5 ms·
> The thing that irks me about this the most is how it's the people who were doing exactly what they were told that got hurt the most. The good kids who went to
by ryandrake 10y ago
> The thing that irks me about this the most is how it's the people who were doing exactly what they were told that got hurt the most. The good kids who went to the best school they could get in to, studied whatever they were interested in, and if that thing happened to be literature or women's studies or a wide number of other things you might just spend the next 20 years figuring out how to live with debt you can't pay off.
Are they REALLY telling kids nowadays to go major in whatever interested them? Because when I went to college (nineties), nobody told me to just go major in women's studies or medieval history. They were telling me, "Study medicine or engineering because that's the only way it'll be worth the cost." The "what does a liberal arts major say" joke was very much a thing back then, as I assume it is today, now that job prospects for anyone not in STEM are even bleaker than when I went to school.
I don't think the guy who took out $100K in loans to study literature for 5 years was really doing exactly what they were told to do.
- austenallred 10y agoI graduated high school in 2008 and dropped out of college a few years later. I can honestly say not one person (other than my parents) ever recommended considering cost until after my Freshman year of college. The message that was pounded in again and again and again was "The best college at all costs." I'm pretty sure that's no longer the case - at least I hope so.
- antisthenes 10y agoThe classic case of "You can totally substitute being part of the capitalist class with education signaling!" Turns out you can not, at least not in America.
- agalarza 10y agoSorry if this is too personal, but did you think your parents were blowing hot air or something? This thread has been eye-opening from the perspective of all these comments who (apparently) had negligible guidance from a group of people (parents) who absolutely need to talk about debt to their kids. Maybe a silver lining in this topic is a generation of future parents who will have better conversations with their kids around going into debt for their college education.
- austenallred 10y agoNo, I think I swung too far in that direction if anything. I decided not to go to Stanford because it would be too expensive (one semester's tuition at Stanford is about one year of median income where I'm from, and that scared me to death). Only years later did I learn it would have been free because of how much (or little) income my parents had. It still upsets me to think about it. I now have an almost unhealthy fear of debt, to the extent that I don't even want to own a home until I can pay cash for it. (Though, to be fair, living in Silicon Valley right now with housing prices swinging $500k for what was a $500k house in a few years that fear may be somewhat healthy).
- rayiner 10y agoMy parents never warned me about education debt. I think it's a common trait among baby boomer parents - they're convinced it'll all work out and that education is worth any cost. Heck, my parents (who are both baby boomers and asian, so double whammy) are disappointed that my brother will not leave his Wall Street job to go to graduate school. They can't even articulate a reason how that would help his career--they're just disappointed that they both have masters degrees and he's just got a bachelors degree. The culture surrounding education in this country is not rational. It's a soup of optimism, hope, preconception, ignorance, and classism, along with the avarice of those in the educational establishment that prey on the foregoing.
- will_brown 10y agoI would add that baby boomers either: a) had parents able to pay for their entire education; b) were able to work their way thru school; or c) used a GI bill. In other words the market effects of guaranteed student loans that permited colleges/universities to charge any tuition fees they want and still have an endless supply of student with the funds to pay. Baby boomers can't imagine graduating with the equivalent of a mortgage payment and the reality of a non existent job market that might put them in a financial position to payoff their student loans much less pursue the American dream (house, car, kids). Meanwhile culturally we have a media that pushes the narrative of 4% unemployment; that young people don't want to own a car; young people don't want to own a house; and young people don't want to get married and have families. The whole thing highlights US culture from the individual to the collective willing to lie/embellish finances, which prohibits anyone from having honest conversations about guaranteed loans; actually costs of school; lack of jobs; non existent wage increases since the 80's...it's the culture of lying/masking finances and a debt fueled economy that lead to housing collapse and eventually will lead to a collapse in the student loan market.
- soverance 10y agoDon't feel bad, this exact same situation happened to me. I wanted to make a change in my life, and build a better future for myself. Everyone I spoke to said that going to college would be a great idea - there was no way the investment would not be worth it. My parents, my coworkers, my friends, and of course the advisors at my school - they all said it would be worth it. Not a single contradiction throughout countless conversations. So I went to college, at my own expense. I had no money, so I pulled federal loans like so many others. $25k and 1.5 years later, I realize that college isn't teaching me anything I could not have learned for free on YouTube/Google. Angry at the scores of people who deceived me into believing college was a good investment, and angrier at the institution for acting like predators upon my naive desire to succeed, I dropped out. When I spoke with the Dean of my school about how I was not feeling challenged after paying exorbitant fees, she said these exact words: "Well, maybe college just isn't for you." Needless to say, I now know more about my chosen career field than most average college grads, due to experience. However, years later I'm still $25k in the hole - the only significant debt I've ever incurred in my entire life. For me, college was a literal waste of $25,000+ and nearly two years of my life. At this point in my life, I'm telling everyone who asks that college is a complete waste of time, money, and energy.
