11 ms·
The company behind Adblock Plus is acquiring micropayment service Flattr
- notyourwork 10y agoI have heard about Flattr a few times over the years and the idea sounds great in theory. Personally though I have never met someone who has actually used it, nor have I come across a place I frequent to use it. Would love to hear from other's about their experience with it.
- hutattedonmyarm 10y agoI've used it until about a year ago. In theory it's pretty good, but it never reached critical mass. Sites were not using it, because it didn't pay off and users weren't using it because you didn't have enough sites. Most things I used it for was blogs, quite a few of the ones I had in my RSS reader have/had flattr, and I supported them that way
- frik 10y agoFlattr was midly popular, then Patreon ate their cake. Not really a fan of both, as pretty much any hobby project that tried to monetize with Patreon lost its soul. If something is free and suddenly they want money for it, even if there are free alternatives that usually doesn't work. To each their own, some probably like it. I avoid reoccurring monthly costs, where possible and prefer one time costs or just good old advertisement.
- s73ver 10y agoI cannot agree with the idea that something wanting to pay the bills has "lost its soul".
- eropple 10y agoFor sure. I know a lot of Twitch streamers, and that is a full-time goddamn job. Wanting to be able to pay rent off of something that a lot of people like (and some of the streamers I know are north of 10,000 viewers when they're on, so while they're not huge they're not small either) is not a big ask. Yeah, there are alternatives--but if you like what you're watching and you're not hurting for cash, throw a buck a month in the hat.
- coldpie 10y agoI believe that's a risk and some projects have probably not managed it well. For what it's worth, I've been happy with the half-dozen or so projects I support on Patreon, so it's certainly not a universal failing. I think it's important for the creators to phrase it as supporting a work that is already free, rather than as charging for providing a service.
- aninhumer 10y agoI find Patreon funded content to be far less soulless than advertising funded content. (This comment brought to you by Audible).
- Paul-ish 10y agoYears ago when I tried to use it, the default currency was the Euro. As an American, doing the currency exchange on their website added friction to the transaction.
- qqrs 10y agoI like the idea of micropayments to support content. But I wasn't able to get Flattr to accept my credit card. Wasn't sure if it was because they are Sweden-based and I am in the US, as I didn't keep trying.
- notyourwork 10y agoI agree, I think this is a possible next maturation of content creation. People don't like advertisements, it is difficult to generally monetize online content otherwise from my understanding. It reminds me of a similar theme in the music industry, record labels make most money, artists make little. Whoever can solve this problem for the masses of content creators is surely bound to make lots of money.
- sfilargi 10y agoI don't think privacy and business mix. Personally, I have switched to uBlock Origin.
- id122015 10y ago+1 mee too.
- M_Grey 10y agoHaving run into this the other day: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14032410 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14032410 I'm inclined to agree. Clearly we're not alone in that sentiment, if you check the responses to their ill-conceived Twitter poll.
- losteric 10y agoMe either, but I'm curious to see where this goes. Ads suck but they are the defacto revenue model for the contemporary internet. Micropayments struggle partially because of the network effect... websites don't integrate because there aren't enough customers, and there aren't enough customers because most websites don't offer micropayments! ABP could help establish a sustainable micropayment model for the broader internet, and ultimately help increase privacy by addressing that root cause (revenue). Their customer base is significant and the value proposition of "micropayments vs nothing" is much more compelling than "micropayments vs ads". Imagine if Google adopted the same standard with Google Wallet, Youtube, and native Chrome/Android support... That said, I will continue using uBlock Origin in the mean time. Much faster than ABP :)
- cat199 10y ago> Imagine if Google adopted the same standard with Google Wallet, Youtube, and native Chrome/Android support... major industry players charging us all for per-youtube, etc. views of everything? hmm
- sfilargi 10y ago> Ads suck I don't agree with this blanket statement. It is not ads that suck. What sucks, for me, are ads that track me, ads that try to install malware, ads that are data and cpu hogs, ads that try to get my attention in anyway possible, ads that try to deceive me, etc..
