8 ms·
> There is a worrying trend of treating staff as equally capable but untrusted cogs in a wheel, and metricising performance. That's a great way of summing up w
by wpietri 10y ago
> There is a worrying trend of treating staff as equally capable but untrusted cogs in a wheel, and metricising performance.
That's a great way of summing up what I've heard called "managerialism".
There's a theory behind, e.g., the MBA that a competent manager can manage anything. That what one manages makes no difference as long as you're a real manager. One of the corollaries of that theory is that all one has to do is find the right short-term metrics and make them go up and to the right.
I don't think this theory makes much sense when you examine it. But it's excellent at justifying a caste system, one where all workers are controlled by wise managers, and where there's a stable hierarchy of executives above that. I note that the hierarchy established is basically equivalent to those of feudalism. It also has the handy property of justifying high compensation for managers and executives; since workers are cogs and higher-ups do the important thinking, all gains should flow upward.
There are other ways of organizing things, of course. But this has become such the default that people have a hard time even imagining alternatives.
- nickpinkston 10y agoI tend to find people with your view have never been an executive managing the managers, or even a manager. When you are (like myself) then you see that good managers / leadership (including tech team leads, etc.) really do make a massive difference in performance with the same people. Things like metrics, values, and re-orgs might seem like Dilbert-esque corporate speak (a view I used to share), but they're incredibly important once you're trying to get a bunch of people to do something with excellence and speed.
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agoI tend to find people with your view have never been a cog, or even a worker. When you are (like myself) then you see that good managers / leadership (including tech team leads, etc.) really do nothing at all, and only worry about making a massive difference in performance with the executive managers. Things like metrics, values, and re-orgs might seem like Dilbert-esque corporate speak (a view I used to share), but they're incredibly important once you're trying to believe you're getting a bunch of people to do something with excellence and speed. you're all idiots.
- maxxxxx 10y agoSure there are plenty of managers who do a good job but there are also plenty of useless managers who do more harm than good. Especially in complex jobs like academia or software engineering it's pretty easy to make up some metrics that look good but in reality do more harm than good. And somehow the sample people that created this system are then paid to fix it.
- dleslie 10y agoThis thread reads like an argument on the merits of standardized testing in school. I suppose if you value employees who are trained by rote and operate in a manner reflecting that training...
- kylebenzle 10y agoI think this argument against "rote learning" is basically defunct. The bottom line is unless we want to live socialistalically and force roles on children like in Germany we need to teach ALL the stuff to ALL the children, and the only way to do that is to blast through the material with tons of homework, rote learning, after school tutoring, standard testing, etc. So it is a choice we make, tell everyone what to do from an early age and allow them to focus, or try and teach all the things to everyone, using standard testing to make sure everyone is at least keeping their head above water. </best_post_ever>
- goatlover 10y agoSarcasm? I hope.
- steve_g 10y agoI am also a manager of managers. I agree 100% that managers/leadership makes a big difference in performance. But I don't see the difference being systems and metrics. I see it much more as interpersonal relationships, respect, and caring about the people that work for you. The manager's competence in the domain itself is also important. Selecting the right person for the job is also vital, but you are specifically addressing different performance by the same team with a different manager.
- kylebenzle 10y agoI manage manager managers. I agree 200% the managers make a big difference in performance and we need more of them. </clever_sarcasm>
- iamatworknow 10y agoThat's great, but I'd love to hear what your manager says about your recent performance. Is there any way I can sit down with him or her and maybe come up with a game plan of how we can improve their performance in helping you meet your managerial goals?
- chadcmulligan 10y ago> The manager's competence in the domain itself is also important. Correct me if I'm wrong but this is a minority view in management circles
- sevensor 10y agoFrom ground level, though, it's really easy to see the dysfunctional cultures growing up around metrics. At the factory where I used to work, we'd zig-zag from metric to metric. Yield one quarter, Cpk the next, scrap rate the quarter after that. Special cross-departmental teams to manage the metric. Regardless of which metric was chosen, people would do really dumb things to try to meet it. If scrap rate was the metric, we'd send terrible material through the line to keep the scrap rate low. If yield was the metric, we'd scrap anything that was even slightly abnormal. Cpk was the worst (or maybe the best), because we just adjusted our spec limits until Cpk was acceptable. The better managers translated the quantitative metrics into qualitative guidance for their teams. The worse managers provided no such buffer and instead made their teams achieve metrics by any means necessary.
- rattray 10y ago> The better managers translated the quantitative metrics into qualitative guidance for their teams. The worse managers provided no such buffer and instead made their teams achieve metrics by any means necessary. This seems like a key insight. Metrics are key to good management – but metrics are for the managers, not for the teams. Managers that pass metrics directly down to their teams as goals aren't doing their jobs; they're trying to make their team do their job. Maybe. Thoughts?
- codys 10y ago> Metrics are key to good management This doesn't follow from the GP's comment. All we know from that comment is that Metrics + some managers = bad.
- sqeaky 10y agoParachutes are key to survival when jumping from airplanes. Doesn't mean they always work or are always used correctly. Maybe this is a matter of necessary but not sufficient? I have no strong opinion, I am just pointing at a grey area.
