3 ms·
I hope this isn't Science being taken to a irrational extreme, as tends to happen with news and science. This has incredible potential not only for the develop
by dijit 10y ago
I hope this isn't Science being taken to a irrational extreme, as tends to happen with news and science.
This has incredible potential not only for the developing world but also for sea travel and even the fact that we are running out of drinkable water in the west.
Only 2.5% of the water on the planet is even potentially drinkable. If we were able to convert even 1%. Crazy.
- larsiusprime 10y agoThe question, as always, is how much energy it takes to do the filtering.
- daveguy 10y agoYup. Sieve implies that the only energy required is that necessary to pump the water to a level above the filter. I highly doubt that is the case. Surely you need some significant pressure differential. Even with pores the size of proteins (100x+ larger) you need pressure.
- larsiusprime 10y agoIndeed, and even if we live in a magical world where it was 100% free to run the filter, you need to manufacture the filter in the first place, and it will have to be replaced at some point, so there is ongoing energy expenditure no matter how you slice it.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoIn any case, they have designed it for pressure. The article describes how pressure causes water atoms to line up, train fashion, and move water much much faster than without pressure.
- daveguy 10y agoright, the question is -- how much pressure is required? Is it the pressure generated by a 1 cm column of water (as is implied by sieve), or is it the pressure generated by a 1000 watt high pressure pump? The difference will determine whether they have groundbreaking technology or get a participation trophy. From the article it didn't seem like there was any sort of functional prototype.
- VygmraMGVl 10y agoWhat you're describing is Reverse Osmosis - pushing salt water through a water permeable, salt impermeable membrane. It requires very large pressures, on the order of 2-30 atmospheres of pressure. The membranes used are incredibly cheap, most of the cost of RO is the pumps and maintenance. IMO innovations on the membrane are pretty marginal to the cost of RO and are usually done for hype.
- ghaff 10y agoNote that reverse osmosis desalination through membranes already exists as the article notes. (Not sure what the current state of the art is as I haven't worked in this area for a long time.) The question in whether this has advantages to the desalination systems used today.
- SEJeff 10y agoGenerally speaking, the Aussies and Israelis have some of the top of the line Reverse Osmosis Purification Tech. I saw a ROPU (reverse osmosis purification unit) truck from the Army Corps of engineers when I was active duty US Army and that thing was unreal. You could ingest raw sewage into that thing and out would come drinkable, albeit not wonderful tasting, clean drinking water.
- callalex 10y agoThat only works when you have the luxury of burning massive quantities of oil on the taxpayers' dime.
- dijit 10y agoMy impression was that removing salt/saline from water is possible but it consumes a lot of energy to do so.