- Illniyar 10y agoGood luck to them. I can only hope they manage to get people into paying for content and finally giving us alternatives to the terrible Ad based business model
- fencepost 10y agoI could see this being really good for them if they can get content creators interested independent of their own subscription options. There are sites that I go to 2-4 times a month (e.g. the Guardian, Wired, The Atlantic) that I'd love to support, but I'm not motivated enough to subscribe to the more expensive ones at $70/year (Guardian), $52/year (Wired, $1/week for the website with adblocker and it's separate from their print+tablet subscriptions), etc. The Atlantic at $24/year is a much more palatable option. I sometimes feel bad about not being able to support them with ad revenues, but these days I regard even the better ad networks as unmarked minefields.
- intrasight 10y agoExactly. I assume they are leaving a great deal of money on the table. But then again there are some smart people working in digital publishing, and presumably they have done the focus groups, etc. and found that readers aren't interested. But I also think if there was a secure, distributed payment infrastructure...
- brilliantcode 10y agoI like good investigative journalism and frustrated I can't pay to support it. For instance, WSJ endlessly sticks paywall for recycled news. Some journalists risk their lives for the sake of jouranlism. https://magazine.atavist.com/he-always-had-a-dark-side https://magazine.atavist.com/he-always-had-a-dark-side This was posted a while back on HN and we talked about how to support such journalists that take actual risks which needs to be rewarded.
- snthd 10y agoHow about the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (Panama Papers)? https://donate.icij.org/ https://donate.icij.org/ or https://www.gofundme.com/icijorg2017 https://www.gofundme.com/icijorg2017
- brilliantcode 10y agoThe real problem with the panama papers incident is that it's not clear whether people on that list have done wrong or anything interesting. Clearly, it was a way to hide away ill gotten cash for some people but it also has legitimate usage. I disagree the way it attempts to paint anyone who's name shows up in the panama papers as a criminal. Lastly, I want to pay for journalism that weaves together a highly interesting and entertaining story. I think part of the talent is not just telling the facts but weaving a good story that invokes emotional response. Panama papers did not meet those criteria so it's not as interesting as that paul le roux story.
- intrasight 10y agoI do like the idea of micropayments for content. But doing so under the auspices of an ad-blocking tool or any client-side tool smells too much like a protection/extortion racket. This should be handled by the publishers themselves.
- viewer5 10y agoThis actually gave me a bad taste until I read your comment, now I'm wondering if that exact situation might be a positive. Maybe it's a plus if they can say "We're hiding your ads, but here's an alternative" rather than simply "We're hiding your ads", full-stop.
- eveningcoffee 10y agoThe question is does the alternative provide privacy or replaces it with another tracking tool.
- dageshi 10y agoThe record industry was incapable of doing that, it had to be imposed by outside companies. The TV/Movie industry is incapable of doing that, it has been imposed by Netflix/Amazon e.t.c. I don't think large publishers are any more capable of building their own micropayments system than either of the other industries I cited, they've certainly had long enough to try.
- belovedeagle 10y agoOfftopic, but "etc." isn't an acronym or initialism so shouldn't have periods after each letter. It is an abbreviation for "et cetera". Fun fact: historically it could also be rendered &c., because, after all, the ampersand is itself just a ligature for "et".
- nathanaldensr 10y agoMaybe they're saying that the Elite Tauren Chieftain imposed it? :-D
- eveningcoffee 10y agoThe only question with micro payments is privacy. Otherwise it is no different from the current situation where majority of people are constantly logged in to Facebook or Google. Having a fixed identity is not desirable from multiple perspectives. It allows others to create a personal bubble around you and feed you with controlled information. When users can not be uniquely identified then Internet compares to the radio where you can be sure that every listener will receive the same information as you do. This means that users can not be individually deceived.
- TorKlingberg 10y agoI use uBlock Origin, but I hope they can make something good of this. Flattr is a good idea, but it never gained critical mass. Patreon is fine for hobbyists with dedicated fans, but not really for websites you only visit every now and then. Someone will eventually figure out "Netflix for News/Webstuff" so I support anyone trying.