- kamaal 10y ago>>I realize that college isn't teaching me anything I could not have learned for free on YouTube/Google. And yet not many people train themselves watching just these videos. You generally need a highly disciplined lifestyle to get your education through these means. >>Angry at the scores of people who deceived me into believing college was a good investment, and angrier at the institution for acting like predators upon my naive desire to succeed, I dropped out. They were most likely talking about your job prospects. Many things in college have gone from 'learning' to 'getting a degree for a job' a long time ago.
- randomdata 10y ago> And yet not many people train themselves watching just these videos. Although not that many go out of their way to train – period. You are already an exceptional case if you are thinking about furthering your education, be it through postsecondary schooling or Youtube videos. > You generally need a highly disciplined lifestyle to get your education through these means. More disciplined than than those who do not attain an advanced education at all, but not more than other avenues of gaining the same education. > Many things in college have gone from 'learning' to 'getting a degree for a job' a long time ago. The perception has, at least. The outcome hasn't. Job quality has measurably declined with increasing college attainment rates, and incomes have remained stagnant.
- watwut 10y agoI looked at college statistics once and overwhelming majority of students went for practicaly sounding degrees. Most students wanted study business in various forms. Antropologi and such had small number of students.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- paulddraper 10y agoHaving graduated high school in 2008, I don't quite understand it either. My school counselors were always saying "School is expensive; you need to apply for scholarships!" And then there was career day, when you quickly figured out some of the realities of work. Plus the STEM folks always said things like "The US needs more engineers!", "Math + science is important!". Perhaps because I lived on Florida's Space Coast (east central Florida, the general vicinity of NASA) my experience was different than most?
- ryandrake 10y agoI grew up in a shithole slate-mining town of less than 5000 people. Most of the people there couldn't even spell STEM. High school guidance counsellor was still extremely clear. "Do go to college, but for the love of god, major in Medicine, Science, or Engineering. Don't waste your time and money with anything else."
- mercer 10y agoI get the impression that it's mostly middle-class parents who told their kids to 'follow their heart' in this regard. Anecdotally, but very obviously so, both the working class and upper-class people I know were give more strategic advice.
- sjg007 10y agoIt works if your parents are doctors or dentists or otherwise wealthy. You can start a company with a safety net!
- austenallred 10y agoInteresting. I was probably right at tha sweet spot where we were making just enough to dream but not enough to be able to afford it :)
- geebee 10y agoThat's really interesting, and I'm not surprised to hear it. There was a study a while back concluding that it doesn't matter where you go to college - provided you major in STEM. It's a little more complicated than that (attrition rates, quality of curriculum), but overall, there is some truth to this - if you want to get a good job and keep costs down, majoring in engineering at a reputable state school can be a good way to go. There is an interesting corollary to this, though - it does matter where you go to college, provided you don't major in STEM. This might explain why "elite" US college students are so allergic to engineering. Why go to Harvard if it doesn't provide you with any advantage. If computer science majors from San Jose state have access to the same jobs, what good does Harvard do you? If you go to an elite college, you can major in economics and go to business school, or hell, major in international relations and go to law school. Jobs prospects for lawyers aren't generally great, but pay and prospects are very good for people who build a network at an ivy and go to a very elite law school. So your comment about a slate-mining town may be particularly relevant here. People who perceive college from a low income perspective see no point to majoring in Art History, because their chances of becoming a six figure salaried director or an art or cultural institution are basically zero. For a Harvard grad, however, especially one form an upper middle class family with the right connections, it may be a very achievable possibility. Similarly, why would. a Harvard grad be a senior CRUD bug fixer for 140k a year when he or she could run a nonprofit or cultural organization for a similar salary? Perhaps the value of elite colleges isn't so much that they can get you a higher salary, but that they can give you a path to a higher salary in culturally interesting job paths that are closed off to most of the populace. Harvard allows you a crack at that salary without having to be a senior CRUD bug fixer. As an aside, I think one big thing may be overlooked in the "it doesn't matter where you go if you major in STEM" study, because there's a lot under the hood if you only consider salaries. Just as there is a big difference between being a senior CRUD bug fixer for $140k a year and the "director of the American Heritage Film foundation" for $140k a year, there's also a difference between ostensibly similar titles in tech. It could be that elite tech graduates don't show a big difference in salary between grads from less celebrated schools, but do they end up with more autonomy, fewer deadlines, more interesting and exploratory work? "Machine Learning Specialist for Election Results analysis" for the NYTimes is a very different job from "Manager of Payroll and Benefits Data Migration" for a bigco. I'm not 100% convinced where you go to college plays no role in this.
