Reports like this are meaningless, because they make up arbitrary categories, and then assign them arbitrary weights. This one is especially bad because it has

Reports like this are meaningless, because they make up arbitrary categories, and then assign them arbitrary weights. This one is especially bad because it has categories that are almost impossible to judge objectively, like "Strategy". Reminds me of San Francisco's report on the Central Subway. They created eight categories, equally weighted, of which one was "cost". Of course, everything in construction trades off against cost. So the most expensive option always came out ahead, because it "gained" in seven categories but "lost" in one.