4 ms·
Good and bad. Setting aside the changing weather patterns (also good and bad), a warmer planet will likely be good for some kinds of life and bad for others.
by Jtsummers 10y ago
Good and bad.
Setting aside the changing weather patterns (also good and bad), a warmer planet will likely be good for some kinds of life and bad for others.
It will be good, particularly, for vegetation (discussed in this article, the greening of the Siberian tundra). It will also be good for animals which depend on the now more plentiful vegetation and opened up territory. It will be bad for animals that are dependent on the old climate. For humans (ignoring ethics and other concerns over species becoming extinct), it's probably a net positive as this means more arable land and territory as well. Though this may only be temporary.
At sea, it's again a mixed bag. Cold-blooded animals, in particular, are very sensitive to changes in temperature. Most fish and sea creatures are also sensitive to levels of CO2, O2, and acidity. Increasing temperatures and CO2, even if still technically sufficient levels of O2, may render some species infertile or unable to thrive. Increased CO2 and reduced O2 will make large swaths of the ocean uninhabitable by fish and other creatures. The CO2 will help CO2 consuming ocean life, but until a new balance is reached O2 consuming life will likely be greatly harmed. This has major ramifications for people dependent on the ocean for their sustenance or livelihood.
Going back to the tundra and its recent browning described in the article, it's possible (note: totally my hypothesis, not based on any research, this is just a thought experiment based on systems thinking and modeling) that the initial greening was due to abundant local water (frozen in the ground) paired with increasing temperatures. The plants spread, temperatures rose more, creating a positive feedback cycle. However, this also results in less snowfall (or retained snow) meaning the water may not be replenishing at a sufficient rate to sustain the increased local demand by plants. In turn, plants die (the recent browning event). But a browning event doesn't imply that the temperatures will or are dropping. So it's not clear if this will be cyclical, or if it is at what period. Perhaps a new equilibrium will be reached, or new, less demanding, plants will take over. This also assumes something of a closed system, the real world is far more complex than this simple model.
This could be very similar to any other boom/bust cycle in nature or economics. Major initial change causes immediate significant positive results, followed by negative, followed by ??? (neutral, more cycles, who knows yet).