- mercer 10y ago> Are they REALLY telling kids nowadays to go major in whatever interested them? Speaking for myself and the majority of people close to me (late twenties / early thirties, Dutch, mostly middle-class), that's exactly what we were told. Maybe around one in ten people I know went for STEM taking into account 'worth the cost', but it's hard to tell because most of them were pressured by their STEM-parents, so the reasons could've been different ("everything else is pseudo-science", etc.) People I know slightly older than me are even 'worse' in this regard and seem to have been raised with the 'keep studying as long as you like' and 'follow your passion above all else' model, which I was most definitely not raised with, so the perspective has been changing pretty rapidly. looking at the friends of my progressively younger brothers, the advice is more as you say: college is still 'the thing to do - if you can', but there is much, much more emphasis on job prospects. Part of the reason for that might be that the Dutch system has become more expensive though.
- epalmer 10y agoThis makes me sad and mad. I work at a small liberal arts university in IT and they are still telling the students to take whatever Arts and Sciences major. The school I work at does limit student debt and is a needs based school (they provide a lot of debt free aid in the form of grants), so that is good. But still majoring in the classics or art (especially from a school not known for art), art history and art management is not good for long term career options. I was in a meeting yesterday where a professor was lamenting that too many students are majoring in business and not arts and sciences. The interesting thing about that is our biggest alumni donors are business school majors and not A&S. If you can't major in a science, CS or engineering then major in business. I guess you can't fix stupid. I am so glad my youngest will be attending an engineering school next fall and will get a mechanical engineering degree with an emphasis in systems.
- xname2 10y agoIt is not just stupid. It is politically motivated. The idea that people should be responsible for individual decision making is somehow contradict with today's teaching in humanities and liberal arts. It is no coincidence that almost all of those professors are far left and they advocate students should just major in whatever they like, and at the same time they hate business school, and at the same time them agree with free college to everyone, etc.
- epalmer 10y ago@xname1 I agree. I see this up close.
- BeetleB 10y ago>If you can't major in a science, CS or engineering then major in business. When I was in school, people had the most contempt for business majors. The engineering people got respect for the technical difficulty of what they did. The liberal arts folks got respect for the intellectual pursuit. When we would look at a business major, all we would see was style with no substance. Almost all their education was geared towards appearances. When my undergrad forced all business undergrads to own laptops, the reason was "No one will take you seriously without one". A business professor told me that when students give presentations, he never listens to the content. His feedback is entirely about appearance (suitable clothes, appropriate voice, sexy presentation, etc). As far as actual content goes, you could more easily learn it all on your own than you could for, say, software or programming (since that is a concern in this thread somewhere). The primary utility of the business degree is: 1. Learn to look good. 2. Join a somewhat exclusive club.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- smoyer 10y agoI think there are a lot of interesting disciplines that make great minors but that are unlikely to allow the recipient to earn a living. If you're independently wealthy, it doesn't matter - otherwise you might find that humanities and STEM create an even stronger career.
- zaccus 10y agoI was in high school in the late 90s, and had absolutely no interest in college, at all. Not in medieval history, not in women's studies, certainly not in STEM, nothing. I just wanted to graduate HS and go learn a trade or something, and do music on the side. I never wanted to set foot in a classroom again. As dumb as that sounds, that's what I wanted to do. I got so much shit from my parents and teachers. Not going to college was unacceptable. You HAD to go, it didn't matter what you majored in or how much it cost. People who go to college get good jobs and join the country club, people who don't wind up in jail or something. I'm not exaggerating, that was the message. Of course that's just my experience, but for whatever that's worth, OP's experience is definitely consistent with mine.
- laughfactory 10y agoUh, as recent as six years ago, the common refrain around the state school I went to was "C's get degrees," and various statements about how all you need is the piece of paper. Hah. Plus, most people in college believe that just having a degree will entitle them to a six-figure job. Seriously. They've surveyed college students and found this to be true. Most don't realize that the average American household income is something like $40K. And even those who do, or who look at the distribution of pay for their chosen profession (though most studying English, American Studies, Art, etc. don't have a career in mind), may make fatal errors in evaluating the trade-offs. My wife and I were top of our class, both very bright (if I do say so myself), we knew about the income distribution (etc.) and we still screwed up and took out way more loans than we should have. Oops. Even on IBR our payments are the equivalent of a car loan for something nice. So now we're living with the consequences and it'll definitely shape how we talk to our kids. We'll lean on them heavily to live at home through college, go to community college for the first two years, and then finish at a state school. The less debt they have out of college the better their choice set.
- burfog 10y agoIn the early 1990s at least, high school guidance people in Massachusetts did in fact tell us to study whatever we liked. The claim was that the degree wouldn't matter, because you'd get a job that wasn't really determined by your degree. (in that case why get a degree, hmmm?) I think it made sense to the people giving the advice. That was how their lives had worked out. They got degrees, then ended up employed to give high school students career advice. (this is a low-paying job) For some reason it never occurred to them to say "Whatever you do, don't go down the path I went down!!!".