- willhslade 10y ago
- tensor 10y agoI would be more inclined to believe this if the pro-manager view didn't come from the managers the vast majority of the time. It seems too convenient and self-service. Of course managers want to think they make a massive difference. Certainly some aspects can: keeping politics away from your group so that they can work, focusing work tasks by eliminating extraneous ones, advocating for people in the company. However, once you start getting into things like values and metrics it starts becoming a lot more grey. On the one hand metrics are a great idea, a tiny step towards making management more science driven. But on the other, the metrics so often used are such a poor and overly simple representation of a very complex system that it's often hard to see how they provide an accurate view of any given work place. Goals and values are often completely lame. We value hard work! Your goal is to do your job! Somehow managers must know that they are ridiculed for this. After all entire movies are made doing so. Yet they still seem to want to believe this rhetoric works.
- WalterBright 10y agoSometimes companies are forced into doing metrics. If you need to fire someone for poor performance, in order to avoid a lawsuit, you'll need to document it, and that requires metrics. The same goes for lawsuits over who gets paid how much. As long as there are regulations and lawsuits over this sort of stuff, there will be metrics.
- xapata 10y agoI believe "The Zen of Python" is one of the reasons for Python's success. I also believe that most "goals and values" that CEOs obsess over are bogus, but there's a kernel of truth that setting the philosophy for the company has a subtle, but strong effect. Your skepticism based on who's speaking is warranted. After all, you shouldn't ask your barber if you need a haircut. Yet, maybe your hair stylist has the most expertise. Should you trust your dentist on how often you should get your teeth cleaned?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- metaphorm 10y agoI tend to find that people with your view have a psychological and material necessity to believe the mythology. "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it." -Upton Sinclair
- hasbroslasher 10y agoThis makes two big assumptions that can't be overlooked: 1. People can't self-manage (to some degree) 2. Performance is the end goal of management I think both of these are wrong, or at least unfounded. I work in a more-or-less self-managed environment, and performance is actually pretty good. I get to pursue about 50% of my work independently and the other half is either collaborative and in line with a coworker's needs, or is one of those "must-dos". I don't see a possible world where I'd get more work done over the average day if there were artificial metrics like "time spent at desk", "lines of code written" or "number of tasks completed" dangled over my head - I'd probably just fuck off more and come up with clever schemes to break the game. This problem can be seen in academia as well - give a bunch of smart people a matrix of rules and yell "GO!". Watch them optimize. I'd also argue that if it's only performance you're looking for, you're both ethically and intellectually off base. Good managers do increase performance/productivity - bad managers do not. But to assume that, as with teachers, academics, or software engineers, you can measure and reward behaviors without causing adverse affects on your workplace then you're dreaming. My manager is good because he backs off when needed, leaving me and a coworker to argue about an implementation design. My manager is good because he sets up an area of focus and says "ideas, go!". My manager is good because he will let people take a week or month to pursue a new solution that he personally doesn't understand, but trusts them to solve it aptly. My manager is not good because his team excels in certain metrics - his team excels in certain metrics because he is good. And last, my manager is good because productivity is not the end goal - employee happiness is. Happy employees do good work, and more importantly, they're happy for their own sake, which is much better than being surrounded by burnt out metric junkies. So maybe my takeaway is that if we're going to do any kind of metric gathering it should probably be sub-perceptible and not be treated as a golden calf. If my CEO wants to devise a clever way of using me as a science experiment in pursuit of better management practices then I encourage that. But to tell people "here's what we're tracking now go off and do good work instead of that" is really fraught with problems.
- mixmastamyk 10y agoTrue, to borrow the metaphor there are 10x as well as 1x and -1x managers. The problem however, is that they all tend to be absurdly compensated whereas logic would support paying only the first group in that manner.
- tomdz 10y agoIt seems like you're talking from a viewpoint that doesn't understand the point of the article. There is no manager I've ever encountered in a university who has been of any value to the academics they've managed or produced any increase in productivity or excellence with their ridiculous metrics.
- s73ver 10y agoIf this is the case, then why are so many bad managers still managing?
- wpietri 10y agoHello! I have been both, as well as a founder. I also have been consulting on organizational process since before you started high school, so maybe lay off the condescension a bit. I'm not saying good management is unnecessary. I'm saying that managerialism is basically the opposite of good management. Metrics can be valuable if used very carefully. But they so rarely are, because a lot of the drive for metrics is really is in service of a cultivated shallowness. Simple metrics allow somebody to swoop in, jerk some levers, provide apparent gain, and then jet off to something else, never mind the consequences.
- dasmoth 10y agoThings like metrics, values, and re-orgs might seem like Dilbert-esque corporate speak (a view I used to share), but they're incredibly important once you're trying to get a bunch of people to do something with excellence and speed. The need for this sometimes seems to be, itself, an aspect of managerialism. Sure, if you're going to the moon on a tight timescale you probably do need to marshal a larger number of people than can usefully self-organise in the available time. But most projects are much smaller scale. A feature of managerialialist organisations is that there's rarely any consideration of the possibility that a give project could be done by a self-organised group (let alone a single smart individual). Everything starts with managers assigning a "team", which then inevitably ends up requiring management.
