2 ms·
Is that just a long-winded way of stating that government can be a useful tool to interfere with price discovery, which we should only do when we are certain it
by justin66 10y ago
Is that just a long-winded way of stating that government can be a useful tool to interfere with price discovery, which we should only do when we are certain it's called for?
- dmix 10y agoI'm pretty sure there is never a good use-case for centralized price controls. As I mentioned, the biggest problem is that it causes shortages. There are tons of historical examples of this happening in other markets (for example: rent control resulted in a shortage of affordable housing in NYC and Toronto, only making the problem worse not better, as landlords had no incentive to invest in new properties). Having shortages of medication is a serious risk. The need for price controls is usually caused by other problems... lack of competition/monopolies, a weak economy, lack of a proper social safety net for poor people to afford basic necessities, etc. But my comment was hardly just about price controls. It is a critique of the default instinct people have to look to centralized control (typically regulations) to solve problems in a marketplace.
- justin66 10y ago> I'm pretty sure there is never a good use-case for centralized price controls. Wow. The most obvious counterexamples involve resource allocation during wartime.
- dmix 10y agoDo you mean a 'total war' situation? I highly, highly doubt there will ever be a total war again. Economic sanctions would destroy a country before that ever happens. And if it gets that serious we have thousands of ICBM to handle the job. Millions of westerns won't be dying any time soon. But regardless that is an extreme rare example. Not what I'm talking about at all...
- nickik 10y agoIt can be argued that avoiding price controls in wartime would vastly improve the performance. The problem is usually that to be able to avoid it and still fight a total war, you would have to massively up the tax rate and that is usually not possible. You are correct, it is a usecase for them.