3 ms·
And I think a lot of people misunderstand the Innovator's Dilemma, even Clayton to some extent. I've heard people say things like, "We should eat our lunch bef
by kenjackson 16y ago
And I think a lot of people misunderstand the Innovator's Dilemma, even Clayton to some extent. I've heard people say things like, "We should eat our lunch before someone else does". The problem is that starting lunch too early can result in you losing your core business too quickly.
For example, if MS is making $15B a year in client products right now. And over time, against Google and such, that number will drop $1B/year until it hits $3B. Or they could accelerate that drop, such that it drops $3B per year, but they can generate $1B dollars per year by eating their lunch.
While it may be "fashionable" to be the cutting edge company generate $1B/year on some cool technology. It's actually prudent to fight against the new technology as the incumbent for as long as you can. And try to find totally new markets, rather than eating your own lunch.
- dhimes 16y agoThe problem is that starting lunch too early can result in you losing your core business too quickly That's exactly why it is a "dilemma," and not a "lack of vision."
- lincolnq 16y agoWhat does eating lunch mean in this context?
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoUndercutting your own existing, successful business with a new business better prepared to go into the future. Specifically, think about Office. MS could have released a web-version of these at a price-point that competed with other web office stacks. Doing so would have put them in position to succeed in the Internet world, but it would have gutted their Office profits in the process. Given their cost structures are set up around those profits, no sane business person will make that decision. Hense, the dilema: you can see you are going to die to companies who change the rules, you know what you would need to do solve that, but the economics of doing that would mean anybody who really tried would be out on their ear.
- dkarl 16y agoThe problem is that when you fight against the new technology, you mis-educate your own people. Ideally, Gates would have liked to denigrate the web and promote desktop apps to the outside world while pounding a completely opposite pro-web message into his own stuck-on-the-desktop developers. Unfortunately, with a company as big as Microsoft, it's impossible to keep the two messages separate.