3 ms·
Yes, this guy gets it. This community gets it. Not everything needs a global singleton like a blockchain or DHT or a DNS system. Bitcoin needs this because of
by EGreg 10y ago
Yes, this guy gets it. This community gets it.
Not everything needs a global singleton like a blockchain or DHT or a DNS system. Bitcoin needs this because of the double-spend problem. But private chats and other such activities don't.
I have been working on this problem since 2011. I can tell you that peer-to-peer is fine for asynchronous feeds that form tree based activities, which is quite a lot of things.
But everyday group activities usually require some central authority for that group, at least for the ordering of messages. A "group" can be as small as a chess game or one chat message and its replies. But we haven't solved mental poker well for N people yet. (Correct me if I am wrong.)
The goal isn't to not trust anyone for anything. After all, you still trust the user agent app on your device. The goal is to control where your data lives, and not have to rely on any particular connections to eg the global internet, to communicate.
Btw ironic that the article ends "If you liked this article, consider sharing (tweeting) it to your followers". In the feudal digital world we live in today, most people speak must speak a mere 140 characters to "their" followers via a centralized social network with huge datacenters whose engineers post on highscalability.com .
If you are interested, here I talk about it further in depth:
https://youtu.be/WzMm7-j7yIY https://youtu.be/WzMm7-j7yIY
- ytjohn 10y agoI have been researching along these same lines for a while now as well, ad-hoc/mesh network messaging. My use case would be an amateur radio mesh network. For a while, I was investigating running matrix.org servers on raspberry pis, connected to a mesh network without internet. And that does work, the closest I've come to a great solution. But I had never heard of scuttlebut until now. This looks even more ideal. In amateur radio, everyone self identifies with their call sign, this follows the same model. For amateur radio, there is a restriction against encryption (intent to obscure or hide the message), but the public messages would be fine. Private messages (being encrypted for only those the right keys) might be a legal issue, so for a legit amateur radio deployment, the client would have to disable that (or at least operators would have to be educated that private messages may violate fcc rules).
- throwaway32445 10y ago> And I predict, in the next 5-7 years we're going to see a lot more power to the people (...) through decentralized social networking tools / platforms that can run in new types of topologies. (at 9m53s: https://youtu.be/WzMm7-j7yIY?t=9m53s https://youtu.be/WzMm7-j7yIY?t=9m53s) How do you see this happening in such a relative short amount of time? Who (else) is going to do this? Is our culture predisposed to do this, and, if not, is there a strategy to overcome this culture factor? edit: for clarity