3 ms·
> I strongly disagree with this. Everyone with more than 2 users in their organization can benefit from AD/LDAP support, if it is easy to set up and administer.
by mschuster91 10y ago
> I strongly disagree with this. Everyone with more than 2 users in their organization can benefit from AD/LDAP support, if it is easy to set up and administer.
You will always need a server. And aside from QNAP NASes (which aren't cheap) there are no "set it up and it runs" options which are free and easy to maintain.
Cheapest option, hardware wise, would be a RPi but it will melt when you try to use it as a filer. Next option is a PC, which adds at the minimum 200W of 24/7 power requirement, not exactly cheap given today's electricity prices.
Software-wise you have the option of MS Small Business Server which clocks in at 200€ but definitely requires a PC plus someone who can set it up, and a Linux variant with Samba which is free but definitely requires someone skilled.
Then there comes the maintenance - with Windows there shouldn't be a problem with regular updates, but with Linux... not so much.
The maintenance and the energy consumption of a server is what keeps small businesses off AD.
- ansible 10y agoNext option is a PC, which adds at the minimum 200W of 24/7 power requirement, not exactly cheap given today's electricity prices. I've got just the hardware for you: http://www.tedunangst.com/flak/post/new-home-router http://www.tedunangst.com/flak/post/new-home-router https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16856205007 https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E1685620... There are various other NUC type devices based on laptop chipsets (or you could just use an old laptop with hardware Ethernet and a large-enough hard drive... built-in battery backup!). The software maintenance is definitely an issue, but I don't see Windows Small Business Server being any better than Linux, there's still a lot of mysterious things that can happen.
- zokier 10y agoFreeIPA and RPi should be pretty good combo for prosumer/SB market. RPi has definitely enough horsepower to run a small domain, and FreeIPA bundles all those admittedly gnarly pieces into one neat packages
- mschuster91 10y ago> RPi has definitely enough horsepower to run a small domain Maybe enough for the DC part (i.e. Kerberos server, LDAP server, ntpd) but not enough for a fileserver given the Pi is still 100 MBit and limited by its USB ethernet connection, as well as that it doesn't have eSATA, mSSD or any other high-performance storage option. Plus SMB/CIFS implementations are known for performance issues. Also, a Pi is nowhere near reliable enough for running something as mission critical as an AD server. Good luck when your micro-SD card gets corrupted, e.g. due to power fluctuations. And you WILL get corruptions, especially if you have high write throughput.