4 ms·
Yes it is true. If a miner has 51% hash rate, they can in theory steal your coins by rewriting history to replace the transaction that granted you the coins wit
by modeless 10y ago
Yes it is true. If a miner has 51% hash rate, they can in theory steal your coins by rewriting history to replace the transaction that granted you the coins with a different transaction that sends the coins somewhere else. Or, if your coins are too old for that to work, they can DoS you by refusing to mine on any block that includes your transaction, essentially rendering your bitcoins worthless.
In practice these attacks probably need significantly more than 51% hash rate, but there is some % hash rate where they would work. Of course, evidence that such an attack was being carried out would immediately crash the Bitcoin market, which would destroy the value of the miner's investment in mining hardware. (A crude form of proof of stake?) So it's hard to imagine that such an attack would actually happen in reality, unless it was carried out by someone with the intent to destroy Bitcoin and a few billion dollars to burn.
- dllthomas 10y ago> replace the transaction that granted you the coins with a different transaction that sends the coins somewhere else If the party that sent you the coins controls (directly or indirectly) >50% of the hash rate, they can reclaim the coins they sent you by omitting the transaction in a fork. No amount of hash rate lets you send coins to arbitrary places - you need the sender's key to sign a transaction.
- philsnow 10y agoreplace the idea of "stealing your coins" with "depriving you of your coins" and it makes more sense. the attacker wouldn't be able to deposit the coins in any desired wallet, but would be able to create a fork of the chain that omits the transaction that put the coins in your wallet.
- dllthomas 10y agoThat's what had been stated upthread a ways. The comment I replied to specifically spoke of replacing the transaction with another.
- modeless 10y agoThey don't need any keys to omit transactions and therefore deprive you of your coins, or hold them for ransom. It's true that they can't gain control of the coins without the keys, but that doesn't change the fact that you lose the coins. And they can potentially get keys from people by promising to pay them in stolen Bitcoin.
- dllthomas 10y agoI don't see how any of that has any bearing on my objection, whatsoever. My point wasn't to say "WAT NO BITCOIN IS INVULNERABLE". My point was to correct the inaccuracy in the bit of your post that I quoted, lest it confuse others and for your benefit as well if it reflected actual misunderstanding.
- erikpukinskis 10y ago> If a miner has 51% hash rate, they can in theory steal your coins by rewriting history to replace the transaction that granted you the coins with a different transaction that sends the coins somewhere else. Nope. Unless they have your private key, they can't sign your coins no matter how much hashing power they have. What they can do is unspend their own coins. So if they paid you BTC$1,000 and you gave them a yacht they can go back and send that money to someone else (double spending). But even that is limited: You can think of it like a race. With 51% of the network you're slightly faster than the other half. That means you can probably win disagreements going forward. But in order to change past transactions you have to go backwards in the race and then catch up again. Your ability to do that is proportional to how far back you are going and how much above 50% you have. If I want to go back one block (ten minutes) and I am going at 1.1x the rest of the network, it will take me 100 minutes to catch up (I can do 11 blocks to their 10). If I want to go back 2 blocks (20 minutes), it will take me 3 hours to catch up. You can see how this gets out of hand quite quickly.
- modeless 10y ago> they can't sign your coins They don't need to sign your coins. They need to sign the previous owner's coins. And they don't need to literally be the previous owner, they just need the previous owner's cooperation. And in fact they don't even need that: they can omit the transaction without knowing anyone's keys, and they've still deprived you of your Bitcoins. And they don't need to go back in time, they can omit all of your future transactions and thereby make your Bitcoins worthless, or hold them for ransom.
- DennisP 10y agoTrue, but the farther back they want to rewrite history, the more hashpower they need to outrace the rest of the network, since they're starting from further behind.