4 ms·
It seems that people are too hurried to read the article and are commenting the title and economics on general level. Basic macroeconomics did fine. Austeri
by nabla9 10y ago
It seems that people are too hurried to read the article and are commenting the title and economics on general level.
Basic macroeconomics did fine. Austerity side Alesina/Ardagna/Reinhart/Rogoff camp was utterly wrong. Spreadsheet errors in their studies that became basis for political action etc. Even after the austerity approach has been shown to be baseless in academia it continues to live in politics. Politicians have little or no ability to evaluate what they hear or read.
Backgrounder:
How the Case for Austerity Has Crumbled
http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2013/06/06/how-case-austerity-has-crumbled/ http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2013/06/06/how-case-austerit...
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y ago> Even after the austerity approach has been shown to be baseless in academia it continues to live in politics. Politicians nearly no ability to evaluate what they hear or read. Unfortunately, politicians and the general public often inject philosophy and morality into their view of finances and Economics. Beyond austerity, another example is drug testing and work requirements for entitlements. This is particularly problematic if automation permanently reduces the demand for actual human labour.
- empath75 10y agoThe problem is that politicians don't give a solitary shit about economics except when it gives them cover for doing what they wanted to do anyway. I hope no one genuinely believe that politicians wanted to enact austerity measures or shrink government because of economics. They do it because huge corporations and billionaires want less taxes and lower regulation so they can accumulate more wealth personally. Whether the economy as a whole or even a a majority of the people benefits is irrelevant to them. See also climate change.
- ksk 10y agoAs you probably might also agree, its a bit of both. Politicians don't go into politics thinking they're just going to accept donations and do whatever. They believe the stuff at some level and then get corrupted by the marketing/lobbying. The greater problem is that politicians are lay people, and even if they wanted to listen to economists they would first have to navigate the topology of the topic at large, and then understand the minutia of what each side represents. Now apply that for 10 different varied fields including foreign policy/medicine/science/defense/social issues/etc and you quickly realize that its just impossible for any one person to make accurate decisions across such a wide swath of issues. Maybe the answer is more decentralization, but then you cant do the moonshots where you need to pool in the resources/talents/labor across a large populace. Its all a shitshow to some extent. But then again, the world hasn't gone to shit just yet so at-least somethings working .. :)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nickik 10y agoIf you look now, you will see that this is simple not true. Countries with independent aggressive monetary policy did the best. Countries one the Euro that did Austerity did better then those that increased taxes. Maybe in Krugmans fantasy land you can do neither, but most people live in the real world. The IMF actually apologized to Britain after attacking it about cuts. It was Krugman that was horrible wrong on the US for example, anybody remember the "fiscal cliff" in 2013? Krugman and friends went large and issued dire warning, he even called it a "test for market monetarism". Not a single blip in GDP was observed and then Krugman promptly denied everything.
- dimitar 10y agoToday's prominent Keynesians certainly still advocate for independent aggressive monetary policy, but they also claim that fiscal policy matters a lot. In the case of the "fiscal cliff"/sequester, there was indeed fiscal tightening in the federal government, but it was offset by less tightening at the state level. Does that mean it was wrong to warn against cuts at any level of government? Of course not. Here is Krugman, acknowledging why this situation might be confusing. https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/06/22/2013-and-all-that/ https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/06/22/2013-and-all-th...
- nickik 10y agoKrugman, Krugman, when other people make evasion like that, then he attacks them so aggressively that you would think it was personal. When he does it, it is simply that people did not understand his arguments. If there was tighting before 2013 already, that makes his story even worse. Why did the economy continue to grow on path when there 4 years of tighting? Taking the 'cyclically adjusted data' to save his point is pretty fishy to me. Its also not true that Krugman always advocated for more aggressive monetary policy, they all claimed that monetary policy was 'out of ammo' and fiscal expansion was needed. He said that