5 ms·
I took a graph of a map of Manhattan and of the greater New York region and U.S. Geological survey’s print then looked at the streets and the contour levels and
by kbenson 10y ago
I took a graph of a map of Manhattan and of the greater New York region and U.S. Geological survey’s print then looked at the streets and the contour levels and I simply marked the 50-foot intervals to see what kind of an island was left, what kind of a bay. And then I walked around town with a tourist-map version of that that I had altered so that I could have a smaller version of that. I wandered around and I looked at the terrain and I looked at the streets running from like Fifth and Sixth avenues between the Empire State Building and say 20th — there’s a 10-foot drop there that would [in a 50-foot sea-level rise] be the tidal zone that is actually several blocks of the wetland at low tide, but underwater at high tide. Even though it would be the shallows with waves breaking.
That actually sounds incredibly fun. Taking pictures and photoshopping in water at the appropriate levels would be pretty cool too.
I have to say, not having been to New York and having nothing on the line, that actually does sound like an incredibly cool setting.
- johan_larson 10y agoWould it really be remotely cost-effective to take a skyscraper and refit the bottom three stories to be underwater? Sounds like a stretch. It would probably be cheaper to abandon low-lying areas and demolish the buildings there.
- kbenson 10y agoGiven that skyscrapers seem to describe buildings of 40+ floors, losing 3 is less than 10% of the total floors, possibly a little more of the total floor space given that upper floors may not have the same dimensions, offset by possibly fewer elevator shafts beyond certain points. If the bottom can be retrofitted to be very secure in water (extra concrete?), then I don't see why you would abandon it. It's not like you're constructing a whole new building and have to forego three floors, it's already existing and it's just a matter of putting the work in to make sure it's still usable. These things are all anchored into bedrock anyway, so it's not like you should have to worry about the material under the foundations shifting or eroding.
- myowncrapulence 10y agoYou aren't taking into account the degradation sea water has on infrastructure. The pounding waves and salt would most certainly make the buildings unsafe.
- virgil_disgr4ce 10y agoWell, the concrete that actually takes all the load would be safe; that's how pretty much any caissons or foundations in water are built anyway. Electrical delivery would have to be completely re-thought and redeployed. There wouldn't be 'pounding waves' since the rest of the city would be diffusing large waves.
- L_Rahman 10y agoMost of the things that skyscraper needs in order to be a viable structure - electricity, data, water, sewage - lie underground in systems that will not survive extended submersion beneath seawater.
- sevensor 10y agoKim Stanley Robinson has this problem in general. It's as if he just doesn't care about the science in his sci-fi. Engineering problems just get hand-waved around whenever they're inconvenient. Terraforming Venus? No problem! Ten kilometer tall spiral launch structures? Sure! A service corridor that goes all the way around a planet? Easy! I might be more inclined to forgive him if he could write a halfway interesting character, or manifest some semblance of a theme, but I'm just constantly disappointed. His work seems more ambitious than spaceships and rayguns, but it always comes up short. I'd rather spend my limited leisure reading time on mindless space potboilers like The Expanse.
- jessaustin 10y agoI've just about given up halfway through Years of Rice and Salt. If the writing is this pedestrian, I need more of a point than reincarnation! In truth, I'll probably read the whole thing eventually, since I bought the paperback already, but it's certainly not a page-turner.
- thriftwy 10y agoOr build a few dams here and there. Doesn't seem very hard to do.
- DavidAdams 10y agoI'm sure it would be much more effective to go full Netherlands on Manhattan and set up dikes and seawalls and pumps.
- johan_larson 10y agoHello, Reinhardt Gehrke here from Deutche Bank Municipal Bonds. We got the the RFP you sent around. We are eager to be of service of course, but is this a misprint? You want to borrow trillions of dollars for infrastructure projects?
- thriftwy 10y agoI don't think it would be prohibitively expensive. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_Petersburg_Dam https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_Petersburg_Dam to compare to - 15mi of dams built for a much less wealthy city.
- binarymax 10y agoAt New York prices it would be... http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/01/23/where-the-second-avenue-subway-went-wrong http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/01/23/where-the-secon...
- davidw 10y agoThey're certainly not skyscrapers, but that's what has happened with the lower floors of buildings in Venice, as they sink into the muck.
- WalterBright 10y agoIt's be cheaper to build a dike around the city.