5 ms·
Ted Talk Review Why people believe weird things
- swayvil 10y agoGo science? Science has become such a cult.
- beisner 10y ago*Pop science
- nonbel 10y agoI don't think any scientists consider TED talks a serious venue. Anyone who thinks they are learning rather than being entertained is mistaken. Not saying there is anything wrong with entertainment, it is just bad for us all when people confuse the two.
- throwanem 10y agoBut that's the whole point of TED. It's upmarket standup that you can feel like you're improving yourself by watching, which is why so many of the jokes suck - laughing might make the pretense impossible to maintain.
- AstralStorm 10y agoSometimes it does show serious topics that are or have been pretty seriously researched. It'd is quite easy to filter out the entertainment or worthless talks in fact: See if math or diagrams are used. Some talks are pie in the sky idea talks, essentially fuel for hypotheses. Filtered by talking about a serious subject but not showing math or diagrams. And finally there are stories. Spotted by a typically "human" talk and "social" topic. Not useful.
- JuliusKaiser 10y agoI can't tell if this comment is serious or not but I find it odd that people who know fuck all about science go around bashing people over the head with it.
- kapauldo 10y agoThey only bash in defense. Non scientific people have been bashing people over the head with non science for centuries.
- metaphorm 10y agoI think it's a serious comment lamenting the rise of "scientism" which is a dogmatic belief in the supremacy of rationalism and materialism. it's possible to be very opposed to scientism while also being very supportive of good science.
- thr0waway1239 10y agoThe dogmatic belief also has side effects. If you have ever been with someone you considered generally wise but also held on to some non-scientific belief, you know two things. 1. Taking away the non-scientific belief will cause a genuine vacuum in their life, and what comes in to fill it usually takes away the happiness they had earlier 2. The dogmatic folks don't put any/much importance on what a moving target science is, and how badly it conflicts with normal folks need for permanence. Some of them will scoff at this as "unwillingness to change", but realistically speaking no one likes change just for the heck of change unless it is an actual improvement of some aspect of their life. Society has "changed" towards embracing more materialism, but its side effect of less human connection is not an improvement that most people actually desire. So do you wish to be happy and contented? Don't expect science to give you an answer. If there is something that science cannot provide, then it is just another tool in your toolkit and will continue to co-exist with other things which can make you happier, no matter how "unscientific" those things are.
- joefourier 10y agoWhat's the alternative to rationalism and materialism? How can good science be practiced without rational reasoning and physical (i.e. material) evidence?
- javajosh 10y agoIt's more than just measuring outcomes. There's also a very strong belief among the scientifically minded that there should be a valid causal chain between one event and another. Astrology, even if it succeeded, would fail this test because there is no causal chain acceptable to science that explains why astrology was correct. Another test that must be met (and which many conspiracy theories fail miserably at) is the implication test: e.g., if that is true, then what else could be true? For example, if you believe Bush engineered 9/11, then surely he could have planted WMD evidence in Iraq (a far simpler conspiracy!) We never found WMD in Iraq, planted or otherwise, so the idea that Bush did anything special around 9/11 is just silly. One conspiracy which I think is particularly potent is the moon landing deniers. This conspiracy is tough to argue against because ultimately it really is unlikely that humans ever made it to the moon, and only a very few people were actually involved, and indirect video evidence is indeed capable of being faked. The best reason I can think of to argue against this is that far too many people would have had to be in on it for it to work, but really that's not very satisfying. (Next moon landing I hope the mission lays down an enormous silver blanket that can be seen by amateur astronomers and ordinary people are encouraged to come out and look through a 'scope for themselves!)
- hussong 10y ago(Next moon landing I hope the mission lays down an enormous silver blanket that can be seen by amateur astronomers and ordinary people are encouraged to come out and look through a 'scope for themselves!) OT, the old moon landing joke comes to mind: Astronaut: “Houston, we have a problem.” Houston: “What?” Astronaut: “The Russians painted the moon red!” Houston: “Well, do you guys have white paint with you?” Astronaut: “Yes. Why?” Houston: “Write Coca-Cola on it.”
- kombucha2 10y agoWell I mean for the moon landing hoax debate one can not only look at stuff left behind on the moon's surface let alone the fact that you can bounce a laser off of mirrors left on the surface to measure the distance from the Moon. It is also high unlikely that such items were placed there using automated methods.
- Theodores 10y agoRight now in the UK a new controversy has hit the headlines. Former London mayor Ken Livingstone effectively said 'Hitler = Zionism'. Obviously Ken Livingstone is now painted as worse than Hitler and hell-banned from public life forever, banned from being a member of parliament. With Ken Livingstone now thrown out with the truly crazy holocaust deniers into true David Icke world, the moral majority can then get on with the normal British fuzzy belief that 'Judaism = Zionism' (and vice-versa). Ken Livingstone may have wanted to explain how it came to be that the Palestine Mandate was the only place accepting Jewish immigration, for that to happen people in places like the UK had to be persuaded to not accept Jewish people but send them on to this new and Zionist 'homeland'. This mini history lesson covering several decades of history would never fit into a soundbite so the 'OMG Nazi!' so let's go with the moral majority and condemn this guy before we hear him out, okay? It is during these moments when we cast out some crazies that our own society digs deeper into things that become established cultural beliefs that can't be questioned. Right now in the UK that means more acceptance of blindly believing 'Zionism = Judaism'. It is easy to call out people for believing crazy things about moon landings but not to call people out for things like 'Zionism = Judaism'. Both are beliefs and also crazy misunderstandings of history.
- BuckRogers 10y agoI have a cousin who participates in this willing cognitive bias (really crazy ideas like flat Earth theory). Of course he only cherry picks from the unfounded conspiracy bucket that suits his chosen political view and what he wants to be true. Nothing rooted in any evidence review or similar approach.
- teslacar 10y agothis is a low-quality submission of a site that was created just a month ago and filled with affiliate links.
- Pica_soO 10y agoThe human species is just not build for logic. The process seems to be: 1. Search for a heuristic 2. Glue Logic Bits to the found heuristic 3. Generate a coherent backstory for heuristic 4. Query parts of the Backstory to check the heuristic. 5. If Part of the Backstory fall apart, reconstruct 6. If reconstruction fails, have a crisis. 7. If crisis continues, start to think it through for the first time or 8. Solve by discrediting facts (aka believes) Its very efficient. The only time, its not completely efficient is during youth, as this is the time, one has to carve out a thiefdom for oneself. Also a slight trait of intellectual sado machismo helps. I think to get normal people to think and question believes, education as proposed is a rather lousy tool, applied often too late. If you are tempted to question "everything" at 21, that phase of your life is almost over. Kindergarten age and first years at school, should be ideal- basically teachers should weave in wrong "days" where they would tell falsehoods, and reward those discovering and questioning.
- ctsciencenut 10y agoI would argue that the value of Ted Talks is their ability to spark conversation, and introduce people to new ideas. The quality of Ted Talks varies greatly, but on that wide spectrum, there are definitely a few things to learn. Is the science always infallible? Of course not, but I do think most Ted Talks provide a platform for learning.