- anigbrowl 10y agoYeah, but it makes a huge difference whether the managers have domain knowledge or are just dictating based on statistics. In the latter case, their expectations will be unrealistic and they won't be able to process the input from below effectively because they've already agreed to implement imperatives from above. Professional managers can of course learn about different jobs, but there is a massive and largely unpleasant difference between being manged by someone who's been promoted for their domain competence and someone who has been parachuted in because of their expertise in ordering people about. Since it's virtually impossible for junior workers to fire a manager they dislike then what appears to be efficiency is often achieved through exploitation. To know this and perpetuate that pattern is to disavow moral agency, converting what is nominally a cooperative enterprise into a zero-sum game.
- Ultimatt 10y agoI can almost guarantee the managers improved nothing other than reporting of work. Before they arrived everyone was too busy doing it to tell execs what was happening. If anything I bet tangible productivity is reduced with the introduction of management structure and more detailed reports.
- arjie 10y agoThis may not be true. Let's take the case of Stephen Smale. An incredibly smart man who would go on to win a Fields Medal. And yet, without someone providing the structure within which to work and without an external motivation, a mildly mediocre graduate student. All the credit for his work goes to him, of course. But one can easily imagine him completely flaming out with a different department head and advisor. It is precisely because people are not cogs that managers can either be a force multiplier or an unmitigated disaster. EDIT: on rereading, that guy isn't saying all management is like this but that his hypothesis explains certain managers. All right. That makes my comment a non-sequitur.
- eastWestMath 10y agoBut that was the result were two academics recognizing a diamond in the rough. An MBA-type concerned with metrics would never even have accepted him for graduate studies.
- arjie 10y agoThat's fair. I'll accept my punishment.
- ygaf 10y agoSome of the most interesting posts happen by accident.
- metaphorm 10y ago> But it's excellent at justifying a caste system exactly. the managerial class claims dominion over the rest of us, and then swiftly constructs a rigid social system that locks in their position on top of it. this necessarily includes promulgation of unfounded myths and beliefs taken on faith to support the ossification of the system.
- crdoconnor 10y ago>promulgation of unfounded myths and beliefs taken on faith to support the ossification of the system. a.k.a. neoliberal economics
- jdmichal 10y agoFurther reading: The Gervais Principle https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-or-the-office-according-to-the-office/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-... My friend and I have internally renamed the roles "producers", "regulators", and "harvesters" in an attempt to remove the negative connotations. Feel free to use that in your own discussions also.
- lgas 10y agoWhat do you hope to achieve by removing the negative connotations? Getting people to buy into the negative ideas without realizing they are negative?
- Qwertious 10y agoThe ideas can be negative, yet still exaggeratedly negative due to a negative name.. Renaming to a less aggressive phrasing will make them easier to buy into and does not require attempting to distort reality.
- Karrot_Kream 10y ago> I don't think this theory makes much sense when you examine it. But it's excellent at justifying a caste system, one where all workers are controlled by wise managers, and where there's a stable hierarchy of executives above that. I note that the hierarchy established is basically equivalent to those of feudalism. It also has the handy property of justifying high compensation for managers and executives; since workers are cogs and higher-ups do the important thinking, all gains should flow upward. Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater. I agree that metricising performance is only as good as your metrics, and in my personal opinion, metricising knowledge work is a fool's errand (too many variables to accurately capture performance). That is _separate_ from having managers though. Managers can often triage work effectively, help engineers unblock their work, help identify people in the org that contain the domain knowledge necessary to help one of their direct reports, etc etc. I think the whole urge to track velocity and points and stupid things like that to be absolutely dumb, though. Also I'm an IC and am coming up to the point in my career where I have to figure out a way to not be pushed into management.
- wpietri 10y agoI'm not opposed to managers. I am one, after all. But I don't think "management" is a universal skill. I think somebody who manages developers should probably be a developer. I think somebody who manages doctors should be a doctor. And I think there's a lot of merit in non-hierarchical systems, like the way doctors and lawyers are mainly accountable to professional organizations. I agree that metricising knowledge work is a mistake. But I think it's also true for other kinds of work. In colleges I worked in a factory and there was no end of trouble that came from managing via metrics.
- iamacynic 10y ago> I think somebody who manages doctors should be a doctor. i could be wrong, but i believe in 'real' professions like medicine and law, there's some kind of board/bar rule that prohibits being managed by someone who never had the actual job they're managing. any one know if that's accurate?
- chadcmulligan 10y agoYes, I was going to say follow the money - the administrators get paid well, and yet by the same logic applied to the academics, the administrators should be paid a pittance, because there's no shortage of administrators. They'd probably argue that you have to pay well for a good administrator. How do you measure a good administrator? By how much money they save. So the less the academics are paid, the more the administrators save and so therefore the more they are paid - and we're there. It used to be academics took turns at administrating for a couple of years, this was before the rise of the professional manager, and they insinuated themselves everywhere.