4 ms·
Yeah, perhaps I should retract the implication that the officials involved are corrupt. There doesn't have to be outright corruption for regulations to be an e
by nostrademons 10y ago
Yeah, perhaps I should retract the implication that the officials involved are corrupt. There doesn't have to be outright corruption for regulations to be an effective barrier to new entrants, and to prevent consumers from getting new services they want. All it requires is a cost of compliance that is greater than the delta in perceived consumer welfare, or even just a failure to pass the benefits to consumers of regulatory changes along to the regulators who are responsible for making them.
The broadband technology may have postdated CEQA, but Verizon already had the right-of-ways, utility poles, and trenches dug. My parents were one of the first customers for Verizon Fios when it launched. They ran our fiber line over the telephone pole that had been outside our house since it was built in 1960.
- rayiner 10y agoThose poles, conduits, and other rights of way are regulated by the FCC (or a state agency under delegated powers). See: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/47/224 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/47/224. Nothing is preventing another company from running fiber along those telephone poles, other than the fact that there isn't any money in it.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoIndeed, Google did an incredible amount of marketing to suggest otherwise, but at the end of the day, I suspect Google discovered the costs of laying fiber to the home and providing gigabit service wasn't recoupable at $60 a month like they claimed it was.
- awongh 10y agoIs that really true in practice? I've been reading lots of stories like these: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160314/09374733901/isps-are-blocking-google-fibers-access-to-utility-poles-california.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160314/09374733901/isps-... that talk about how hard it is for any new player to get access to these last mile infrastructure bits. Even if the rules of renting pole space are "fair" maybe we should be encouraging competition in this space by changing them.
- rayiner 10y agoThe existing pole attachment process is pretty comprehensive and effective, if a bit slow. It requires the pole owner to review the proposed attachment and do the "make ready" work of making space on the pole for the new wires. But there are legally enforceable deadlines for how quickly it has to do that: http://www.kelleydrye.com/getattachment/ea12262c-0564-45b2-93dd-7fca07ec9cb2/attachment.aspx http://www.kelleydrye.com/getattachment/ea12262c-0564-45b2-9.... The fight described in the Tech Dirt article isn't about Google being denied access to existing poles. It's over a "one touch make ready" ordinance that speeds up the process (which currently can take months) by allowing the new ISP to move existing wires while hanging up their own. The ordinances were passed specifically to facilitate Google's fiber deployment. One touch should probably be part of the federal regulation. But without such an ordinance you can still get access to the poles, it just takes longer. (There is a political dimension to the one touch fight that's probably not well known here. Currently, unionized telco and power company workers are guanranteed to get some work out of the process of a new ISP coming in. Under one touch, a new ISP could come in and hire a non-union contractor to do all the work: http://www.tennessean.com/story/money/2016/09/09/t-workers-face-uncertainty-one-touch-make-ready-vote-looms/89958322 http://www.tennessean.com/story/money/2016/09/09/t-workers-f.... It's not a good reason for holding up fiber deployment, but it's why the opposition to one touch laws has more traction than you'd expect.)