- chaostheory 10y agohttps://brave.com https://brave.com is another attempt at this. You can fill a 'wallet' and have Brave distribute it to publishers EDIT: Brave also focuses on privacy and ad blocking. It's also already released.
- problems 10y agoBrave does a lot more than just that though - it's a full fledged browser built on Electron. On desktop I found it lacking, but on mobile it's an excellent option. A good compromise between the UI responsiveness of Chrome and the extensibility and privacy features of Firefox for Android.
- campbelltown 10y agoI finally bit the bullet and downloaded it. It's a pretty seamless transition from using chrome. I'm really impressed.
- btown 10y agoAmazon is actually EXCELLENTLY positioned to build a cross-domain paywall, a distributed Spotify for the web. Bezos owns the Post and knows the space, they have tremendous mindshare among developers (so the actual paywall API would be trusted out of the gate, hell they could even throw around AWS discounts to incentivize the cost of integration), and they have a strong ability to negotiate: "no, you don't get your own terms because you think you're a big news site, you get paid at the same rates everyone else does, because we're the WalMart here and our word is law." The only reason I can imagine they haven't done this already is that they're mired in endless bureaucratic debates about whether this should be bundled with Prime... -_-
- Larrikin 10y agoMy issue with flattr was that you actively had to tip. It would be nice to have a service that simply divided up a monthly allowance based on time and page views. Maybe even make it a white list service that ask at the end of the month which sites you'd like to contribute and a notification if you have not black listed a site but keep saying you don't want to contribute.
- pdelbarba 10y agoIt would be great to decentralize what is already done by Youtube Red and Spotify. I'm honestly surprised that something like that doesn't already exist. Allow sites to register against your payment service and then it keeps track of your visits and at the end of the month, shows you a report and distributes funds. Edit: another cool facet to this idea would be that you don't have to hound end users to join, the content providers that sign up will do that for you :) Edit round 2: looks like brave.com already does exactly this.
- cmdrfred 10y agoI'd like to see something that seamlessly ties a voting system (thumbs up/thumbs down) with a payment system and a social media aspect. Charge a dollar per thumbs up on a video, if a video has lots of thumbs ups than that means lots of people paid to say "this content is good" increasing the likelihood that it is actually good. All of the money can go to the content creator and the aggregator can make it's money with advertising.
- pdelbarba 10y agoThat would be interesting. I like the idea of keeping a fixed monthly amount so you don't have to worry about upvoting things often, you just do what you always have done, and your preferences support creators accordingly.
- CaptSpify 10y agoIt would also help with downvote-brigading if it cost something to vote it down.
- LeicaLatte 10y agoThe tip jar has to be the laziest of all the business models out there.
- treehau5 10y agoAnd yet how many of us waiters, waitresses, bartenders, baristas, cashiers, valets, etc have paid the bills because of the gratitude of others. It can work, especially when combined with social pressure to do so.
- degenerate 10y agoIt works, but neither party likes it. If tipping can be avoided, it will be. Ex: UBER
- dawnerd 10y agoUber made tipping even more awkward by not allowing it in app but allowing drivers to harass people for tips.
- CaptSpify 10y agoreally? I've used uber a lot and I've never had anyone harass me for tips.
- dawnerd 10y agoDepends on the area, but in tourist-heavy places, drivers can be very aggressive. Not to say every driver is bad, but it does seem a good majority will have at least a sign or sticker asking for tips.
- treehau5 10y agoI hate that Uber does not allow you to tip. I have had drivers who deserve way more than what they give them, and then I've had some drivers who deserve to have their licenses revoked. When I learned that Lyft allows you to specify a tip, I switched in an instant. Never missed Uber.
- astrodust 10y agoAdBlock is utterly useless these days. It doesn't block much. Some of the most astonishingly stupid ads from Taboola are let through as part of their "trusted" program.
- hartator 10y agoCheck out uBlock Origin. Ablock Plus doesn't have a lot of integrity.
- GunlogAlm 10y agoYou can disable the displaying trusted ads, no?
