8 ms·
Can Many-Worlds Theory Rescue Us From Boltzmann Brains?
- Symmetry 10y agoI'll point out that Botlzmann brains are only something you would ever think about in a universe going through a graceful heat death rather than the equally likely big crunch or big rip scenarios.
- bmh100 10y agoDark energy suggests that a big crunch is unlikely.
- snowwrestler 10y agoCan one unprovable and arguably imaginary idea save us from another unproveable and arguably imaginary idea?
- devoply 10y agoYeah it's sort of like religion all over again just in a different context. It seems that imagination for humans is more or less inescapable and in the end even if we get really nerdy about it, we end up in the same place we started. Undetermined and all about what you want to believe to be true.
- Moshe_Silnorin 10y agoSaying "Yeah it's sort of like religion all over again just in a different context" is sort of like a religion, but in a different context. It seems that making grand dismissals is more or less inescapable, and in the end we get really nerdy about it, and use atheistic language while we make our psuedoreligious grand dismissals.
- devoply 10y agoIn another words, it's all good.
- ythn 10y agoSwap out prophets for celebrity "scientists"/eccentric billionaires, and swap out scripture with speculative pseudo-scifi publications, and you have a new religion!
- cestith 10y agoScientology is decades old. At this point so are the supposed real-life Jedi, too. And aura healers. And... So you're not just on to something, there are actual examples to back you up.
- unit91 10y agoI agree but I take an even stronger view: religion provides answers to The Ultimate Questions: who am I? why am I here? is there a God (or are there gods)? what happens when I die? etc. So while the various naturalistic metaphysical theories are not themselves religious endeavors, there is a great deal of overlap with religion in terms of their applications to the mind.
- ythn 10y agoOnly artificial recursively self-improving super intelligences know the answer
- snowwrestler 10y agoSpeaking of arguably imaginary ideas... :-)
- Symmetry 10y agoThey're unprovable but they're also straightforward applications of basic physical theories to scenarios far afield from what we've previously encountered. Induction isn't a logical inevitability but it is the basis of science and as a matter of practice we assume that if E=mc^2 has been true up to now it will continue to be true. And likewise that it continues to hold true for very large and very small values of m even well beyond values we've experimentally verified. You can posit that E=mc^2 wouldn't apply to masses larger than a galaxy, or that Schrodinger's equation doesn't apply to things with momentums that make their wavefunction undetectably small. Or that, in the steady state, some regions of a microcanonical ensemble won't be swept. But induction says that the equations that apply at one scale apply at another.
- HeavenBanned 10y agoAs a philosopher, I'm hesitant to just let the physicists off the hook with decoherence. Maybe decoherence as we know it is merely a gap in knowledge and the current dogma that the interference pattern is unobservable may be in fact untrue. Maybe it WILL be observable but we haven't gotten there yet and we're just guessing in the meantime using complicated statistics.
- snowwrestler 10y agoThe point of my snarky comment wasn't that these ideas should be rejected outright. My point is that since neither idea can be rejected or accepted based on current scientific understanding, it seems silly to ask whether one can "save us" from the other. EDIT: I'm also somewhat disappointed that no one on HN has dinged me for spelling "provable" two different ways in one sentence (which I just noticed and will leave for the humor value).
- Moshe_Silnorin 10y agoMacroscopic decoherence (and therefore many worlds) is a straightforward prediction of the Schrödinger equation. It's not something you can just dismiss as imaginary.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoApart from that minor "Let's create an infinite number of universes out of nothing" problem. Mathematical solutions are never guaranteed to be physical, or even potentially realisable.
- bmh100 10y agoWhat is your preferred interpretation? Mine is pilot wave, treating the wave function as a purely mathematical and nonphysical concept.
- Filligree 10y agoPilot wave theory still requires the wavefunction to exist, with all the same detail as many-worlds, all the same computations. It just then picks a particular timeline and declares that this one is real, these are real particles, and everything else is shadows on the wall. It's thus incompatible with computationalism. I consider this scenario improbable.
- bmh100 10y agoMy limited understanding is that the pilot wave is more of a concept regarding embodied in the exact state of the universe. In other words, the pilot wave is the seed in the pseudorandom number generator of the universe.
- Filligree 10y agoI'll admit it does get a little philosophical, but: No. The "pilot wave", in pilot wave theory, is a mathematical object identical to the universal wavefunction of the many-worlds interpretation. As such, if you believe that computation is all is required for consciousness to exist (and there's no separate "is real" tag on the math), then it's an incoherent concept. I fall on that side myself, but I can't convincingly argue that it's the right philosophical stance to take. I've yet to see anyone give a proof, it just seems most likely.
