This argument is no different when Joel first wrote the test, so to say the question is "out of date" isn't very accurate. Furthermore, I would suggest that fi

This argument is no different when Joel first wrote the test, so to say the question is "out of date" isn't very accurate. Furthermore, I would suggest that five years ago people were arguing about whether open plans were better. Seems to me like that argument is over, with the resolution being "nope, but they're cheaper!" I personally often like to work in public areas. Having an office doesn't keep me from doing that, but it does let me retreat when I want to.