- Ajedi32 10y agoApparently when that happens with an "Acceptable Ad" you're supposed to report it so they can remove it from their whitelist: https://adblockplus.org/acceptable-ads#false-positives https://adblockplus.org/acceptable-ads#false-positives The only beef I really have with the Acceptable Ads program is that, since it doesn't discriminate based on ad content, only ad format, occasionally it will let through an ad where the presentation isn't annoying, but the content is. (E.g. A small static image ad that wouldn't normally be obtrusive, except it features a picture of a half-naked woman and the type of clickbaity text you'd expect to see on the cover of a tabloid.)
- hartator 10y agoIt feels weird that an ad blocking company is able to do aquisitions. I really recommend checking out uBlock Origin. It's a superior technical solution while not doing any shady deals or anything of that sort.
- eric_h 10y agoIt feels weird that an ad blocking company makes money by not blocking ads.
- brilliantcode 10y agoPeople are still using Adblock Plus? uBlock is the superior option because I can trust them not to sell out like ADP did.
- cpeterso 10y agoMicropayment tipping and subscriptions seem like features that should be part of the browser with standardized DOM APIs. Mozilla considered a website subscription feature back in 2014 called "Subscribe2Web". https://air.mozilla.org/subscribe2web/ https://air.mozilla.org/subscribe2web/
- khana 10y agoWrong.
- k__ 10y agoThey need to arm against Braves BAT and uBlock Origin. But it seems to me that BAT is the future.
- anotheryou 10y agoThere wher some scandals about them, no? Poor flattr.
- tuna-piano 10y ago-I feel strongly that the mental friction of any payment is the main issue. No matter the UI, payment model or price, micropayment services can't escape forcing mental anguish on the user with the question "is this worth it?" -This is why the unlimited Netflix / Spotify model is so good. Sure, the content owners could get more revenue from the heaviest consumers with a pay-per-click model, but only at the expense of all the sparse users would rather just pay a monthly fee than have to think "is this click worth it?" every time they want to consume additional content. -I'll predict that within the next few years, the major publishers will come together and form their own subscription company with a revenue share similar to Spotify. Not sure why it's taking so long, but that day can't come soon enough for me. Why are the publishers letting AdBlock Plus and other potential startups start a business that they could own? Here's my thought process: -People read tons of different publications. -Publications generally prefer subscription fees to ad revenue -People don't want to deal with micropayments -People don't want to pay for (or manage) multiple subscriptions -Giving away your product for free (purposely or with weak paywalls) and asking for donations is probably not a long term sustainable strategy. If the WaPo had 1 $25 subscriber and the WSJ had 1 $25 subscriber, the total industry revenue is $50, but each consumer only gets half the content (although much of the daily news content is roughly identical). If the WSJ and WaPo shared subscribers, the consumers would get double the content while the industry costs would stay the same. When consumers see additional value for their subscription dollars, they are more likely to sign up, increasing the number of potential customers. The industry will lose the revenue of the big spenders, who subscribe to both WaPo and WSJ... but I don't think many of those are digital subscriptions, and I think that's likely to be offset by the torrent of new customers.
- freshhawk 10y agoThis lines up well with all the research into social vs financial norms and human biases surrounding things that are "free".
- lkrubner 10y ago"I'll predict that within the next few years, the major publishers will come together and form their own subscription company with a revenue share" That's like saying all the hotel companies should come together and form a company to compete with Expedia and Orbitz. But the hotel companies did exactly that, when they formed a joint venture to run RoomKey.com. And the team at RoomKey built some amazing technology. But the various hotel companies, who jointly owned the joint venture, fell to fighting and they starved RoomKey.com of money and independence. So RoomKey.com could have transformed the space for booking hotels, but RoomKey was sabotaged by its owners. Which turns out to be a very common story for joint ventures -- each partner has its own internal politics, and when they form a joint venture the result is complete dysfunction. The moral of the story is: never underestimate the short-term greed and stupidity of big companies, and their ability to sabotage their own self-interest. So don't expect the major publishers to have much success launching their own subscription service.
