4 ms·
It's getting downvoted because there will always be open source OS'es that can run open-source emulators. Since all computers are also Turing machines. Dystopi
by pmarreck 10y ago
It's getting downvoted because there will always be open source OS'es that can run open-source emulators. Since all computers are also Turing machines.
Dystopian reasoning in the 2 parent comments is slippery-slope fallacy.
- seba_dos1 10y agoYeah. I'll sound cheesy now, but - open your eyes. There are plenty of locked down computers around us in everyday use that often need to be literally exploited in order to turn into something resembling a device controlled by its owner instead of manufacturer. One easily noticable group of them is called "mobile phones", for instance.
- the8472 10y agoAnd even when you root your phone you still don't have full control over it. Just see the recent broadcom wifi exploit.
- JetSpiegel 10y agoIt's already a reality on mobile, the slope is already greased.
- wpietri 10y agoI don't think "in theory you could be free, even if in practice you aren't" is much in the way of freedom. Is there even a full open-source OS for the iPhone? If so, I have never once seen anybody using it. In practice, Apple has full control over the apps their users run, and they are not shy about using it. It has been 10 years, and this picture has been getting worse, not better. Clearly other vendors have looked at that and said, "30% of tens of billions of dollars per year, plus the ability to screw over competitors? Yes please!" This is definitely not the slippery-slope fallacy, because all he's really positing is that corporate control will continue to tighten at the current rate. If you want to demonstrate otherwise, you have to prove it. And I think the only thing you've proven so far is that there will always be a few greybeards willing to boot up an old Linux kernel on obsolete hardware, which does not sound like true freedom to me.
- pmarreck 10y ago> Is there even a full open-source OS for the iPhone? Heh, not officially, but this does exist: https://ios.gadgethacks.com/how-to/exclusive-dual-boot-android-your-iphone-ios-7-0161123/ https://ios.gadgethacks.com/how-to/exclusive-dual-boot-andro... > because all he's really positing is that corporate control will continue to tighten at the current rate. "The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it." - John Gilmore (https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/John_Gilmore https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/John_Gilmore) In this case, I argue you can replace "censorship" with "too much regulation" or "too many controls" or "too much DRM" or "too tight a walled garden" because what they all share, are being benefits to centralized control and profit at the expense of the convenience and joy of innocent users. This was largely the promise (and threat) of Bitcoin, by the way. An Internet-native completely digital pseudonymous payment system that is nearly impossible to regulate. There is (or will be) a direct relationship between the stringency of capital controls and the below-the-radar usage of cryptocurrencies. If you expect capital controls of innocent people (which, disclaimer, I really effing abhor, as a person who once had their main bank account locked out for a month sans any evidence of criminality) to get worse/more onerous, and you want to make money off it, you should probably own some crypto.
- wpietri 10y agoAnalogizing to a 20-year-old quote about the Internet is not really proving anything. Even about the Internet, really; the loss of Net Neutrality and allowing ISP datamining may have significant effects. But it definitely doesn't prove anything about software. If you want to claim that the currently slipping slope will stop at some point, you'll have to name that point and defend it.
- asveikau 10y agoDo you remember the days when it was hard to get Linux on a machine? When I started using it a majority of modems didn't have Linux drivers, so your average PC user could not get on the internet with Linux unless they very carefully selected a replacement. Then the same issue repeated itself with WiFi drivers in the following decade. We are at the mercy of hardware vendors to run open source OSes - they can giveth and they can taketh away. Imagine a future where most hardware you can buy only loads signed kernels and bootloaders. That's not a totally theoretical outcome. It came pretty close to happening during the Windows 8 cycle.
- Declanomous 10y agoYeah, about WiFi. I wanted to bring my desktop somewhere where I wasn't sure I'd have ethernet. "No problem," says I, "I'll just buy a USB adapter." I have 802.11ac in my house, and it's pretty nice, so I thought I'd get an 802.11ac adapter. So I run down to the store, and pick up an adapter that says it works on Linux ON THE BOX. I look online, and it is using the RTL8812au, which people have reported working in Linux. Turns out none of the drivers compile on Linux 4.4+. I managed to mess around with the makefiles and the code a bit to get most of the compile errors to go away, but it was still hanging on a few files that I couldn't make heads or tails of. So I went on Github and downloaded a version that had been updated to account for this device in the past 4 days. No dice. All told, I probably spent 6 hours trying to get the stupid adapter to work. I would have returned it after hour 1 and bought a more expensive Atheros or Intel adapter, but they literally only make 802.11ac adapters in the mini-pcie form factor. On one hand, the device was USB 3.0 instead of USB2, was made by Tenda (who kind of cut corners), and all the fixes were either for Ubuntu or Arch, and I'm using Fedora. On the other hand, it's 2017, 802.11ac has been out for a while now. I kind of expect to be able to find at least one 802.11AC adapter that works. Most of the 802.11ac adapters that other people had gotten working only worked in 2.4ghz mode, or only worked with 802.11n. So that was pretty disappointing. It felt like it was 2006 all over again. (It really would have felt like 2006 if Xorg had broken during this process.) It's not like I bought "outdated" hardware either. The FCC approval is dated December 19, 2016. So you'd expect the driver to compile on a recent kernel. I think I'm just going to buy an 802.11ac router, run it in client mode, and velcro it to the top of my case.
- pryelluw 10y agoI dont think there will always be open source software. All it takes is a new law to be passed and then become illegal.
- the8472 10y agoYou don't have to make open source illegal, all it takes is a requirement that all devices sold must come with secure boot keys by a government-approved vendor. And of course the vendor can't hand out descendant keys to open source projects because those could be modified to do anything that could get the key yanked by the government.
- TelmoMenezes 10y ago> It's getting downvoted because there will always be open source OS'es that can run open-source emulators. Since all computers are also Turing machines. Not really: - Just because some computational device is Turing-complete, that does not entail that it can perform the computations that you want in a practical manner. For example, my brain or even many biochemical mechanisms in my organism are Turing-complete. That does not mean that it is feasible for me to run some open-source emulator on them; - In practice, modern computers are no longer Turing-complete in a strict sense. They come with opaque processors that can be commandeered by third parties to interrupt or interfere with computation that the users wishes to perform. Open-source software cannot solve that problem. > Dystopian reasoning in the 2 parent comments is slippery-slope fallacy. Arguing that a given bad situation is likely to get worse does not constitute, by itself, a slipper-slope fallacy. It that were the case, no argument that led one to conclude that something will become worse would be valid. This is obviously absurd. In this case, there is strong empirical evidence that users are in fact losing control over their computational devices, when compared for example with the hardware commonly available in the 90s. This is objective fact. Conversely, you provide no counter-argument. Writing the scare word "dystopian" is not an argument.