9 ms·
Is Matter Conscious?
- buhrmi 10y agono
- lutusp 10y agoa. You're conscious. b. You're composed of matter. c. Therefore some matter is conscious. d. What's true for some matter might be true for all matter --- or not. That's the "hard problem" of consciousness.
- visarga 10y agoYes, but many people still think there is magic fairy dust sprinkled into our brains that make them special. It's hard to comprehend that we are not magical, just the same matter as in all the physical world. A failure of vision or imagination on their part. They don't realize that the universe, plain and physical as it is, is capable of consciousness and thus "sacred". For them the world is just dust. I believe the world is plenty mysterious and special without imaginary friends in the sky.
- qb45 10y agoSure you can reject religion. Then it all boils down to whose model of the not-yet-really-understood is more accurate and who will eat whom on the top of the food chain ;) Take this: N years ago, for some value of N, nobody talked about friends in the sky. Now they do. Atheism: myth busted :)
- abiox 10y ago> Sure you can reject religion. Then it all boils down to whose model of the not-yet-really-understood is more accurate and who will eat whom on the top of the food chain ;) this seems to be the case regardless of religion.
- lutusp 10y ago> Atheism: myth busted :) If we find "friends in the sky," i.e. alien intelligences, that would be as likely to argue against religion as for it. Consider the dilemma posed for Christians by the idea of another planet with another intelligent species. That would challenge their core belief that we were shaped in a deity's image -- a deity imagined to rule the entire universe.
- bitL 10y agoFor all we know, our brain can be just an interface to something else we don't know yet. Like when nobody knew what radioactivity was, miners thought some monsters resided deep inside Earth, illuminating caves and mines in green, and anybody that got nearby died soon afterwards. Quantum theory spawned a lot of scientism at the beginning of 20th Century, attributing consciousness properties down to atomic level, and this seems to be the case with each new generation, falling into the same though a bit more refined scientistic trap. Just for fun: If we play with the idea of Platonic Theory of Forms as a super-set of what we can perceive with our sens-es(-ors), under assumption philosophy/math is above reality, we can simply be plugged into some kind of a virtual machine with some API of sorts (of course undocumented) that is called by our brains when we think. Those who figured out some rare API calls on their own or by a secret tradition we call magicians, conjurers, gurus, Neo etc. Maybe words/thoughts could invoke some of those API functions, hence magic Harry-Potter-esque words and generally prayers in many religions. Similarly, what we call angels could be simply API services with highly intelligent behavior, preferably operating outside time, providing verifiable and expected outcome. Demons then are some intelligent services gone completely wrong, messing up with the rest of intelligent services that depend upon them, playing eternal asynchronous byzantine generals (by e.g. trying to upgrade all services to Windows 10 or flat interfaces with telemetry /s). I think I should write a dystopian cyberpunk sci-fi "Services and Daemons" about this ;-)
- Eerie 10y ago>For all we know, our brain can be just an interface to something else we don't know yet. This is a very old, but unproven hypothesis. You might have heard of it, it's called "soul". :-)
- abiox 10y agothis seems like a potential composition fallacy.
- lutusp 10y agoYes, had I positively asserted the claim about all matter on the basis of some of it. But I won't do that. Rocks might just be rocks. And compared to some hypothetical beings far more advanced than we are, we might be rocks.
- pixie_ 10y agoIt's great taking the time to read a large insightful article, and then coming to the comments to see an insightful post like this.
- cool_shit 10y agoI can't stand articles like this -- they bait you into reading poetry at the promise of science. So many words, so few ideas that are actually substantive. Consciousness speculation articles are a dime a dozen today, this is part of the noise. Even worse when they ramble on for what seems pages of periodic content.
- lutusp 10y agoOne can argue that such contentless articles only reveal to us what we don't know (a "known unknown"). It might be true that we can't know this particular thing, but that's still an open question. But I agree that there are too many such articles, with too little original content.
- oldmancoyote 10y agoI think this subject is too deep for some people to understand. Rather than find fault with themselves, they find fault with the subject.
- catshirt 10y agoI'm reminded of people talking about tripping. we don't really have the vocabulary or knowledge to talk about certain things and they end up sounding wishywashy. but I don't think it means we can't try, or hypothesize...