- malikNF 10y agoNotice everyone is suggesting uBlock Origin. Please Please be careful installing uBlock https://www.reddit.com/r/ublock/comments/32mos6/ublock_vs_ublock_origin/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ublock/comments/32mos6/ublock_vs_ub... You should be installing "uBlock origin".
- hkmurakami 10y agoThe changes to Adblock Plus remind me of the changes to uTorrent over the years. Both did one thing well in the beginning, and slowly feature creeped (and added "features" undesirable to users) in a pursuit of grander ambitions.
- Balgair 10y agoI see a lot of people plugging uBlock Origin here. I am curious, has anyone gone through their code to make sure they are on the up and up. Look, I'm not saying that they are as scummy as ABP, all I am asking is if anyone knows, to some degree of sureness, that they are not also doing these scummy things too. The pressure on uBO must be pretty high.
- bricestacey 10y agouBlock Origin is written by gorhill, a user of much respect. I can't say I've heard of anyone auditing its source code, but you may find reading his comments interesting to make a better guess as to its legitimacy https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=gorhill https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=gorhill He seems pretty cool to me. And you can peruse the issues in the repo https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock I'm pretty sure you can't delete issues, so if someone found something and reported it you should be able to find it.
- Balgair 10y agoThank you!
- vit05 10y agoIt is not entirely clear how they will measure engagement and divide the budget among publishers. And how much is similar to Medium's new strategy? I prefer the strategy of Patreon and the new strategy of Spotify. Receive new content first when you pay something.
- Animats 10y agoAs I've pointed out before, all the enthusiasm about micropayments is from people who want to collect micropayments. There's no demand from people who want to send micropayments. There's a trend towards charging for timeliness. The movie industry would like an online model where streaming movies cost most shortly after release, then decline in price. This fits the "bargain bin at the video rental store" model. This works for Bloomberg, but they think minutes where the movie industry thinks months. "Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg terminal". That's the whole pitch of their financial news-gathering operation. Pay $25K a year and get the info a few minutes sooner. It's worth it for traders.
- gambiting 10y agoI work in the games industry and you would be surprised how often we get feedback for games which don't have any micropayments and which cost full $50 price - "please make a way to unlock everything quickly for a fee". I don't know if it's because people are so used to it because of stupid free-to-play games on mobiles or what.
- porjo 10y agoGlad to hear that Peter Sunde, Flattr's co-founder, has been able to move on with his life and have some success elsewhere after the Pirate Bay fiasco. [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Sunde#The_Pirate_Bay_trial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Sunde#The_Pirate_Bay_tri...
- red023 10y agoWow this is BAD this is soooo bad. The company behind Adblock Plus is very evil. - "Acceptable Ads" aka extortion money enabled ads enabled by default. - Their CEO made money with scamming sites. - They used to have a url correction "feature" that added Amazon reflinks to your urls without asking. - They lied back in the days about that companies can buy themselves onto the acceptable ads list. They claimed it was community decided, that everyone can get on it if the have no annoying ads. Then researchers found out Google payed them 10000€ already and stuff. - They are connected to various German Media companies that are pushing fake news with their ads on it ... Fattr on the other Hand was made by this awesome guy form the pirate bay who has a great vision for the web. The two now fit together at all if you ask me. I switched to a Addon Fork (True Adblock or something) that had the "Acceptable Ads" removed very early on. Then swiched to uBlock origin. So much better in EVERY way. Guy who does it does not even want (last I checked) donations, no BS company that wants to make money, is dishonest ... behind it. Technical faster, much better UI, better list of filters easy checkable on one giant page the way it should be. Can praise it enough. Seriously if you are reading this install uBlock Origin NOW!
- sciencesama 10y agoit means paid ads are coming back !!
- manigandham 10y agoWe tried something similar. Automatic adblocker with monthly subscription - block ads and distribute money by time spent per domain. Then bundle it as a simple "content" add-on on your ISP plan. Issue was getting either publishers or ISPs to pay attention - even though the math came out to it being more profitable for both in most situations.