- gus_massa 10y agoThe Many Worlds interpretation is equivalent to the Copenhagen interpretation. I prefer the Copenhagen interpretation. But since both are equivalent, both are equally good or bad. So one of the ideas is not "unprovable and arguably imaginary", it is only weird, extremely weird, as weird and all quantum mechanics. (I'm not sure if they are using some extension of the Many Worlds interpretation. If it is not 100% equivalent then there must be an experiment to decide between the interpretations, and get a Nobel prize.) I agree with you about the other idea. Moreover, I'm annoyed by > A Boltzmann brain existing is more probable than a universe existing. What are the odds? 10 to 1? 1000 to 1? How did they calculate it? Are the odds based in some experiments or only unsupported handwaving?
- arunix 10y agoCan a Boltzmann brain exist in the absence of a universe?
- empath75 10y agoI think the logical incoherence of the Boltzmann Brain saves us from it. 1) What we know about the world leads me to the belief that it's far more likely that a collection of particles in a thermal equilibrium have randomly and temporarily formed into a brain for an instant, than that the entire universe exists as I believe it to. 2) Since I am extremely likely to be a boltzmann brain, everything I know about the world is illusory, and nothing outside of my own mind exists, and my memories don't represent reality. 3) Therefore, everything I thought I knew about the world which led me to believe that I am a boltzmann brain is unlikely to be true. 4) I am unlikely to be a boltzmann brain.
- bmh100 10y agoBut you also have to consider the probability of the brain containing precisely the self-consistent information that would allow you to develop a false theory. To me, the probability argument is more compelling than attacking the circular nature of the idea.
- Strilanc 10y agoStep (3) is not valid. You can't use "I would reason badly in case A" as a proof that A can't happen. At best it's an argument that, when deciding what to do, case A isn't worth worrying about. But that's different from asserting case A can't have happened.
- contravariant 10y agoStep 3 doesn't quite work. If not being a Boltzmann brain implies that you are a Boltzmann brain, then it is irrelevant that this logic no longer works under the assumption that you are a Boltzmann brain. The first is enough to show that not being a Boltzmann brain is impossible, the second is not enough to cause a paradox.
- bmh100 10y agoIntuitively, I feel that it is extremely more probable for a Big Bang, giving rise to life that knows science, to randomly occur than for a Boltzmann Brain, self-consistently simulating the evolution of such a universe for billions of years, to randomly occur. However, it is hard for me to explain that feeling more precisely. Maybe it's like this: it is much more likely to randomly simulate a game of chess where a pawn gets promoted to a queen than it is to randomly generate a move history from random characters, which resulted in a valid chess game of a pawn getting promoted to a queen.
- stavrianos 10y agoWe don't need it to simulate the universe for a billions of years. We just need it to simulate your belief that it happened for a couple of seconds.
- bmh100 10y agoYes, a belief which relies on logical validity and self-consistency of memory and thought, which would in turn need to be the result of a "simulation". And by "need", I really mean "much more likely than the alternative" of producing such a state otherwise.
- dri_ft 10y agoBut are you really scanning all of your beliefs for consistency at every moment? Couldn't you just be presented with a simulated feeling that your beliefs are consistent? Wouldn't that be enough? It's certainly plausible that a Boltzmann brain could have that.
- contravariant 10y agoAnd in the end, does it really matter? The person I recognise as myself isn't the Boltzmann brain, but rather the person the Boltzmann brain thinks it is. Even if the Boltzmann brain swiftly disintegrates I will still live.
- jwilk 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines
- richardlong 10y agoGiven the internal and logical consistency apparent in this life, it stands to reason the Boltzmann brain would have to be simulating the entire thing -- the thought processes of other people, countries, wildlife, the movement of the stars, and so on. Absent some calculation cost, which Boltzmann brains don't seem to provide, there's no reason everything wouldn't be fully rendered inside the Boltzmann brain. At some point you just have a God, and are right back at old-timey religion, not that there's anything wrong with that.
- macawfish 10y agoIs a Boltzmann brain by definition unstable? Over what timescales? While it exists, does it function within its presumably more stable context, or is it somehow magically disengaged from its context in a way that necessitates instability? What I'm getting at is that the idea of a Boltzmann brain, as juxtaposed with a "real brain", seems a little too " classical binary logic" for a universe that evolves. Perhaps some of our most resilient features have evolved with the help of spontaneous Boltzmann-brain-like intuitions, whims, or setups, but have been since then integrated in a stable way. I imagine a Boltzmann brain to be something like a spark, but not immune from outside interaction or influence. Am I missing something? What happens if a Boltzmann brain "catches on"? Is it still a Boltzmann brain, now that it has contextualized itself in a stable way? Was it ever a Boltzmann brain? This also comes down to the meaning of "randomness", and I don't think the mathematical jury is quite out on that subject.