- M_Grey 10y ago
- visarga 10y ago> No matter how precisely we could specify the mechanisms underlying, for example, the perception and recognition of tomatoes, we could still ask: Why is this process accompanied by the subjective experience of red, or any experience at all? Why couldn’t we have just the physical process, but no consciousness? The difference comes from context. It is one thing to have a feedforward network that detects tomatoes, another to have a reinforcement learning agent that optimizes for survival in nature. The RL agent has a value function that assigns a predicted future reward to the current state and actions available. The value network, together with the sense data, is "what it feels like" for the agent to see the tomatoes. Maybe it knows that red tomatoes are good, or that red fruit are ripe, and they can give it a reward signal by reducing hunger. That makes perceiving red an experience colored by emotion. Maybe agents that didn't see red tomatoes as good, had less chance of survival and died off. Also, the RL agent is not a simple feedforward net, but a loop: perception->judgement->action->effect in environment, and rewards. It is a dynamic process, evolving from moment to moment. In that continuous perception-action-effect loop, there is space for the inner world and all its complexities.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoWhy? All of those could be feedback/computation systems without any experience. Your answer only argues for why the system would have certain computational features, not a subjective aspect.
- visarga 10y agoMy answer explains why there would be an emotion attached to a perception. The subjective aspect is a result of the network being an agent, that has to fend for itself in the greater environment. The stake of the RL game is survival itself. Each new state it finds itself in opens some possible future paths and closes other paths. Some actions lead to rewards, other to losses. I think subjectivity lays in this space of values, options and actions. That places is where "it feels like something" to see red. And if you're still unconvinced, remember what we are: a collection of cells, a protein based dynamical system that has computing and learning abilities. Why would it feel like something to be a protein-based computer?
- powera 10y agoAnother article that basically says "quantum and consciousness are both poorly understood; maybe they're related" in thousands and thousands of words.
- markbnj 10y agoThis reminds me of Ursula K. LeGuin's "A Wizard of Earthsea," in which all things had a name, and knowing a thing's name granted power over it. At the same time it also seems weirdly suggestive of The Matrix.
- jat850 10y agoHoly wow. I just finished reading the first of the Kingkiller Chronicle books, The Name of the Wind. I did not realize this central theme was so similar (and/or derivative). My exposure to sci-fi and fantasy is more deep than broad, a lot from the same authors instead of several from many. I think I must be somewhat blinded to how common this probably is.
- bitexploder 10y agoI have read a lot of sci-fi and fantasy fiction. A lot. Very few stories surprise me regarding the broad strokes or philosophical system / theme as it relates to magic and world building. I always enjoy when an author teases a new perspective on a known theme or system. Sanderson is great at taking a "known" system and bounding it tightly and thus making it a great story telling device. I always enjoy an author with a deep understanding of a subject like game theory and they weave it into the magic and story giving a view into something new. So "everything is derivative". And nothing is :)
- jat850 10y agoI also just finished the first Mistborn book. I REALLY enjoyed that, much more than Kingkiller Chronicles (of which I've read two books). I'm moving onto the next one and am excited that there are a number of them I can consume in this same series/world. I thought the magic system in Kingkiller was pretty neat, and I think the same of Mistborn. It really exposed further my narrow scope because I am very used to conventional, plain magics and they were both different and unique, and well-crafted.
- bitexploder 10y ago
- kneel 10y agoThis subject has been beaten to death by a lot of smart people. I think it's well understood how consciousness works, (on a higher order level) the answer is just boring and somewhat demeaning to many who believe that they're something bigger than a sack of nerves.
- catshirt 10y ago"I think it's well understood how consciousness works" care to expand on this at all? it completely contradicts most everything I've heard. saying consciousness is just a neural reaction could be right but it's by no means an understanding.
- bitL 10y agoWe don't even have a proper explanation of how neurons themselves work; there are some processes we have no idea how they are possible (vast amount of ions passing through membranes) as well as some local protein computations that go against perceptron simplification operating on simple analog electricity.
