6 ms·
It would be interesting to see how this compares to theoretical limits. At a given brightness and collecting area, you get (with lossless optics) a certain num
by amluto 10y ago
It would be interesting to see how this compares to theoretical limits. At a given brightness and collecting area, you get (with lossless optics) a certain number of photons per pixel per unit time. Unless your sensor does extraordinarily unlikely quantum stuff, at best it counts photons with some noise. The unavoidable limit is "shot noise": the number of photons in a given time is Poisson distributed, giving you noise according to the Poisson distribution.
At nonzero temperature, you have the further problem that your sensor has thermally excited electrons, which aren't necessarily a problem AFAIK. More importantly, the sensor glows. If the sensor registers many of its own emitted photons, you get lots of thermal noise.
Good low noise amplifiers for RF that are well matched to their antennas can avoid amplifying their own thermal emissions. I don't know how well CCDs can do at this.
Given that this is a military device, I'd assume the sensor is chilled.
- doubleunplussed 10y agoIt's not enough to do crazy quantum stuff in the camera, the light source would have to be similarly manipulated in a quantum way as well. My understanding is that the human eye has a surprisingly high quantum efficiency (about 12 to 30 % of photons are detected), and that the reason night looks dark is because there really aren't that many visible spectrum photons around. My guess is that this camera is physically enormous. Edit: Apparently, it's really small! I am dumbfounded. Then again, I guess it could have a hundred times the area of a human pupil and still be pretty small.
- twelvechairs 10y agoHumans can actually see well in the dark once adjusted but generally without colour (due to using rods rather than cones in the eye). The colour is probably what makes this video appear incredible to us as its not how we are used to percieving darkness (even with eg night vision). As to the technical question according to this you need 90 photons for a 60% chance at a human response http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Quantum/see_a_photon.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Quantum/see_a_photon.h...
- amluto 10y ago> It's not enough to do crazy quantum stuff in the camera, the light source would have to be similarly manipulated in a quantum way as well. Not entirely true. Assuming an incoherent source, conventional optics, and a well-defined frame (i.e. you measure for a time t and the source is unchanging for the whole time), you have a bunch of modes of incoming light that would hit each pixel. Measuring these modes in the photon number basis isn't optimal. The ideal measurement is probably something quite different. It may also depend on your exact assumptions avoid the source.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- doubleunplussed 10y agoUltimately you want to count photons to produce an image. And if it's an incoherent source, I don't think there's anything else you can do with it. With coherent light it can be useful to have the light interact with matter in a way that depends on the phase of the light. But if the light is incoherent then that won't yield anything useful. And this still doesn't beat the shot noise limit - your phase measurements still come from counting photons subject to shot noise. Then there's polarisation. Two polarisation states. But really that's just like saying there are two kinds of photons. Both polarisation states are subject to number-phase uncertainty principle. I think that's it. There's the number and phase, which are conjugate variables. You can make number more accurate by squeezing phase, but only if you control the light source. And then there's the two polarisation states. And the EM field simply doesn't have any more degrees of freedom than that, so I think that's it unfortunately. It's number-phase squeezing or nothing if you want to count photons more accurately than shot noise.
- krastanov 10y agoYou are missing something though: Using entangled detectors you can surpass the diffraction limit. Googling "quantum internet and diffraction limit" would bring up some more information. Either way, this would apply to resolution, not to sensitivity (which is what you seem to be covering)
- grondilu 10y agoTheoretical limits are probably very high. For one, collecting area can be pretty large. Obviously you don't want a square meter lens, but a foot-wide one would probably be acceptable for a specialized camera. Second, nocturnal animals like howls see very well in the dark. Granted, they don't see colors but they still show that in theory seeing in the night is physically impossible. PS. regarding the collecting area, something I've been wondering for a bit : isn't the number of photons a lens can capture proportional to the square of the surface and not the surface itself? I know that sounds counter-intuitive but with interference, quantum mechanics and stuff, I checked the math once and I could not see where I was wrong.
- greglindahl 10y agoI don't know what you mean by "surface", but the number of photos collected depends on the area of the lens. No quantum mechanics or interference involved.
- grondilu 10y agoI did mean area. And I thought the number of photons was proportional to the square of the area because the probability amplitude is proportional to the area. Therefore the probability should be proportional to the square of the area, shoudn't it? It also seemed to make sense to me otherwise we would not need to build large telescopes, we could just build lots of small ones and fuse the images.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- titanomachy 10y ago> the probability should be proportional to the square of the area, shoudn't it? No.
- greglindahl 10y agoHang out with astronomers, they do this stuff all the time: poisson noise, dark current, readout noise, readout time, taking thousands of shots and stacking them according to the previous factors.
- dr_zoidberg 10y agoDSLRs have come with dark current removal for a few years now. Another fun fact, the sensor used in Canon's G15/16 has a Quantum Efficency of over 60%, meaning that 60% of photons reaching the sensor generate a signal. Most cameras have sensor with QEs between 15 to 25% (but have way larger sensors, so in the end a better SNR than the G16).
- greglindahl 10y agoI should hope that they subtract off the dark current, astronomers have been doing that since the first time they used a CCD. Dark current is a big limitation to seeing dim things. That's a much higher QE than the good old days, wow.
- dr_zoidberg 10y agoHere's a list of QE numbers: http://www.sensorgen.info/ http://www.sensorgen.info/ I knew it was over 60%, and I remembered (wrong) as the G15 and G16 having the same sensor. Welp, 77% QE for the G16 and 67% for the G15. There are others with higher QE, though in general those are used in smaller sensors. DSLRs, while having lower QE numbers, have much larger sensors, and hence a better image quality.
- mark-r 10y agoThat's incredibly useful, thanks. The only problem is, I don't trust the numbers. How does the Nikon D2X get a QE of 476%?
- candiodari 10y agoWhat does a QE of >100% mean ? (Sony) Alpha-900 234% 3.6 892070 (Pentax) Q 101% 1.6 8429 There's a few more.
- frozenport 10y agoI can see in a dark lab with my EMCCD camera. It doesn't look as good as in this video, but they got maybe a 3x improvement compared to what I can do at present, with minimal effort.
- hawski 10y agoOn the producent's website there is a comparison between their X27 and competition. EMCCD has fair 2nd place in this contest. It has more noise than X27, but what you can get is still remarkable.
- mschuster91 10y ago> Given that this is a military device, I'd assume the sensor is chilled. There's a promo video of the manufacturer. At 0:16 you can see something looking like cooling fins on the side. https://youtu.be/c_0s06ORTkY?t=16s https://youtu.be/c_0s06ORTkY?t=16s