4 ms·
For any individual case, you don't lose by having the option available. But more options doesn't always lead to better outcomes, see the Prisoners' Dilemma for
by mikeash 10y ago
For any individual case, you don't lose by having the option available. But more options doesn't always lead to better outcomes, see the Prisoners' Dilemma for the classic example.
In this situation, having lots of plea deals predisposes the system to increase sentences for cases which go to trial, in order to get more plea deals. If every single person gets the harsher "trial" punishment, then there will be pressure to make the punishment fit the crime. When only 6% of people get that one, and 94% get a lighter sentence due to a plea deal, the "trial" punishment can be way worse.
For a really obvious and somewhat contrived example of how more options isn't necessarily a good thing, imagine if you could get a discount on your taxes if you agreed never to criticize the government. You don't have to take that choice, and you lose nothing by having it available, but I think most of us would see that program as a really bad thing.
- sametmax 10y ago> In this situation, having lots of plea deals predisposes the system to increase sentences for cases which go to trial, in order to get more plea deals. ... > if you could get a discount on your taxes if you agreed never to criticize the government. Ah ok. The problem is not the deal itself, but that the system's goal then lead to utilize the deal in negative ways.
- mikeash 10y agoI think that's right. A plea deal in any given case may be OK, but when they're a pervasive part of the system they start to look like a punishment for insisting on a trial.