- kneel 10y ago>We don't even have a proper explanation of how neurons themselves work; there are some processes we have no idea how they are possible (vast amount of ions passing through membranes) as well as some local protein computations that go against perceptron simplification operating on simple analog electricity. I think neuron function pretty well characterized. What about ions passing through membranes do we not understand? The exact details of all neuron types and protein interactions are definitely not known but basic function is understood.
- catshirt 10y agojust because these things can conceive consciousness does not make them consciousness. unless you can tell me exactly why and when in these processes consciousness arises, were not having the same conversation.
- oldmancoyote 10y agoFor a while it was common for folks to speculate that consciousness was self-organizing behavior of a chaotic assemblage of electro-chemical relations within the brain. The problem with that has been that self-organizing behavior adds nothing new. It merely reorganizes existing behavior/properties. This article proposes the existence of the fundamental "thing" that is organized in consciousness, that thing that is the primitive element possessing the property of awareness. Seems good to me. In fact, it seems necessarily true.
- visarga 10y ago> self-organizing behavior of a chaotic assemblage of electro-chemical relations within the brain That seems about right to me. Add that the organism itself is part of a complex environment, with all its sensations and reward signals, and that the organism has to adapt in order to survive/exist in the first place. With these constraints, the self-organizing behavior leads to consciousness.
- lend000 10y agoThere's no reason to believe so. Advancements in CS, AI, biology, and general models of intelligence are slowly bringing us to the point where consciousness is no longer a mystery to the enlightened. One of my favorite researchers in general AI is Professor Schmidhuber, who has pioneered some of the (currently) more practical areas of machine learning, too: http://people.idsia.ch/~juergen/ http://people.idsia.ch/~juergen/ Even when we create self-aware machines that can demonstrate generalized intelligence, I think most people will struggle to come to terms with what consciousness is (or more so, what it isn't). My spin on it: consciousness isn't real; it's a necessary perceived byproduct of 'everything else.' I believe Schmidhuber said it more elegantly, describing consciousness as a result of data compression.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoNothing about our understanding of intelligence or self-awareness explains why we're not philosophical zombies. Your explanation only addresses the form of perception, not why there's perception at all. It doesn't even address it, just implicitly assumes there must be such! Your comment isn't even wrong: it fails to address the topic at all.
- abiox 10y ago> Nothing about our understanding of intelligence or self-awareness explains why we're not philosophical zombies. perhaps we really are zombies. > why there's perception at all why do atoms interact at all? why do fields interact at all? perhaps "there's perception" because fields and matter can interact.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoWell, that would agree with the article and disagree with the person I was replying to. So I think you're responding to the wrong person.
- praxulus 10y ago>perhaps we really are zombies Maybe you are, but I'm definitely conscious. I find it hard to believe that I'm unique in that respect.
- s_gourichon 10y agoAnyone interested in consciousness (even out of personal curiosity) is likely to love all the work of Kevin O'Regan. http://nivea.psycho.univ-paris5.fr/ http://nivea.psycho.univ-paris5.fr/ Interesting, sound, scientific. For example his book "Why Red Doesn't Sound Like a Bell: Explaining the Feel of Consciousness (2011)". Author makes it available to download on https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/869531/OReganWhyRedDraft.pdf https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/869531/OReganWhyRedDraft...
- KennyCason 10y agoI think the title may mislead some and result in their dissatisfaction. This article (and comments) are more addressing the unknown nature of consciousness and matter. Specifically, how they seem to be circularly related. I.e. Our consciousness seems to have originated from our physical configuration, yet also the only way we perceive/understand the physical reality is through our consciousness/mind. It also concludes with the fun statement "The possibility that consciousness is the real concrete stuff of reality". Which is quite a fun statement to truly unpack and understand, of which, I will not attempt to do now. :)
- visarga 10y agoThe article is referring to "idealism", the belief that world is primarily ideal (ideal = "of the same kind with ideas" = mental), not physical. It says that the world we perceive is just an internal state inside the fundamental substratum which is consciousness itself. It was in vogue in India 1000 years ago in the time of Abhinavagupta and appeared in many other places, even in Europe. Look for idealistic monism in the wiki.
