6 ms·
It's not decentralized if there's a trusted oracle. So many schemes in the "blockchain" space fail to understand the core problem Bitcoin solves. Bitcoin solve
by modeless 10y ago
It's not decentralized if there's a trusted oracle.
So many schemes in the "blockchain" space fail to understand the core problem Bitcoin solves. Bitcoin solves trust. You can transact Bitcoin with anybody and you don't have to trust a single person, even the sending party. If someone sends you Bitcoins and the transaction is 6+ confirmations deep in the blockchain, you can be certain that you own those Bitcoins and nobody else can take them from you without your private keys. Not a bank, not a government, not a miner, not a "core dev", not a full node operator. The only necessary assumption is that 51% of the hash power is not conspiring against you.
Whenever you see a new "blockchain" scheme coming out, ask yourself who you need to trust for it to work. If the answer is not "nobody", then it is not worth any more of your time.
- ntomaino 10y agoThere is not a trusted oracle
- modeless 10y ago"Oracles are trusted external actors tasked with providing continuous price data" https://github.com/makerdao/docs/blob/master/Dai.md https://github.com/makerdao/docs/blob/master/Dai.md
- csomar 10y agoHow can this work if there is no Oracle? Think about it, the price of USD/ETH has to be retrieved from somewhere. It's not in the blockchain, so it must provided in an Oracle.
- ntomaino 10y agoThere is not one trusted oracle. The oracles are determined by the MKR holders, and MKR holders can easily replace oracles if they act badly. MKR ownership is decentralized, hence I don't think it's accurate to say there's one trusted oracle.
- kobeya 10y agoPrediction networks. But I don't think TFA is actually doing what is claimed, by the looks of it.
- aakilfernandes 10y agoBitcoin has a trusted bunch of bootnodes hardcoded into each client. If they act poorly, its trivial to swap them out. Just like its trivial to swap an exchange rate oracle.
- kobeya 10y agoNot really. It also fetches new bootstrap nodes from DNS servers. But neither is very much trusted as it takes only 1 valid connection to relay other valid network addresses.
- csomar 10y ago> The only necessary assumption is that 51% of the hash power is not conspiring against you. That's not true. Even if a miner has 51%+ hash rate, they can't "steal" your coins. They can, however, prevent you from moving your coins but that puts them at risk of getting forked. (unless they have way more than 51% of the hash rate)
- modeless 10y agoYes it is true. If a miner has 51% hash rate, they can in theory steal your coins by rewriting history to replace the transaction that granted you the coins with a different transaction that sends the coins somewhere else. Or, if your coins are too old for that to work, they can DoS you by refusing to mine on any block that includes your transaction, essentially rendering your bitcoins worthless. In practice these attacks probably need significantly more than 51% hash rate, but there is some % hash rate where they would work. Of course, evidence that such an attack was being carried out would immediately crash the Bitcoin market, which would destroy the value of the miner's investment in mining hardware. (A crude form of proof of stake?) So it's hard to imagine that such an attack would actually happen in reality, unless it was carried out by someone with the intent to destroy Bitcoin and a few billion dollars to burn.
- dllthomas 10y ago> replace the transaction that granted you the coins with a different transaction that sends the coins somewhere else If the party that sent you the coins controls (directly or indirectly) >50% of the hash rate, they can reclaim the coins they sent you by omitting the transaction in a fork. No amount of hash rate lets you send coins to arbitrary places - you need the sender's key to sign a transaction.
- philsnow 10y agoreplace the idea of "stealing your coins" with "depriving you of your coins" and it makes more sense. the attacker wouldn't be able to deposit the coins in any desired wallet, but would be able to create a fork of the chain that omits the transaction that put the coins in your wallet.
- maxander 10y agoIt pretty explicitly declares who Dai-holders are trusting- those who hold the rarer MKR coins. MKR-holders, presumably, appoint oracles by manipulating the Ethereum DAO that's running the whole business- but they also seem to have control over the rest of the system as well, so its not as though they would have to even be as subtle as manipulating oracles to mess things up. If they want to declare their own farts to be valid collateral to borrow Dai, I don't see a mechanism provided to stop them. Its really easy to see the MKR-holders as just a formalization of the movers of high-finance in the fiat currency world- they would have a similar oversight role and powers as the high-level bankers and governmental financial regulators that control the workings of conventional markets. I suppose the idea is that MKR-holders have it in their best interest to defend a system they've invested in. But if the motivation of the whole digital currency movement is autonomy this seems to defeat the point.
- mst 10y ago51% of MKR holders versus 51% of miners is a different threat model, but "ability to make MKR" and "ability to own mining kit" both seem to depend on financial expenditure, so I wonder if the difference in practice will be that big?
- skybrian 10y agoReplace "blockchain" with "merkel trees" and you get interesting things like certificate transparency, which is certainly "worth your time". Hype aside, public, shared, consistent, irrevocable ledgers are useful for all sorts of things even if you're not attempting to solve the "no trust" problem.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- elzr 10y agoHow can you get an irrevocable ledger without solving the "no trust" problem?
- skybrian 10y agoYou have a lot of people watching the trusted source to make sure that it's append-only and follows the rules for appends. It's a reputation thing; not impossible but it will be detected.
- davrosthedalek 10y agoIsn't reputation trust-by-historical-evidence?
- ajross 10y agoThe same way you know your copy of the kernel tree is authentic.
- kobeya 10y agoBecause my distro signed it? That is pure centralized trust.
- skybrian 10y agoThis is about tracking the source code using git. The specific thing being guaranteed is that they won't rewrite history; if they rebase you (and many others) will detect it. Of course you're still trusting them in other ways.
- kobeya 10y ago> The only necessary assumption is that 51% of the hash power is not conspiring against you. Or s network operator , to be pedantic.
- modeless 10y agoI'm not sure what you intend to mean. If you intend to mean that you must trust your ISP, that is false. ISPs cannot forge blocks due to the proof of work. The worst your ISP can do is a DoS attack delaying block delivery, and that is fairly easy to detect.
- kobeya 10y agoYou can end up on a less work chain because your ISP filtered all connections to the real bitcoin network and you only connected to Sybil nodes. You never hear about the real blocks, just the handful of blocks mined by the attacker.
- modeless 10y agoNo matter what your ISP does you can still verify the proof of work. So your ISP's forged blocks still need the full difficulty PoW that the real chain had at the fork point. Which means that in order to generate a forged block more often than once a day, your ISP will need a significant fraction of the hash power of the whole network, costing probably tens of millions of dollars to buy and operate. Even so the forged blocks will come much, much slower than the real blocks, and that will become noticeable after just a few blocks.
- kobeya 10y agoSignificant? No it only takes a few percent of the hashrate to make a few blocks to successfully Sybil an infrequently connected SPV node, or a full node that has been partitioned off for which you have sufficient time to prepare the alternate chain. You're not outracing the network, just making sure the victim doesn't have a view into the real network.
- irickt 10y agoBitcoin only "solves" one part of trust. The blockchain transaction is perfect but to be of any use there is a corresponding exchange of some service or good or title. Even if the transaction is to exchange currencies from two different chains, trust or a trusted escrow or trusted multiparty consensus is needed. Trust can only be eliminated in narrow circumstances involving low-risk transactions or in environments with some extrinsic enforcing mechanism. For a cautionary tale see https://aeon.co/essays/why-the-hidden-internet-can-t-be-a-libertarian-paradise https://aeon.co/essays/why-the-hidden-internet-can-t-be-a-li...