3 ms·
I don't endorse racism by any means, but there's an overarching concept that a persons home is their castle, and you have broad discretion to control who and wh
by Spooky23 10y ago
I don't endorse racism by any means, but there's an overarching concept that a persons home is their castle, and you have broad discretion to control who and what goes on in your home. In most jurisdictions, you have a broad legal right as a person renting out your downstairs or a room to turn down tenants for any reason.
Airbnb wants to have it both ways. They demonstrate their contempt for the law by pushing accountability for illegal renting to their "hosts", but where they have a messy situation where there is bad PR for them, all of the sudden they care about how "hosts" follow rules about discrimination that may or may not even apply to them.
This is yet another example of why AirBnb is a ridiculous business that shouldn't operate as it does. Dealing with the issue in a way that would be compliant with the law would require that they acknowledge that many "hosts" are really running as hoc hotels, so they roll over the individual homeowners or tenants subletting their homes.
- vorotato 10y agoIt seems like the because of the broker aspect the law might apply to them, however I'm not a lawyer. It's certainly I would think, a bad idea to say I'm not renting to this person because of their race. You're basically inviting a racial discrimination lawsuit. "The Fair Housing Act covers most housing. In some circumstances, the Act exempts owner-occupied buildings with no more than four units, single-family housing sold or rented without the use of a broker, and housing operated by organizations and private clubs that limit occupancy to members."
- Spooky23 10y agoIs it housing or a short term rental? Is it a room in your home or your home, or a second house? I agree with you that behaving like this is a generally bad idea -- and in the specific case of this poor woman it is reprehensible. But the broader context is important too. Why is AirBnb making itself the arbiter of what laws need to be followed and what do not? Why is discrimination a bright line that cannot be crossed, while fire code violations in multi-unit AirBnb quasi-hotels are not? We end up in these troubling scenarios where we allow companies and individuals to pick and choose what rules are ok.
- vorotato 10y agoAs I understand it and I'm not a lawyer but I do work in housing finance, housing, rentals, and short term rental all fall under the fair housing act. This is purposefully broad and done so because of how discrimination is such an affront to human rights. That being said Airbnb is merely hoping to avoid any class action litigation, which will likely come as a result of tenants viewing the broker as not putting a good faith effort to preventing discrimination. The broker, after all, cannot intentionally facilitate illegal behavior to make a profit, that would just create puppet mafias. They probably have figured they are less likely to be found guilty of facilitating the illegal behavior of fire code violations because fires are just a lot less likely and a lot less externally obvious to the broker. TLDR: The laws are laws whether Airbnb says they care about them or not, but should Airbnb put forth a good faith effort to prevent flagrant lawbreaking on their website they'll likely avoid being seen as legally culpable.
- BMorearty 10y agoI work for Airbnb but don't have inside knowledge of this case. If it seems like "all of a sudden" we care about discrimination, then we're not doing a good enough job of communicating. At every level, this company cares deeply about discrimination. As the article states, this host was removed because they violated the non-discrimination policy that we believe makes our community better. It was not because of the law. (We operate in just about every country but our terms are the same worldwide.) This is not new. We have repeatedly, for years, removed hosts who we've determined are discriminating. I can understand if from the outside it seems self-serving and seems like it's being done for PR, and I probably can't convince anyone who has made up their mind to be against Airbnb. But if you could look inside the company or be a fly on our walls, you would know. We all care extremely deeply about discrimination and we are more than willing to remove discriminatory hosts from our platform to make a better, more welcoming community.