- Animats 10y agoThis seems to be the old homunculus argument in another form.[1] As knowledge of how brains work increases, this will probably become a non-issue. A big question for millenia was "what is life?" This question continued through the discovery of bacteria, and later, DNA. As the lower level mechanisms of biology were understood, it stopped being a question. Bacteria are alive, and are reasonably well understood. The components of bacteria are not quite alive, but are also understood. (There's still some argument over whether viruses are alive, but that's now just an argument over the definition.) "What is life" is now a "go look it up" question, not a mystery. "What is consciousness" will probably go the same way in time. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homunculus_argument https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homunculus_argument
- Razengan 10y ago> "What is life" is now a "go look it up" question, not a mystery. Is Earth – the planet itself – alive? > "What is consciousness" will probably go the same way in time. But what about free will?
- abiox 10y ago> Is Earth – the planet itself – alive? not according to the definition i just looked up. depending on what you mean, the earth is 'simply' a ball of mud hurtling through space, or it's something more akin to a label for the complex emergent system composed of many individual instances of LivingObject. > But what about free will? how are we defining "free will"?
- Koshkin 10y ago> ball of mud I am afraid, geologists (and many other people) might disagree with this characterization. They find the composition of our planet an extremely fascinating subject.
- abiox 10y agooh, certainly. i once took a geology class without much expectations, and found it tremendously fascinating. very interesting stuff!
- ppod 10y agoI don't see any advance in this debate since things that Dennett and Hofstadter wrote 20+ years ago (both independently and in their co-authored book "The Mind's I[^]"). It's surprising to see academic philosophers still using arguments like the "redness problem" described in this article. How can anyone with any knowledge of visual neuroscience or artificial neural networks be confused by a generative system producing a novel state? And perhaps more controversially, I'm always a bit taken aback by the constant blase assertion that consciousness is a mystery. Is it really surprising that we have a first person subjective experience? We know that we are incredibly complex things, constantly integrating and acting on very complicated external stimuli. Such a system should have references to its own body and its own neural states, its train of reasoning should frequently include itself, its focus will drift forward and backwards in time... this is just how a system like this would work. If the system communicates about its state then its language should have referents to these internal states, referents like "experience", and "feels like", and "I understand". Is that surprising? Wouldn't it be surprising if it wasn't like that? I think that Tononi's approach is a good approximation, but it can't be a full solution because the word 'consciousness' is too anthropocentric. One criticism of IIT showed that a seemingly uninteresting complex artificial system could have a very high IIT complexity quotient. The problem is that the things we use to define the term 'consciousness' are things that can be approximated to varying degrees by chimps or dolphins or generative adversarial networks or antfarms or thermometers. But behind our use of the word 'consciousness' there is still almost always a very slightly disguised dualism that uses it as a substitute for the word 'soul'. [^]edited
- rexpop 10y agoIt's "The Mind's I: Fantasies and Reflections on Self and Soul" by Douglas R. Hofstadter and Daniel C. Dennett "The Mind's Eye" is by Oliver Sacks (who has almost definitely read Hofstadter/Dennett) https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2081.The_Mind_s_I https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2081.The_Mind_s_I
- visarga 10y agoBravo. Might I add that Tononi's IIT theory is just a technical detail of implementation, insufficient by itself. Consciousness is in fact the reinforcement learning system connected to the world by the perception system. The state + value of the RL agent represents consciousness.
- dgreensp 10y agoThis is actually one of the better presentations of this idea, and it gave me a better handle on it. Here's one way to look at it. If you accept the claim, "My conscious experiences exist, non-physically," which seems true, you can reason to some interesting places from there. For example, it would be pretty weird if you were the only "conscious" person in the world, surrounded by zombies who only appear to have an inner life, so we can say that all brains have consciousness. Then, you can keep delicately applying Occam's razor to say that what we call consciousness could be just one manifestation of a more basic phenomenon, which fills a metaphysical explanatory void. Even if we don't accept the claim, and we say consciousness doesn't really exist and we are merely projecting its existence, we could still discover new phenomena that seem just as real to us as the illusion of consciousness, despite not being clearly connected to physical laws. Maybe pretending that it's possible to have a "direct experience" of something can reveal that everyday consciousness is just one kind of direct experiencing.
- arc_of_descent 10y agoI've been hooked onto UG for more than a month now. Articles like this would have piqued my interest earlier. Now they just bore me. I'm going back to learning CL.