5 ms·
> It costs billions to get up and running, and isn't modular. One of my primary concerns with nuclear power is that it's very much dependent on the actual orde
by paganel 10y ago
> It costs billions to get up and running, and isn't modular.
One of my primary concerns with nuclear power is that it's very much dependent on the actual order of things carrying on as usual, meaning stable Governments, skilled technicians available etc. What would have happened if Syria (a secular state until not that long ago) had had civilian nuclear plants? Answer: they would most probably have fallen under the hands of either ISIS or an Al-Qaida offshoot. We had the same issue after the Soviet Union collapsed. Had the political uncertainty and power vacuum continued for much longer into the '90s then nobody knows what could have happened to their civil nuclear plants.
- boomboomsubban 10y agoHow is this more concerning than the raw amount of weapons that a lying around everywhere? Giving them access to cheap power or a potential local weapon doesn't seem like that pressing of an issue.
- paganel 10y ago> How is this more concerning than the raw amount of weapons that a lying around everywhere? Is this a serious question? Conventional weapons are a lot less deadly if captured by the wrong people compared to nuclear-based installations.
- lithos 10y agoIf someone has the tech to convert nuclear fuel to weapons, they are a short step from converting raw ore to nuclear weapons.
- paganel 10y agoYou don't necessarily need to convert the nuclear fuel to weapons, you just need to blow the whole thing up, which ISIS is more than capable of doing, and then see how the winds carry the radio-active clouds 3,000 km away. For example see this map: http://i.imgur.com/zlRGSs3.jpg http://i.imgur.com/zlRGSs3.jpg , more especially Austria.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThey're not. The power of nuclear weapons is like 1% the fuel, 99% complex electronics you need to have them actually detonate with meaningful yield.
- justin66 10y agoI'm not quite sure what you're driving at but the bomb that destroyed Hiroshima (the "gun" design, Little Boy) did not rely on complex electronics.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIt also required quite a lot of fissile material and wasn't all that powerful. Dropped on lower Manhattan, it wouldn't even reach midtown Manhattan. See for yourself at http://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ http://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/. I was actually quite surprised to realize that a "city" in 1940s was something much smaller than what we call a city today. The point I'm aiming at is that nuclear weapons are (still) something expensive, hard to make, and useful only for nation states with large military budgets. Going for dirty bombs would be a better strategy for terrorists. The second point I'm aiming at is that nuclear is not as scary as Hollywood seems to have made us believe.
- justin66 10y agoI'd venture to guess that most people would regard the quarter of a million people dead and billions in property damage from an airburst over Manhattan (what that site indicates would happen with a Little Boy-style device) as quite significant. Losing the NYSE might just possibly have a small effect on the overall economy, as well. > The point I'm aiming at is that nuclear weapons are (still) something expensive, hard to make, and useful only for nation states with large military budgets. The fissile material is quite expensive, and requires a state-level actor's resources or cooperation to create or obtain. You're not going to take fuel directly out of a reactor and use it in a proper bomb. If that's the point you were trying to make, okay. On the other hand, a simple bomb is not difficult to make given the necessary, weapons-grade material. I cannot even imagine why you think a terrorist organization would not find such a device useful.
- boomboomsubban 10y agoChernobyl killed 38 people directly, and led to a moderate increase in cancer rates. I'd say 1000 bullets could outkill it.
- mikepurvis 10y agoThe concern for me is that a nuclear power plant and its associated spent fuel storage pools are a facility that requires an unwavering commitment to maintenance and upkeep by highly specialized personnel—not just for as long as you want power out of it, but for decades beyond. Coal isn't like this. If you stop needing power, you stop feeding it coal, and the machinery can sit there idle, doing no further harm. I'm not a coal-booster, but I absolutely see the concern about regime change and commitment to the safety of a nuclear installation. Between Trump and Brexit, how confident are we that even first world nations are capable of taking on the long term responsibility for such a project?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Recurecur 10y ago"Between Trump and Brexit, how confident are we that even first world nations are capable of taking on the long term responsibility for such a project?" Extremely.
- dukeluke 10y agoThis post did nothing to advance the conversation. There's nothing thought invoking, no statistics, and no argument. Please provide substance to your posts in the future.
- nebabyte 10y agoWKUK did a skit on this; well, more a commentary on the social/political contract, but still related and amusing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NKERC6F7mSM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NKERC6F7mSM
- ElijahLynn 10y agoThat was a fantastic video! Thanks for sharing it.