5 ms·
Well, no. Not no one. But a government has the task to always use the least costly bid. And that can also be "build it from scratch". In this example, that’d b
by kuschku 10y ago
Well, no. Not no one.
But a government has the task to always use the least costly bid. And that can also be "build it from scratch". In this example, that’d be cheaper.
- ghaff 10y ago>In this example, that’d be cheaper. I'm no particular fan of Uber. But the idea that some small city government could create a more economical mobile taxi app seems unlikely to me. Now maybe this should be some shared local government infrastructure app but those sort of things aren't that common. I know I use checks to make various payments to my town because the online service actually costs me an incremental fee.
- notatoad 10y agothat's not true - the government has the responsibility to use the least costly qualified bid. if the government of innisfil feels they aren't qualified to build their own uber competitor (and they probably aren't) then self-building isn't an option on the table.
- prostoalex 10y agoThey already have a bus system built from scratch (as well as some metal parts, I assume). It's too costly: "Council considered the options for fixed-route bus service during the 2016 Budget deliberations ($270,000 annually for one bus and $610,000 for two buses), but it was determined that they would be too costly for the limited level of service that they would provide" But now you're saying they should buy vehicles, hire drivers, hire an iOS dev, an Android dev, a back-end coder, an ops team to watch the servers 24/7, a coder to handle payment back-end, a general manager to run the whole thing, pay AWS or GCP or a bare metal hoster for the servers, hire customer support to handle issues, pay Google (or Bing) maps commercial license fee, cover gas, maintenance, tires for all of the aforementioned vehicles and still have a lot of money left over from that fat $610,000 check to justify this project?
- wasted_intel 10y agothis. There are so many costs to operating a service like this.
- michaelmrose 10y agoWhat about situating a small number of operators in an existing office with existing phone lines and communicating with a small number of drivers using smart phones?
- prostoalex 10y agoDo operators' compensation packages, phone bills, office rental, equipment expenses and utility bills add up to an amount above or below $610,000?
- tzs 10y agoQuite a few of those items can be eliminated or reduced. I think people suggesting "build it from scratch" mean build a local Uber-like service from scratch, which like Uber would not own vehicles itself or pay for gas or maintenance. That gets rid of the buying vehicles, and covering gas, maintenance, and tires. Dispatching drivers could be done with pairs of text messages to the driver, of the form "pick up <NAME> at <ADDRESS>" and "drop off <NAME> at <ADDRESS>". The driver can tap on the addresses in those text messages to open them in the driver's smartphone's map application. That gets rid of the need for a commercial map license. I don't see any need for a payment back end. The town can require drivers to accept payments directly using one or more specified methods (such as Square). It probably doesn't need native iOS and Android apps. A web-based application should be sufficient. They already have a website. They should be able to add the back end stuff to that, so no new costs for ops or hosting. (That is assuming that they have access to the code for their site and can make changes. Their site is run by Pathfive.ca, which seems to be a company that specializes in building and hosting websites for educational institutions and local governments. It may be that the town only supplies content to fill in templates).
- prostoalex 10y ago
- tblair 10y agoI think you're almost right. If the federal government built it and amortized the cost across every town/city in Canada then it could very well be cheaper. I think siblings are correct that a one off would be a mistake though.
- terryf 10y agoGovernments indeed have the requirement to use the least costly bid. I wonder if that's actually part of the problem. Although, I really don't know how to make the rules better. Anyway, from personal, anecdotal experience, I have hired building contractors, first time around I took the cheapest offer, then two years later I needed the same work done for another room and then didn't take the cheapest offer (the one I took was about 25% more). The result could not have been more different. The cheap room has cost me more than 2x the original price, because I've had to redo most of it during the last 7 years and the second room shows no signs of needing any more work anytime soon. So, taking the longer term view, sometimes it's better to pay more upfront to get more quality. Except that quality in this sense is really hard to quantify and put into rules.
- pikzen 10y ago>a government has the task to always use the least costly bid. lolno A government has the task to provide the best service for its citizens with its budget. We've seen what least costly bid leads to: degradation in quality of all public services impacted.