2 ms·
"Unix considered harmful" I think "a demonstrably inhumane environment" may be my favourite description to date. There are many terrible assumptions in the de
by TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
"Unix considered harmful"
I think "a demonstrably inhumane environment" may be my favourite description to date.
There are many terrible assumptions in the design of the shell. Not least:
Use short commands (because they're quicker to type in theory, even though you'll waste time huge amounts of time in practice looking up commands and switches, because even the average god-like greybeard can't remember more than a few tens, and beginners have no chance)
Use terse switches (ditto)
Text is universal and computers are text processors (not true back then, even less true now)
Make no attempt at standardisation (switches are effectively random between different commands)
Quick hacks are better than a smart and structured environment (this was always bullshit and has caused endless grief, not just in Unix, but in everything touched by Unix)
Software forks are good (not in the shell, they're not)
And now computing is buried under the dead weight of accumulated cruft and poor theory and practice - probably forever.
But that isn't even the real problem. The real problem is that research into humane OS design seems to have stalled. CS academics could band together to design something smarter, better, and friendlier than the current shell. But there seems to be zero interest in starting a project that would generate huge productivity and reliability gains and also make low-level computing more accessible to ordinary users.
I find that baffling, and actually rather disturbing.