4 ms·
> That mindset seems to have changed. I dunno. State schools are only sometimes and somewhat cheaper than private counterparts, USPS is sometimes better in ter
by prostoalex 10y ago
> That mindset seems to have changed.
I dunno. State schools are only sometimes and somewhat cheaper than private counterparts, USPS is sometimes better in terms of price + speed, but many times it loses to UPS and FedEx, and anyone extolling the virtue of government-run service should get an option to change their medical provider to a VA hospital and report back in a few years.
- siidooloo 10y agoThe VA hospitals arn't the only government run healthcare in the world. Some others are good, some are bad. As with everything reducing the options down to two political choices just seems to makeveryone stop thinking about creative ways to solve problems. The uber thing is a good choice for Innisfil. They wouldn't have the money to roll their own ride share, and they can't afford the infrastructure to create a bus system.
- kennywinker 10y agoI'm a little more skeptical than you. I think it's interesting they are trying this, but uber being a good choice? We'll see. How many drivers sign up? Are rides available when needed? etc. Uber has shown they replace taxis pretty well, but have they shown they can replace public transit? Let's find out...
- NoGravitas 10y agoThe VA hospital example is an interesting one. I was at a town hall with Lindsey Graham where he used it as an argument against universal public healthcare. And clearly, no one wants universal public healthcare to be like the VA system -- where there are a limited number of understaffed government-run hospitals, and you get no choice as to your doctors. But the interesting thing is that absolutely no one is proposing that; what's being proposed is Medicare-for-all, where you get your choice of providers (pretty much any existing provider), and you pay the government for low-overhead insurance through your taxes. It's kind of a really obvious rhetorical bait and switch, but it seems to resonate with people.
- eastWestMath 10y agoI kind of hate how people on the right can cut government funding and then turn around and complain that the underfunded programs are functioning poorly.
- nickjarboe 10y agoSort of like how sometimes when government tries to solve a problem with a certain program and, if the problem gets worse, the solution suggested (and often tried) is to give even more resources to the program instead of trying a different program with different people.
- popinman322 10y agoRun option A in one location, and option B in another, then see which works better? Of course the key would be to replicate the results in other locations to make sure the "better" option actually pans out. Are there any policies that were built this way?
- NoGravitas 10y agoIn a sense, the US states are supposed to work this way. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis described them as "[Laboratories of Democracy][0]". For example, the health care system governor Romney instituted in Massachusetts (Romneycare) was moderately successful, and was adapted to nationwide use as the ACA (Obamacare). However, you can never really control for differences between the states, which means weak predictive value, and it's easy to argue about results. And given that the policies we're talking about are inherently political, facts and evidence don't necessarily contribute to policymaking. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laboratories_of_democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laboratories_of_democracy
- eastWestMath 10y agoI dunno, I'm pretty happy in a country where all the major universities are public and the healthcare system is socialized.
- 10y ago
- baursak 10y agoI wonder if there's some research on this somewhere. Organizations like NASA or the entire US military apparatus are also government-run, but you never hear free-market conservatives argue that US military sucks or is inefficient. On the other hand, there are plenty of private organizations that are universally hated, like Comcast, American Airlines, or Bank of America, which are also huge, bloated, and have tons of waste internally.
- sfifs 10y agoYou've picked poor examples. NASA just gave up on making rockets and arguably going private is going well for them. US military is quite famous for inefficiency. F35, B2, the 100 million dollar gas station in Iraq etc. Given the mess in the middle east, effectiveness is questionable as well.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> US military is quite famous for inefficiency. F35, B2, Those are private industry contracts.
- baursak 10y agoArguably, NASA gave up because it was funded poorly for decades. The rockets they're using are Roscomos rockets anyway, which is another government-run organization. US military is pretty effective in its primary function, but may not work as well when required to adjust to something like policing the population, sure. But that's a separate discussion. But yeah, those were just a couple of examples. There are plenty others. - University of California system, along with many other state universities. - Various three-letter spy agencies - Your local fire department etc.. I'd say that it doesn't matter whether any given organization is private or public. What matters is enough funding and semi-competent management.