm skeptical that this how they account for it though... 3. Like others have mentioned, the miles game really is fun for many people. It's fun to collect points, to win things, and get the satisfaction of free travel. In general for me psychologically, the price of airline tickets is the bar for whether a trip is worth taking or not- regardless of the other trip expenses. When you get a vacation with free redeemed airline tickets, it somehow feels so incredibly satisfying.
- dakial1 10y ago1. It's a matter of reference. Even with the 40+ margin airlines put over the miles price, banks put even more. In the end the one who is paying for it is the consumer. Also, this mileage programs are made by contract over a period of time, and airlines usually don't have contracts with different banks. This lack of "liquidity" makes it harder for banks to have an upper hand in negotiations. 2. Airlines have different ways of calculating the cost, but usually they use the normal price as a proxy for the redemption price. Airlines actually can charge less than the cheapest fare because they segment their consumers by travel patterns and (sort of) split the flight total seats into this different segments. So they have a certain quantity of seats alloted for redemption passengers at X price, another for Y price. This would become a long reply if I explained in detail, but I suggest you search for "Revenue Management" or "Yield Management", as it is very interesting to see how airlines do their pricing. 3. Yes. Absolutely! Even after being in the industry (I worked with Revenue Management for a Latin American airline), I still love a good mileage program. I even choose my banks over it.
- infosample 10y ago“These deals remain lucrative in both good times and bad, as they are immune to economic cycles.” So were tech stocks and real estate until they weren't. This time is different because loses will only affect banks, no big deal.
- organifi1865 10y agohttp://www.organifigreenjuicereviews.org/ http://www.organifigreenjuicereviews.org/
- jbuzbee 10y agoIf you use these airline cards thoughtfully, they're a great deal for the consumer. Last year United offered both myself and my wife 50K miles to sign up with no annual fee for the first year. Then they threw in some club passes and more miles when we added each other, spent some amount, etc. We ended up each getting 55K miles or so. Then United had a mileage sale for tickets to Australia - 60K miles per roundtrip ticket. Combined with the miles we already had, we ended up with two free round-trip tickets from the US to Australia. Of course we never carried a balance on the cards and cancelled them before the yearly fee came in. Now we'll wait a year and sign up again.