6 ms·
In other words nuclear never killed anybody apart from the ones it killed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_accidents_by_death_toll#
by tonyedgecombe 10y ago
In other words nuclear never killed anybody apart from the ones it killed:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_accidents_by_death_toll#Chernobyl_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_...
- blowski 10y agoI'm no expert on Chernobyl or power generation. But I think Chernobyl was the result of under-investment and poor management, whereas many of the deaths from coal are an unavoidable consequence of burning coal. Hence, you can say nuclear is safer as long as it's managed well.
- lostlogin 10y agoWhere is it managed well?
- blowski 10y agoI have no idea. I don't even know if it is practically possible to manage well enough to guarantee zero disasters. But there are many nuclear plants around the world that have operated with no problems. As I said, I'm no expert.
- LoSboccacc 10y agonew design exist that in case of disaster self contains under most conditions, trouble is it's very hard to obtain certifications needed for operation today as opposed to decades ago, so we're mostly stuck with old designs.
- ekianjo 10y agoby design already. all recent reactors have containment tanks to prevent radioactive leakage in a meltdown event.
- cjrp 10y agoThe UK seems pretty good at it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_the_United_Kingdom#Accidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_the_United_Ki...
- adrianN 10y agoChernobyl was the result of turning off all safety mechanisms and running the reactor outside of its design range to see what would happen.
- mirimir 10y agoThat was more-or-less my impression. Edit: See https://www.damninteresting.com/chernobyl/ https://www.damninteresting.com/chernobyl/
- davrosthedalek 10y agoIsn't the point that even with the current mixture of managment, it's safer? However, I don't know if these numbers include the long-term risk from storing/processing the spent fuel.
- vidarh 10y agoYes, we've demonstrated that you can basically mismanage plants into meltdown, and even then nuclear still ends up killing fewer people.
- blowski 10y agoOver a period of 50 years, you can mismanage a couple of plants and still kill fewer people. But not the entire industry.
- vidarh 10y agoI don't know what you are trying to say. 50 years of operation of hundreds of plants. We could have had a repeat of all of the accidents every year and it would still be one of the safest alternatives. Heck, we could have Chernobyl every year, and even based on the current worst case estimates of reduced life expectancy and counting every one of them as a death, we'd still not compensate for 1 Banqiao failure, or more than 1-2 years worth of coal. But we're not having a Chernobyl every year. What we are having is vast numbers of preventable deaths due to other types of power generation. We're talking millions dead over the last 50 years due to other types of plants.
- chadgeidel 10y agoI'm not saying you are wrong - I actually want to believe this statistic, but has anyone actually compiled the data to back this up? Specifically - "we could have Chernobyl every year ... we'd still not compensate for more than 1-2 years worth of coal"
- davrosthedalek 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Recurecur 10y ago"But I think Chernobyl was the result of under-investment and poor management" Chernobyl was extremely poorly engineered, Soviet Union style. Its major flaw was no containment vessel. Even then, it took real effort to make it fail, and it was all totally unnecessary. It was probably the worst testing-related disaster in history.
- petre 10y agoThe other major flaw of RBMK reactors is a dangerously high positive void coefficient of reactivity, which self reinforces the nuclear reaction in case of a loss of coolant accident. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Void_coefficient https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Void_coefficient
- thro1111111 10y agoIt only kills in case of a serious incident. Incidents are rare. Coal pollution and deaths are guaranteed
- mirimir 10y agoThat's not true. Coal pollution and deaths are guaranteed mainly by economic disincentives to using clean coal technologies. Even mercury and CO2 emissions could be captured. But then, that would likely make solar the clear choice.
- petre 10y agoThere is no clean coal. Coal mining alone produces environmental disasters. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_the_coal_industry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_the_co... http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Coal_mining_disasters http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Coal_mining_disasters Carbon capture and storage technologies also lead to 50..91% increased electricity costs. http://www.ekopolitan.com/climate/ccs-five-reports-realistic-costs-clean-coal-prepare-yourself-eye-popping-en http://www.ekopolitan.com/climate/ccs-five-reports-realistic...
- mirimir 10y agoCoal vs nuclear just isn't an argument worth making. Clean coal and clean fission are arguably about as likely, and would be about as expensive. Why bother, when you have solar?
- Recurecur 10y ago"Why bother, when you have solar?" Because solar is intermittent, and isn't practical at all in many parts of the world. The true environmental impact of nuclear is also arguably less, since solar requires a lot of space per watt produced by comparison. Next-gen nuclear reactor designs from Thorcon Power, Terrestrial and others are very near to perfectly safe, and also produce much less long-term nuclear waste than current designs. There will be an ongoing need for clean, high-density electricity sources.
- whiskers08xmt 10y agoI think the important difference is killing people when running as intended, versus killing people when disasters occur. In a way, a Nulcear power plant is similar to dam; when the dam breaks, it's a serious disaster, but as long as it runs as intended, humans aren't really at risk.
- mpweiher 10y agoYes, except that dam disasters have killed a lot more people than nuclear disasters.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- folli 10y agoBased on this list, even the summed death toll of these incidences is still massively lower than the single worst incident involving hydroelectricity: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banqiao_Dam https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banqiao_Dam
- rurban 10y agoNuclear killed a lot of people already and will for the next thousands of generations. There is still no proper prospect of how to get rid of that poison. That's not comparable to any other technology. That's why nuclear energy needs to demolished and banned.
- kaybe 10y agoRight now I feel that nuclear waste would be easier to handle than run-away greenhouse effect. Of course renewable is by far the best energy option in conjuction with using less. But all things considered I have given up hope that that will actually work in time - thus, by all means, we should build as-safe-as-possible nuclear power plants for the transition and shut down all fossil-based versions immediately.
- msvalkon 10y agoSounds like a terribly biased argument. Why would it kill for _thousands_ of generations?
- Turing_Machine 10y agoIt wouldn't. The OP has fallen victim to the "long half-life = bad" fallacy. A long half-life means that the material is less radioactive. By definition.
- vidarh 10y agoWe could take all the current nuclear waste, grind it up, and pump it into the atmosphere and there is still no reason to believe that it would lead to more than a blip in terms of mortality compared to coal. In addition to the reductions in air quality that kills vast number of people from coal - multiple Chernobyls every year - coal plants also pump vast quantities of radioactive material like uranium particles into the air. While nuclear waste would pump nastier stuff into the air, we know the consequences from Chernobyl: Most of it gets washed out and end up on the ground quickly. What doesn't tend to be less dangerous particulates like cesium isotopes. I'm obviously not suggesting that we should, but that pretty much the worst possible scenarios you can think of would still end up killing fewer people than coal.
- vidarh 10y agoThose nuclear accidents are covered in those numbers. The deaths from nuclear have simply not been very high, and the amount of energy created is massive. The result is a very low mortality per unit of power.
- Symmetry 10y agoIf every single nuclear plant exploded like Fukushima a productive lifetime like Fukushima had did that would still be only an order of magnitude more deaths from nuclear than from coal.