4 ms·
So the CIA is using components from the malware known as Carberp, a suspected Russian organized crime rootkit, which mean instead of helping people protection t
by belorn 10y ago
So the CIA is using components from the malware known as Carberp, a suspected Russian organized crime rootkit, which mean instead of helping people protection their computer from organized crime they allow the vulnerability to continue. How is this moral?
- tptacek 10y agoIt's not an either-or; this is malware, not vulnerabilities. For the most part it doesn't make sense to think in terms of using malware components to protect systems from malware. This misunderstanding has come up on a bunch of other threads too; it seems to be pretty widespread. You can't really "burn" most persistence techniques, publishing them in a way that makes them easy to defend against. If you could, a whole lot of platform security engineering would be much easier.
- belorn 10y agoWhat part of a "persistence method" are not using vulnerabilities? If you infect the boot loader, bios, firmware, or some other methods to create persistence then those are vulnerabilities. That a system can get infected in such way is not by any intended design. Could give an example of a persistence techniques that is using a intended feature of a computer system in order to hide the malware in unintended places in such a way that the system can't remove it (which itself is a unintended functionality).
- tptacek 10y agoThat's like suggesting a programmable page table is a vulnerability, because it can be used to hide a malware stub from processes looking for malware. However you want to litigate this on a message board, nobody working in platform security or even malware defense thinks that way. The difference between a persistence vector and a vulnerability is that you can patch a vulnerability, but you can't patch "programmable page table".
- Gaelan 10y agoOne could argue that the ability to replace OS elements is a feature.
- altcognito 10y agoI was unaware that the CIA is the malware division of the US federal government. They are a spy division. At least we have this timely information again from wikileaks that provides a narrative that the US is framing Russia for hacking. It's almost the only thing they are releasing nowadays.
- shuntress 10y ago>I was unaware that the CIA is the malware division of the US federal government. They are a spy division. Is a little like saying "the FBI is the firearms division" because FBI agents are armed.
- jessaustin 10y agoDon't worry about it. GP is "clever" sarcasm, inspired by electoral bitterness.
- anigbrowl 10y agoWell intelligence-gathering is the CIA's nominal job. You could say this policy of using malware is a policy for the government as a whole, and I'm inclined to agree, but if you're going to have an agency devoted to espionage (and you'd be an idiot not to because every other country does) then it's unreasonable to expect them not to use whatever tools are available. I have to say comments like this sound like you also worry that teaching CIA agents to pick locks might result in an increase in property crime, a position that's hard to take seriously.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]