4 ms·
> people have come to realize that infrastructure and private/for-profit don't mix well most of the time. It's too bad. Because singapore, which arguably has
by dnautics 10y ago
> people have come to realize that infrastructure and private/for-profit don't mix well most of the time.
It's too bad. Because singapore, which arguably has the world's best (or maybe second best, after Seoul) public transit system, is basically an entirely privatized system.
- snaily 10y agoWait, what? While the Singapore MRT (subway, metro) system is top-tier (along with Seoul and Hong Kong) it is not a deregulated free market wet dream. The public Land Transport Authority built and still owns most of the assets, and enacts strong regulation for the duopoly of service providers (SBS and SMRT) - not only on service levels, but also on operational processes. Even so, there's awkward UX quirks on the boundaries between lines run by the different companies. If anything, the Singapore MRT runs closer in spirit to a US taxicab system - that is, surprisingly regulated on a global scale.
- dnautics 10y agoYou are conflating unregulated with privatized, these are related but totally different concepts.
- sfifs 10y agoIt's is merely privatized in name. They're basically owned by the government. Shareholding just passed from one government body to another.
- dnautics 10y agoBoth comfortdelgro and SMRT are publicly traded companies, hardly "privatized in name". Can you buy shares in BART or Caltrain?
- sfifs 10y agoSMRT is owned (bought out) by Temasek. It's not traded anymore. Even before the privatization, Temasek owned a majority of shareholding http://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/business/majority-of-smrt-shareholders-vote-in-favour-of-rail-asset-sale/3166256.html http://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/business/majority-of-smr... Comfortdelgro is certainly widely owned - but they're into busses and taxi mainly, not infra heavy stuff like subways. For various reasons, Governments will make state owned companies publically traded. That doesn't mean they're not going to toe the government line in decisions if it has majority stake.
- dnautics 10y agoNorth East Line, Sengkang lines are run by ComfortDelGro. I wasn't aware that SMRT was bought out by the government recently (the last time I rode the MRT, last year, it was still private). It doesn't seem that the buyout was orchestrated as some sort of bailout, especially given that the systems seem to be solvent enough to support at least one for-profit. It, then, remains to be seen if refolding SMRT will result in a net degradation or net improvement in services... This will be an interesting 'control' experiment.