3 ms·
Really though, what is there in an university that justifies a dedicated team of managers? One person in power (say, the dean) is enough to make sure grants are
by pdimitar 10y ago
Really though, what is there in an university that justifies a dedicated team of managers? One person in power (say, the dean) is enough to make sure grants are coming on time, and negotiate those beforehand. They need one accountant to make sure salaries, taxes etc. are in the legal bounds and people receive what they were promised. Honest question: what else is needed?
Most of the managerial work I've witnessed in an university is easily doable by several slightly complex Excel spreadsheets. It just requires people to be diligent and not overlook the unquestionable need for accountability and visibility.
As an additional question -- what exactly is there to "run" in an university?
- dagw 10y agoReally though, what is there in an university that justifies a dedicated team of managers? The same thing there is in any company with several thousand employees (let's not even start to consider the administrative hassle of dealing with several thousand students). Probably a lot more actually, since very few companies are doing research in oriental languages, nano technology, abstract algebra and contemporary music at the same time.
- pdimitar 10y agoYou might be right, but my girlfriend currently is a "leader" of her group in the university -- she's responsible to bring the student's "grade books" (sorry, my English fails me here) to the proper administration, she creates polls for the freely choosable disciplines, makes calendar events for the occasional meets etc. Takes her 2-3 hours a week and is FAR more efficient than the awfully rigid systems I come from, 15 years ago. Self-organization is a powerful phenomena. It can't solve everything for sure, but a good balance between it plus a smaller bureaucracy has in my eyes shown a strong promise for the future.
- tnecniv 10y agoNot to mention some of these places have billion dollar annual budgets.
- BeetleB 10y ago>Really though, what is there in an university that justifies a dedicated team of managers? Conflict resolution, as one example. Plenty of faculty members ready to screw their students. If you spend enough time there, it is really scary how much power professors have to screw their students over.
- pdimitar 10y agoThat's a fair point -- provided the managers aren't in the same bed with the professors.
- Fomite 10y agoGiven I know someone who works rather hard, full time, on negotiating grants and other contracts and they're far from the Dean level, I'd suggest you're off from the amount of work required to run and administer a university by a pretty hefty margin.
- pdimitar 10y agoWell, I don't mind being wrong on that one, it's mostly side observations plus some intuition, and we know these aren't exactly objective criteria. That being said, in your example maybe the dean simply couldn't be bothered? :P
- tnecniv 10y agoIt's more likely that the dean is just not the person who should be writing the grant proposal. Professors whose groups are actively working in the area the grant is for will write a much better proposal. It's also expected that as a professor you are -- to a significant degree -- capable of funding your group.
- Fomite 10y agoI'm not even talking about grant writing. I'm talking about things like negotiating licensing agreements for private industry, contract negotiation to make sure publication and graduate students are protected, etc.
- Fomite 10y agoMore that's a full time job all it's own, and is only one aspect of grant administration. Unless the Dean is some sort of omniscient AI, that's not going to work out well.