12 ms·
My favorite probability paradox has always been the Monty Hall problem[1]: Suppose you're on a game show, and you're given the choice of three doors: Behind o
by pmoriarty 10y ago
My favorite probability paradox has always been the Monty Hall problem[1]:
Suppose you're on a game show, and you're given the choice of three doors:
Behind one door is a car; behind the others, goats.
You pick a door, say No. 1, and the host, who knows what's behind the doors, opens another door, say No. 3, which has a goat.
He then says to you, "Do you want to pick door No. 2?"
Is it to your advantage to switch your choice?
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem
- haddr 10y agoI love this one, but I guess it must be less common to have such a problem in the real life. Or I'm wrong?
- justinpombrio 10y agoAs the Wikipedia article points out, that problem as stated is ambiguous. You need to know under what circumstances the host would have opened that door. The standard assumption is that the host always reveals a door with a goat behind it. However, another possibility is that: (i) if both of the remaining doors contain goats then the host reveals one of them; but (ii) if one of the remaining doors contains the car then the host doesn't open a door at all.
- kharms 10y agoThat variation doesn't make much sense as a paradox. If (i) you know that you should stay 100% success. If (ii) you know you should switch, 50% success.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- casta 10y agoIf you see this problem as a special case of another problem the answer becomes pretty intuitive. Suppose there are N (let's pick 1000) doors: Behind one door is a car; behind the others N-1 (999), goats. You pick a door, say No. 1, and the host, who knows what's behind the doors, opens N-2 (998) doors, excluding No. 1, which have have goats. Now there are only two doors closed, the one you picked No. 1, and one that was part of N-1 (999) doors. He then says to you, "Do you want to pick door No. 1 or the other one?" Is it to your advantage to switch your choice?
- std_throwaway 10y agoSuppose there's two doors. You can't decide. The host opens one. There is no goat behind that one. Now you know for certain.
- p1esk 10y agoIt did not get any more intuitive for me.
- bmay 10y agoSay there are a trillion doors and the host closes 999,999,999,998 of them. Which scenario is more plausible: 1) Your 1-in-a-trillion chance original choice just happened to be correct 2) The omniscient host picked the correct door
- nerdponx 10y agoAgreed. But here's the intuition: because the host never opens a door with a car behind it, the fact that he didn't open a particular door suggests that the door in question is the winner. Compare that to the initial door, which was selected blindly.
- Jedd 10y agoThe most succinct description I've ever found of why you switch was so good I made a note of it, though sadly not the provenance: "If you stay with the door you picked initially you succeed if the initial door has a car, which has a chance of 1/3. If your strategy is to switch then you succeed if your initial pick is a goat, which has a chance of 2/3."
- YCode 10y agoThis one is uniquely impressive in that often when first described to someone they will be all but certain it doesn't matter. Many I told were just about ready to argue their view to death and asserted the switch your choice conclusion is wrong despite them having no formal learning on the subject. This and the birthday problem effectively illustrate how intuitively bad we are at probability and statistics in general.
- j7ake 10y agoProperly applying Bayesian inference gives you the correct answer. Also the answer becomes intuitive once this scales to more than 3 doors (someone below already mentioned).
- denzil_correa 10y agoThe best explanation on the solution for this problem is from Numberphile. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Lb-6rxZxx0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Lb-6rxZxx0
- pmoriarty 10y agoOne of the things that interests me about this paradox is that when you're left with just two doors, the odds of either of them being the one with the car is 50%, so what does it matter if the one you happened to pick was picked before the host opened some other doors? How could that possibly affect the probability? It seems like choosing to switch would be admitting that the host's action has some kind of reverse-causality. The other thing I find interesting about this puzzle is wondering whether the people who find the arguments in favor of switching convincing are actually reasoning better than I am. If so, how are they doing this? What is it that makes those (allegedly superior) arguments convincing to them? The thing that kind of convinced me that the pro-switch arguments must be correct is that people have run simulations of this problem on computers and the switching strategy turns out to win in line with the pro-switch argument probabilities. But the tricky thing about probabilities and randomness is that such successes could be "just a matter of luck", as it were. Maybe they were wrong, but just got lucky. It's improbable, but still possible. Only mathematical proof independent of experimentation should be rock-solid correct. But mathematical proof seems to be a matter of being convincing enough to mathematicians, and no so independent after all, and that seems disappointing somehow. There's a feeling that mathematical proof should be above mere argumentative skill and the audience's susceptibility to being convinced.
- rndmio 10y ago> One of the things that interests me about this paradox is that when you're left with just two doors, the odds of either of them being the one with the car is 50%. Well, no, that's the point of this, it's not 50%. Before you pick there is a 1/3 chance of the car being behind any of the doors, so there is a 2/3 chance of it cumulatively being behind the other two. But there is only one car, so the set of doors you didn't pick must include at least one non-car. The host knows the location of the car so can always open a non-car door from this set. But still as a set they have a 2/3 chance of containing the car. By swapping you can effectively think of it as choosing both other doors. An easy way to get your head around this is increase the number of doors, say to 100. You pick 1 of those 100, the host opens 98 other doors, do you swap?
- kevhito 10y agoAlternate reality rules of the game are: nobody speaks, you pick any two doors you like, and you win the prize behind both of them. The odds of wining this game is obviously 2/3. Monty will gesture at you to point to a door. You point at the one you don't like. Monty will then show you one of your prizes behind one of your two chosen doors. Monty will then gesture for you to point to a door. You point at the remaining one you liked. Monty then gives you your second prize behind that door. Notice that all of the externally visible actions are identical to the original game.
- babyrainbow 10y ago>You pick a door, say No. 1, and the host, who knows what's behind the doors... I don't get this. Why does't the player insist that they open door no 1. Or is it part of the game that the host will open a different door other than the one the player picked... If the host knows what is behind the doors, and you are only given two chances, and the host can open a different door from what you picked, isn't your chance of winning zero? I don't get this...
- Retra 10y agoThe host's job is to create suspense by opening a door and offering a chance to switch. If they opened the door you picked first, there would be no suspense, and if they didn't know what was behind the door, they could show you that you lose, which also removes suspense. Turns out the host just ends up giving you more information that you can use to make a better decision.
- babyrainbow 10y agoCan you please explain this.. >If the host knows what is behind the doors, and you are only given two chances, and the host can open a different door from what you picked, isn't your chance of winning zero?
- z3t4 10y agoWhen we discussed this in school I quickly wrote a program that simulated it ...