4 ms·
“I believe that global warming is real and I believe we are just dumping tons and tons of CO2 into our atmosphere that is heating up the globe,” That kind of p
by tambourine_man 10y ago
“I believe that global warming is real and I believe we are just dumping tons and tons of CO2 into our atmosphere that is heating up the globe,”
That kind of phrasing always bothers me. It's not a matter of belief, it's science.
I'd wager a climate change doubter has no faith crisis when relying on relativity to get an acurate GPS location for their Uber.
- logancg 10y agoI think Cassidy would agree with you. I think it's strategic wording to sell his mission and motivation better. It also potentially engages people who continue to think it's a subject of belief. That may provide an opportunity to educate them.
- hyperbovine 10y agoNit: GPS "relies on" trilateralization to calculate location, while correcting for the effects of relativity.
- Toboe 10y agoNit Nit: But you have to rely on those corrections to be able to rely on GPS
- alphapapa 10y agoIt's not a matter of belief, it's science. Unless you have performed all of the science yourself, all the way "down to the turtles," belief--faith--is involved. You have faith that the chain of science is complete, that each person along the chain has done their part correctly, and that nothing significant has been omitted. It's especially a matter of belief if you are relying on computer models--nay, the claims about computer models. You trust that these models were written by people with integrity, who would not adjust them to achieve a desired outcome, and who are competent enough to do it correctly. Or do you have access to the source code, and a huge cluster to run it on? If you take these claims at face value, that's faith--by definition.
- TillE 10y ago1) We're releasing huge amounts of CO2 into the atmosphere. 2) This CO2 does not magically disappear. We can measure it. 3) We know how CO2 interacts with infrared radiation. You can test it yourself with an FTIR machine. This is all extremely simple. The computer models are just about getting some precision about the broad cause and effect which is utterly obvious to anyone who knows a little physics.
- alphapapa 10y agoRegarding 1, how much CO2 does humanity emit compared with how much CO2 the oceans emit?
- bluesign 10y agowhy does this matter? We are breaking the equilibrium.
- alphapapa 10y agowhy does this matter? Because anthropogenic CO2 is a tiny fraction of oceanogenic CO2. It's like sneezing into the wind: it does not change the direction of the wind. We are breaking the equilibrium. What equilibrium? Equilibrium would imply a stable climate, but the climate has been changing for millions of years, long before humans arrived. Are you saying that the climate wouldn't change without humans?
- yongjik 10y ago> Because anthropogenic CO2 is a tiny fraction of oceanogenic CO2. Really? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_sink https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_sink > Oceans are at present CO2 sinks, and represent the largest active carbon sink on Earth, absorbing more than a quarter of the carbon dioxide that humans put into the air. Next time you want to equivocate, at least try something that can't be falsified by ten seconds of Googling.