3 ms·
I think the logical incoherence of the Boltzmann Brain saves us from it. 1) What we know about the world leads me to the belief that it's far more likely that
by empath75 10y ago
I think the logical incoherence of the Boltzmann Brain saves us from it.
1) What we know about the world leads me to the belief that it's far more likely that a collection of particles in a thermal equilibrium have randomly and temporarily formed into a brain for an instant, than that the entire universe exists as I believe it to.
2) Since I am extremely likely to be a boltzmann brain, everything I know about the world is illusory, and nothing outside of my own mind exists, and my memories don't represent reality.
3) Therefore, everything I thought I knew about the world which led me to believe that I am a boltzmann brain is unlikely to be true.
4) I am unlikely to be a boltzmann brain.
- bmh100 10y agoBut you also have to consider the probability of the brain containing precisely the self-consistent information that would allow you to develop a false theory. To me, the probability argument is more compelling than attacking the circular nature of the idea.
- Strilanc 10y agoStep (3) is not valid. You can't use "I would reason badly in case A" as a proof that A can't happen. At best it's an argument that, when deciding what to do, case A isn't worth worrying about. But that's different from asserting case A can't have happened.
- contravariant 10y agoStep 3 doesn't quite work. If not being a Boltzmann brain implies that you are a Boltzmann brain, then it is irrelevant that this logic no longer works under the assumption that you are a Boltzmann brain. The first is enough to show that not being a Boltzmann brain is impossible, the second is not enough to cause a paradox.