4 ms·
> Only if you define "better" in those terms. No, you can define "better" in pretty much any way and still be able to imagine possible worlds that are better t
by lisper 10y ago
> Only if you define "better" in those terms.
No, you can define "better" in pretty much any way and still be able to imagine possible worlds that are better than the one we live in. In fact, pretty much the only way you can define "better" that does not admit better possible worlds is to define this world as the best possible one. But that's a vacuous definition.
BTW, you do know that Romeo and Juliet are fictional characters, yes? They cannot prefer anything because they didn't actually exist.
- nemo1618 10y agoI am aware of that, yes. I was making an analogy. The point of the analogy is that, even though Romeo and Juliet would likely not have considered their world "the best of all possible worlds," we (the readers) do consider their world to be much better than they do (albeit not "the best"). In other words, the reason Romeo and Juliet do not consider their world to be "the best" is because they are only experiencing their localized part of the story, not the story as a whole. Likewise, even though individual humans suffer, that does not preclude the possibility that this is still the best possible story for us to be collectively experiencing.
- griffinmmahon 10y agoNah, it does preclude that possibility, because some of the suffering of those individual humans is entirely unnecessary.
- nemo1618 10y agoHow can you judge whether someone's suffering is unnecessary? Only the author of the story knows that, because only the author knows how the story ends and how the individual arcs tie together.
- randcraw 10y agoIs it unnecessary? Can you invent a tale of "star-crossed lovers" in a world that is "best" for the characters? I think their suffering is essential to the narrative. If so, perhaps their world is indeed "best" toward serving that purpose, at least for the audience.
- lisper 10y ago> [W]e (the readers) do consider their world to be much better than they do (albeit not "the best"). What??? I think you've completely missed the point of tragic fiction. R&Js world totally sucks (or it would totally suck if it were real). That's the whole point. We tell the story of R&J so that we can learn its lessons without actually putting real people through that wringer. The point of tragic fiction is to say: the world would suck if it were like this, so let's try not to make it like this. > Likewise, even though individual humans suffer, that does not preclude the possibility that this is still the best possible story for us to be collectively experiencing. "Best" by what quality metric? By what would make the best screenplay? That's a pretty horrific way of looking at the world. The best stories are often driven by the worst experiences. All fiction, both tragedy and comedy, is driven by conflict. Again, that's the whole point: humans invented story-telling so that we could engage in shared contemplation of possible worlds that we did not want to bring into reality in addition to those we do. Just because something makes a good story doesn't mean you would actually want it to happen.
- nemo1618 10y ago> The point of tragic fiction is to say: the world would suck if it were like this, so let's try not to make it like this. I think that is a narrow interpretation. Many tragic plays are catalyzed by sheer misfortune rather than anything we could draw a practical lesson from. Stories don't have to be educational to be deeply moving. I don't know what metric to use for "best," but I think "makes a good story" is preferable to "minimizes human suffering." You may find that horrific, but it's only horrific if you view suffering as meaningless and unnecessary. On the contrary, suffering is the engine of the world! Every achievement was motivated by a feeling of lack, and every happiness we enjoy is derived from our equal capacity for suffering. If you accept that, then the question is: "why, then, do we observe events of suffering that do not serve any discernible purpose?" That is, if this really is "the best of all worlds," then how can it contain meaningless suffering? That's a much better question. If you're in my camp, and you do believe that this is the best world, then the only option is to argue that there is no meaningless suffering. You can only declare something meaningless if you know its complete and total effect on the future. Since we don't know the future, we can't know for sure whether anything is truly meaningless. Now, we can't know the opposite either -- we can't know for sure if all suffering will eventually turn out to have been meaningful. That's where you either lean on your faith (if you have it), or take the agnostic position and declare the whole thing moot.